Lesson 9 of 12 · 19 min
Exchange rate systems, shocks and policy
Compare fixed, floating and managed exchange rates, explain how a floating dollar insulates the economy from external shocks, the effects of a movement on different groups, and evaluate policy responses with criteria.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish fixed, floating and managed exchange rates, and revaluation and devaluation from appreciation and depreciation.
- Explain how a floating exchange rate insulates the Australian economy from external shocks.
- Explain the effects of an appreciation or a depreciation on exporters, importers, consumers, inflation and growth.
- Evaluate government policy responses to exchange rate movements and changing trade relationships using criteria.
Australia has not always let the market set its dollar. For most of the twentieth century the government fixed it, first to the British pound and then to the US dollar. Floating it on 12 December 1983 was one of the biggest economic reforms in Australia's history, and the reason is what a floating rate does when the rest of the world changes.
| System | How the rate is set | How it is held | Examples |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed (pegged) | The government or central bank sets the rate against another currency or a basket. | The central bank buys its own currency with foreign reserves when there is excess supply, and sells it when there is excess demand. | Hong Kong dollar, held to the US dollar since 1983; Australia before November 1976 |
| Floating | Demand and supply in the foreign exchange market. | No target; the central bank may step in only when the market is disorderly. | Australian dollar since 12 December 1983; US dollar, yen |
| Managed (managed float, crawling peg) | The market, within limits the central bank sets, or a peg adjusted in small regular steps. | Intervention to keep the rate in its band or on its path. | Chinese yuan, managed against a basket; Australia's crawling peg, 1976 to 1983 |
Definition
Revaluation and devaluation
Under a fixed rate the market cannot move the currency; only a decision can. A revaluation is a decision to raise the fixed rate; a devaluation is a decision to lower it. Australia's dollar was revalued and pegged to the US dollar in December 1971, devalued by 12% and pegged to a trade-weighted basket in September 1974, and devalued by 17.5% in November 1976, when a crawling peg began (RBA). A floating currency appreciates or depreciates instead.
Illustrative market. Switch to floating to see the rate move instead.
Match each event to the term that describes it.
The floating rate as a shock absorber. Australia's exports are dominated by commodities whose world prices swing widely. Suppose iron ore and coal prices fall sharply because China's economy slows. Under a fixed rate, Australian miners earn the full fall in Australian dollars: incomes, profits, tax revenue and jobs fall with it, and the whole adjustment lands on the domestic economy. Under a floating rate, the fall in export earnings cuts the demand for AUD, so the dollar depreciates. Each US dollar of export revenue is now worth more Australian dollars, so miners' A$ income falls by less, while other exporters and import-competing firms become more competitive. The exchange rate takes part of the shock.
Illustrative figures: an exporter's A$ income under a fixed and a floating rate when world prices fall 30%.
Worked example
How a floating dollar cushions a fall in export prices
A coal exporter sells 1 million tonnes a year at US$200 a tonne, with A$1 = US$0.70 (illustrative). The world price falls to US$140 a tonne.
(a) Calculate the exporter's A$ revenue before and after the fall if the exchange rate is fixed at US$0.70. (b) Under a floating rate, the dollar depreciates to US$0.60. Calculate the A$ revenue after the fall. (c) Explain what the comparison shows about a floating exchange rate.
Step 1: Revenue before
US$ revenue million. In A$: million.
Step 2: After, fixed rate
US$ revenue million. In A$: million, a fall of .
Step 3: After, floating rate
In A$: million, a fall of .
Step 4: Explain
Under the fixed rate the exporter's A$ income falls by the full 30%. Under the float, lower export earnings reduce the demand for AUD, the dollar depreciates, and each US dollar converts to more A$, so A$ income falls by only 18.33%. The exchange rate absorbs part of the shock.
This is the sense in which a floating rate insulates the economy: the adjustment is shared between the currency and domestic incomes, instead of falling wholly on incomes, output and jobs.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) A$285.71 million before; A$200 million after (−30%). (b) A$233.33 million (−18.33%). (c) The depreciation that follows the fall in export prices offsets part of it, so a floating rate cushions export incomes and the wider economy from external shocks.
Method
Convert foreign-currency revenue to A$ by dividing by the rate.
Compare percentage changes under each system.
Link the difference to the depreciation that a fall in demand for AUD causes.
Watch out for
Multiplying by the rate instead of dividing when converting US$ to A$.
Saying the float removes the shock: it cushions it.
The same works in reverse in a boom: rising commodity prices push the dollar up, which cools the boom by making other exports dearer and imports cheaper, and helps hold down inflation. A floating rate also frees the RBA to set interest rates for Australian conditions, because it does not have to use them (or its reserves) to defend a peg.
The cost is volatility: exporters and importers face uncertain prices, which they manage by hedging, and an appreciation driven by a boom in one sector squeezes others (in the mining boom of the early 2010s, manufacturing, tourism and education all felt the high dollar).
| Group | Appreciation | Depreciation |
|---|---|---|
| Exporters | Lose: their goods cost foreigners more, and foreign-currency revenue converts to fewer A$ | Gain: more competitive, and each US$ earned is worth more A$ |
| Importers and consumers of imports | Gain: imports cost fewer A$ | Lose: imports dearer in A$ |
| Import-competing producers | Lose: imports become cheaper than their goods | Gain: imports become dearer |
| Australians travelling abroad | Gain: A$ buys more overseas | Lose: travel overseas costs more |
| Tourism and education exporters | Lose: Australia is dearer for visitors and students | Gain: Australia is cheaper for them |
| Inflation (internal stability) | Falls: cheaper imports and competition | Rises: dearer imports feed into the CPI |
| Economic growth | Slower, as net exports fall | Faster, as net exports rise (over time) |
The Australian dollar depreciates by 10% against the US dollar. Who is most likely to be better off? Select all that apply.
