Lesson 2 of 12 · 16 min
The benefits and costs of trade
Explain the advantages and disadvantages of international trade, and how trade affects sustainable economic growth, internal stability and external stability and the policies that pursue them.
What you will be able to do
- Explain the main advantages of international trade for consumers, producers and the economy.
- Explain the main disadvantages, including structural change and exposure to shocks.
- Define sustainable economic growth, internal stability and external stability.
- Explain how trade can help or hinder each of those objectives, and how policy responds.
Opening an economy to trade creates winners and losers. Shoppers pay less for imported goods and exporters reach markets of billions of people, but firms that compete with imports can close, and an economy that sells a lot to one buyer is exposed when that buyer changes its mind. A good answer on trade weighs both sides and says who is affected.
Opening a market to imports at the world price : consumers buy more at a lower price, domestic producers sell less, and imports fill the gap.
The diagram shows the trade-off in one market. Without trade, price and quantity are set where domestic demand meets domestic supply. With free trade, the good sells at the lower world price: consumers gain (they buy more for less), domestic producers lose (they sell less), and the gain to consumers is larger than the loss to producers. That surplus of gains over losses is the case for trade in a single picture.
| Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|
| Specialisation and efficiency. Countries produce what they make at the lowest opportunity cost, so world output rises (allocative efficiency). | Structural change. Import-competing industries shrink and workers lose jobs; Australian car manufacturing ended when Ford (2016) and Toyota and Holden (2017) closed their plants. |
| Economies of scale. Selling to the world lets firms produce at lower average cost than a home market of about 27 million people would allow. | Exposure to external shocks. A recession or a change in policy in a major partner cuts export income, as China's duties on Australian barley (2020 to 2023) and wine (2020 to 2024) did. |
| Lower prices and more choice for consumers and for firms buying inputs and equipment. | Dependence on a few commodities and markets. Volatile commodity prices make export incomes, the dollar and tax revenue swing. |
| Competition and innovation. Facing world rivals pushes firms to cut costs and adopt new technology (dynamic efficiency). | Uneven costs between regions. Losses are concentrated in the towns and regions where the affected industries are, while gains are spread thinly. |
| Jobs and income in export industries, and the foreign exchange to pay for imports. | Environmental costs of producing for export (land clearing, emissions) and of transport; supply chains can break, as during the COVID-19 pandemic. |
| Access to capital and ideas. Foreign investment and imported technology lift productivity. | Infant and strategic industries may struggle to start, or be lost, without protection. |
Which of these are advantages of international trade for Australia? Select all that apply.
Trade and the economy's objectives. Governments judge the economy against a few broad objectives, and the syllabus asks you to explain how trade affects three of them.
Definition
Three objectives trade affects
Sustainable economic growth is growth in real GDP that can be kept up over time without rising inflation, an unsustainable external position, or damage to the environment that leaves future generations worse off.
Internal stability is stability inside the economy: low and stable inflation (the RBA targets 2–3%) and full employment.
External stability is a sustainable position with the rest of the world: a current account balance and foreign debt that can be financed and serviced without a crisis, and a currency without disorderly swings.
| Objective | Trade can help | Trade can hinder |
|---|---|---|
| Sustainable economic growth | Specialisation, scale and competition raise productivity and the economy's capacity to produce. | Growth that rests on depleting resources, or on one commodity's price, may not last. |
| Internal stability | Cheap imports and import competition hold down prices; export industries create jobs. | A collapse in export demand raises unemployment in trade-exposed industries; a falling dollar raises import prices and inflation. |
| External stability | Strong export earnings narrow the current account deficit. | Volatile commodity prices swing the trade balance and the dollar; persistent deficits add to foreign debt. |
Worked example
Explain how trade liberalisation affects internal stability
Explain how a large cut in Australia's tariffs on imported manufactured goods could affect internal stability in the short run and the long run.
Step 1: Define internal stability
Internal stability means low and stable inflation and full employment.
Step 2: Effect on inflation
Lower tariffs cut the price of imports to Australian buyers, and import competition limits the prices domestic firms can charge. The price level grows more slowly: a gain for price stability.
Step 3: Short-run effect on employment
Import-competing manufacturers lose sales to cheaper imports. Some cut jobs or close, raising structural unemployment, concentrated in the regions where those factories are.
The workers' skills and locations may not match the jobs being created elsewhere, so they can stay unemployed for some time.
Step 4: Long-run effect on employment
Resources move to industries where Australia has a comparative advantage. Lower input costs help other firms expand, and real incomes rise as prices fall, creating jobs elsewhere. With retraining and time, unemployment falls back.
Step 5: Weigh the two
Liberalisation helps price stability straight away; its effect on employment is negative at first and positive later, so the short-run cost depends on how fast workers can move into new jobs.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Cheaper imports and stronger competition lower inflation, supporting price stability. In the short run, job losses in import-competing manufacturing raise structural unemployment; in the long run resources move to more efficient industries and employment recovers, so the net effect on internal stability depends on how quickly workers adjust.
Method
Define the objective.
Trace the effect on each part of it (inflation, employment).
Separate short-run costs from long-run gains and weigh them.
Watch out for
Writing only about the trade balance. Internal stability is about inflation and unemployment.
Treating all the unemployment as permanent. The adjustment is what structural adjustment policy is for.
Trade shapes economic policy. Because trade affects these objectives, governments respond to it:
- Trade policy: negotiating free trade agreements to open markets and spread exports across more partners.
- Structural adjustment: retraining and assistance for workers and regions when an industry shrinks, as when the car plants closed.
- Fiscal policy: a commodity boom lifts company tax revenue, and a bust cuts it, so budgets rise and fall with world prices.
- Monetary policy: the RBA watches the exchange rate and the terms of trade when it sets the cash rate, because both affect inflation and growth.
Classify each development as a threat mainly to internal stability or mainly to external stability.
Common mistake
One-sided answers
"Trade is good because prices are lower" earns little. Name who gains and who loses (consumers, exporters, import-competing workers, regions), explain the mechanism, and weigh them. The syllabus verb is often explain or evaluate, and both need the other side.
Summary
Advantages: specialisation and efficiency, economies of scale, lower prices and more choice, competition and innovation, export jobs and income, access to capital and ideas.
Disadvantages: structural change and job losses in import-competing industries, exposure to external shocks, dependence on a few commodities and markets, uneven regional costs, environmental and supply-chain risks.
Sustainable growth, internal stability (low inflation, full employment) and external stability (a sustainable current account and foreign debt) are all affected by trade.
Governments respond with trade agreements, structural adjustment, and fiscal and monetary policy that take the trade cycle into account.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.