Lesson 5 of 12 · 14 min
Competitive advantage and Porter's diamond
Explain Michael Porter's competitive advantage and his diamond, how a nation builds an advantage rather than inheriting it, and the contemporary relevance of all three trade theories.
What you will be able to do
- Explain competitive advantage (Michael Porter) and how it differs from comparative advantage.
- Describe the four determinants of Porter's diamond and the roles of government and chance.
- Apply the diamond to an Australian industry.
- Evaluate the contemporary relevance of absolute, comparative and competitive advantage.
Ricardo explains why Australia exports iron ore: it has rich deposits and few people, so ore costs it little to produce. But why do Switzerland, with no cocoa, export chocolate, and Japan, with little iron ore, export cars? Factor endowments cannot explain an advantage in goods a country has none of the raw materials for.
In The Competitive Advantage of Nations (1990), Michael Porter argued that the most valuable advantages are created, not inherited: built by firms, workers, universities and governments, and sustained by innovation.
Definition
Competitive advantage
A nation's industry has a competitive advantage when its firms can outperform foreign rivals, by lower cost or by better, differentiated products, because of conditions the nation has built: skills, research, technology, clusters of supporting firms, demanding customers and strong rivalry.
| Determinant | What it means | What strengthens it |
|---|---|---|
| Factor conditions | The inputs an industry uses. Porter separates basic factors (natural resources, climate, unskilled labour), which are inherited, from advanced factors (specialised skills, research, infrastructure), which are created. | Investment in education, training, research and infrastructure. |
| Demand conditions | The size and sophistication of the home market. | Demanding local buyers who push firms to improve before they compete abroad. |
| Related and supporting industries | Competitive suppliers and related firms nearby: a cluster. | Specialised suppliers, service firms and research bodies in one region sharing ideas and workers. |
| Firm strategy, structure and rivalry | How firms are run and how hard they compete at home. | Strong domestic rivalry that forces innovation. |
| Government | Influences all four corners: education, regulation, competition policy, research funding. | Policy that builds advanced factors and keeps markets competitive. |
| Chance | Events outside anyone's control: inventions, wars, shifts in world demand, exchange rates. | Industries already strong can take advantage of them. |
Australian wine. Each card is shown afterwards as endowed (inherited) or built.
Australia's mining equipment, technology and services (METS) firms sell software, automation and engineering to mines around the world. Match each source of their advantage to the part of Porter's diamond it belongs to.
Worked example
Apply Porter's diamond to international education
International education is one of Australia's largest services exports. Use Porter's diamond to explain how Australia built a competitive advantage in it, and identify one part of the advantage that is endowed rather than built.
Step 1: Factor conditions
Advanced factors: highly qualified academics, research capacity and accredited universities and TAFEs, built over decades by public and private investment. English as the language of instruction is an inherited (basic) factor.
Step 2: Demand conditions
Australian students and employers demand qualifications that meet professional standards, pushing institutions to keep quality high before they compete for overseas students.
Step 3: Related and supporting industries
Student accommodation, English-language colleges, education agents, migration advisers and tourism cluster around the universities in the capital cities.
Step 4: Firm strategy, structure and rivalry
Universities compete with each other for students, rankings and research funding, which drives investment in courses, campuses and marketing.
Step 5: Government and chance
Government sets visa and work rights and quality regulation; chance events (a pandemic closing borders, policy changes in rival destinations) shift demand.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The advantage was built: skilled staff and research (advanced factors), demanding domestic students and employers, a cluster of supporting services, and rivalry between institutions, shaped by government visa and quality policy. The English language and Australia's location near Asia are endowed rather than built.
Method
Give one specific example for each corner of the diamond.
Say whether each is endowed or built.
Add government and chance where relevant.
Watch out for
Listing the four corners without an example from the industry.
Calling the advantage comparative: it rests on created skills and institutions, not factor endowments.
Comparative advantage (Ricardo)
- Based on opportunity cost.
- Comes mainly from factor endowments, which are largely fixed.
- Explains trade between unlike countries: Australian ore for Japanese cars.
- Static: a snapshot of costs.
Competitive advantage (Porter)
- Based on firms' ability to outperform rivals on cost or quality.
- Created by skills, research, clusters, demand and rivalry.
- Explains trade in similar goods between similar countries, and success without raw materials.
- Dynamic: advantages are built and can be lost.
Contemporary relevance. All three theories still earn their place:
- Absolute advantage explains the simplest trades: Australia does not grow coffee commercially at scale and Brazil does.
- Comparative advantage explains most of Australia's export mix (iron ore, coal, LNG, beef, wheat) and is the core of the case for free trade: gains exist even for a country that is better or worse at everything.
- Competitive advantage explains how Australia can sell education, medical research, mining services and wine to the world, and why governments invest in skills, research and infrastructure. It also warns that an advantage built on endowments alone can fade as resources run down or world demand shifts, as the move away from coal shows.
Which statement best describes how competitive advantage differs from comparative advantage?
Common mistake
Competitive is not the same as comparative
The names are close and markers check you keep them apart. Comparative advantage is about opportunity cost. Competitive advantage is Porter's idea of an advantage built through the diamond. Absolute advantage is about output with given resources.
Exam tip
Applying the diamond
For an "apply Porter's diamond" question, take one industry and give a specific example for each of the four determinants, then say whether each is endowed or built, and what government could do to strengthen the weakest corner.
Summary
Competitive advantage (Porter, 1990) is created by firms, workers and governments, not inherited.
The diamond: factor conditions (basic and advanced), demand conditions, related and supporting industries, and firm strategy, structure and rivalry, with government and chance outside it.
Comparative advantage explains much of Australia's resource and farm exports; competitive advantage explains services such as education and mining technology.
All three theories remain relevant; together they explain what a country trades and how it can change.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.