Policy responses. Governments and the RBA respond both to exchange rate movements and to changes in trade relationships:
- Monetary policy. The RBA considers the dollar when it sets the cash rate: a depreciation that pushes inflation up may call for higher rates; a very high dollar that slows growth may allow lower ones.
- Intervention. The RBA has bought or sold AUD in disorderly markets, such as late 2008, but does not target a level.
- Market diversification and trade agreements. When China imposed duties on Australian barley (May 2020) and wine (deposits from November 2020, duties from March 2021), the Government took both disputes to the World Trade Organization and helped exporters find other markets, while new agreements came into force with India (29 December 2022) and the United Kingdom (31 May 2023). China removed the barley duties on 5 August 2023 and the wine duties on 29 March 2024.
- Industry assistance and structural adjustment. Subsidies, tariffs or retraining for trade-exposed industries hurt by a high dollar or a lost market.
Key idea
Criteria for evaluating a policy response
The syllabus names the criteria. Choose one (or two) and judge the response against it:
- Employment in trade-exposed industries: does it protect or create jobs in exporting and import-competing industries, and at what cost elsewhere?
- Economic growth, nationally or in a state or region: does it raise output, and where?
- Efficiency: allocative (are resources moving to their most valued use, or being held in low-value industries?) and dynamic (does it encourage innovation and productivity over time?).
- Importation of goods and services: what happens to the price, range and supply of imports for consumers and firms?
Worked example
Evaluate responses to a lost export market
In 2020 China imposed duties of 80.5% on Australian barley, which the Australian Government said blocked almost $1 billion a year of sales (Minister for Foreign Affairs, 4 August 2023). Two responses were possible: (A) pay ongoing subsidies to barley growers to make up their lost income, or (B) challenge the duties at the World Trade Organization while helping exporters find other markets.
Evaluate which response better served the Australian economy, using the criterion of efficiency.
Step 1: Define the criterion
Allocative efficiency: resources go to their most valued uses. Dynamic efficiency: firms innovate and adapt over time.
Step 2: Analyse response A
Ongoing subsidies keep growers producing for a market that no longer pays, at taxpayers' expense. They protect incomes and jobs in grain regions in the short run but blunt the price signal to switch crops or buyers: low allocative efficiency, and they reduce the pressure to adapt (dynamic efficiency).
Step 3: Analyse response B
Diversification moves barley to the buyers who value it most (Saudi Arabia, Japan, South-East Asia), at some cost in lower prices at first. It keeps resources responding to world prices and builds new market relationships: higher allocative and dynamic efficiency. The WTO case keeps pressure on the trading partner without distorting Australian production.
Step 4: Use the outcome as evidence
China removed the duties from 5 August 2023 after Australia paused its WTO case (April 2023) in return for an expedited review by China; in the meantime growers had sold much of their crop to other markets.
Step 5: Decide
Against the efficiency criterion, response B was better: it let prices guide resources and made the industry less dependent on one buyer, while subsidies would have locked resources into a closed market. A limit: diversified markets may pay lower prices, and the adjustment costs fall on growers.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Response B better served the economy on efficiency grounds: diversification and a WTO challenge kept barley flowing to the buyers who valued it most and reduced dependence on one market (allocative and dynamic efficiency), whereas ongoing subsidies would have held resources in a market that had closed, at taxpayers' cost. The duties were removed from 5 August 2023.
Method
Define the criterion precisely.
Analyse each option against it, with evidence.
Weigh the options from more than one perspective and make a decision.
State a limit or condition on the decision.
Watch out for
Deciding without a criterion, or naming one and never applying it.
Considering only one perspective (growers) and not taxpayers, consumers or the wider economy.
Common mistake
Assuming every depreciation is good for the economy
A depreciation helps exporters, but it raises import prices and inflation, makes foreign holidays and imported equipment dearer, and its benefits to the trade balance take time as buyers adjust. Evaluate it from more than one perspective before you judge it.
Exam tip
Evaluating a policy
State the criterion first, then apply it with evidence and consider at least two perspectives (a mining region and a manufacturing city, exporters and consumers), and finish with a decision: "Against the criterion of dynamic efficiency, diversifying into new markets was the better response, because…"
Summary
Fixed rates are set by decision (revaluation, devaluation) and held with reserves; floating rates are set by the market (appreciation, depreciation); managed rates combine the two.
A floating dollar absorbs external shocks: it falls when export prices fall, cushioning export incomes and supporting other trade-exposed industries, and rises in a boom.
An appreciation helps importers, consumers and travellers and lowers inflation; a depreciation helps exporters and import-competing firms and raises inflation.
Policy responses (monetary policy, intervention, trade agreements and diversification, assistance) are judged against criteria: trade-exposed employment, growth, efficiency and imports.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.