Lesson 1 of 10 · 18 min
Biodiversity and the species concept
Describe genetic, species and ecosystem diversity, apply the biological species concept, and explain where it fails and which other species concepts fill the gaps.
What you will be able to do
- Describe genetic, species and ecosystem diversity, with an example of each.
- Explain why each level of biodiversity matters for the survival of species and ecosystems.
- Describe the biological species concept and use it to decide whether two populations are the same species.
- Identify the limitations of the biological species concept, and describe the morphological, ecological and phylogenetic species concepts.
Australia is one of 17 megadiverse countries, the handful that together hold most of the world's species. Most of its mammals, reptiles and frogs live nowhere else on Earth. Before you can count that variety, though, you need to say what you are counting.
Biodiversity is the variety of life in an area. Biologists describe it at three levels, from the genes inside one population up to whole landscapes.
The percentage of Australia's known species in each group that are endemic (found only in Australia). Data: Chapman (2009), Numbers of Living Species in Australia and the World, Australian Biological Resources Study.
| Level | What varies | Example | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Genetic diversity | The alleles and genes within a species or population | Koalas on Kangaroo Island descend from a few animals brought there in the 1920s and have far less genetic variation than mainland populations. | A population with more alleles is more likely to contain individuals that survive a new disease or a changing climate. |
| Species diversity | The number of species (richness) and how evenly the individuals are spread among them (evenness) | A hectare of lowland rainforest in the Wet Tropics holds far more tree species than a hectare of mulga woodland. | More species means more interactions and more ways for an ecosystem to keep functioning if one species declines. |
| Ecosystem diversity | The kinds of ecosystems in a region: their communities and physical environments | The Queensland coast runs from coral reef and seagrass meadow through mangrove forest and saltmarsh to heath, eucalypt forest and rainforest. | Different ecosystems provide different habitats and services: mangroves shelter juvenile fish, reefs protect coastlines, wetlands filter water. |
Definition
Biodiversity
Biodiversity is the variety of life in an area, described at three levels.
- Genetic diversity: the variety of alleles and genes within a species.
- Species diversity: the variety of species, combining species richness (how many species) and evenness (how evenly individuals are spread among them).
- Ecosystem diversity: the variety of ecosystems in a region.
Rangers find that a population of mountain pygmy-possums has only two versions of a gene for an immune protein, while a neighbouring population has seven. Which level of biodiversity are they describing?
Common mistake
Species diversity is more than a count
Species diversity has two parts. A paddock with ten plant species where one grass makes up 95 % of the plants is less diverse than a meadow with the same ten species in similar numbers. You will measure both parts in the lesson on measuring diversity.
What is a species?
Counting species assumes everyone agrees where one species ends and the next begins. The definition used most often is the biological species concept, set out by the evolutionary biologist Ernst Mayr in 1942.
Definition
The biological species concept
A species is a group of natural populations whose members actually or potentially interbreed and produce fertile offspring, and which are reproductively isolated from other such groups.
The test is reproduction. A horse and a donkey can mate, but their offspring, a mule, is almost always sterile, so horses and donkeys are separate species. Two populations of eastern grey kangaroos on either side of a river may never meet, but they could interbreed and have fertile young if they did, so they are one species.
"Natural" matters too. Lions and tigers can produce hybrids in zoos, but their ranges and behaviour keep them apart in the wild, so they remain separate species.
Under the biological species concept, why are horses and donkeys classified as different species, even though they can mate?
Where the biological species concept fails
The concept is powerful for animals that reproduce sexually and can be watched breeding. Many organisms don't fit.
| Limitation | Why it is a problem | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Asexual organisms | They do not interbreed at all, so the test cannot be applied. | Bacteria; plants that spread only by runners or bulbs; some populations of Bynoe's gecko (Heteronotia binoei), which are all-female and reproduce by parthenogenesis. |
| Fossils and extinct species | Their breeding can never be observed. | Diprotodon and other megafauna known only from bones. |
| Populations that never meet | Whether they could interbreed is a guess unless they are brought together, and doing so may not reflect what happens in nature. | Populations of a frog on two isolated mountain tops. |
| Fertile hybrids | Some groups that look and behave as separate species interbreed in the wild and produce fertile offspring. | Many eucalypts hybridise where their ranges meet. |
| Interbreeding only in captivity | Hybrids in zoos or laboratories do not show what happens in nature. | Lion × tiger hybrids. |
| Gradual change across a range | Neighbouring populations interbreed, but those at the ends of a chain do not, so there is no clear boundary. | Ring species such as the Ensatina salamanders of California. |
Key idea
Other species concepts
Because no single definition works for every organism, biologists use several. Each has limitations of its own.
- Morphological species concept: a species is a group whose members share physical features (body shape, structures). It works for fossils and asexual organisms, but males and females, or juveniles and adults, may look very different, and cryptic species look the same but cannot interbreed.
- Ecological species concept: a species is a group that occupies the same niche (uses the same resources in the same way). It explains why similar species can coexist, but one species can use different resources in different places.
- Phylogenetic species concept: a species is the smallest group of organisms that share a common ancestor and can be told apart from other groups, usually by DNA. It works for any organism with DNA, including asexual ones, but it can split groups into many very small "species" and depends on how much difference counts.
Worked example
One species of tree frog or two?
Two populations of a tree frog live in the rainforests of the Wet Tropics, north and south of a dry corridor. Biologists collect this evidence.
- Frogs from the two populations look identical, even under a microscope.
- In the laboratory, crosses between the two populations produce tadpoles that develop normally into fertile adults.
- Where the populations meet, in a narrow contact zone, males of each population have a different mating call, and females move only towards their own population's call. Hybrids are rare there.
- A gene in the mitochondrial DNA differs consistently between the populations, showing they have been separate for a long time.
Evaluate whether the populations should be classified as one species or two, using the morphological, biological and phylogenetic species concepts.
Step 1: Apply the morphological species concept
The frogs look identical (evidence 1), so on physical features alone they would be one species.
The morphological concept groups organisms by shared physical features.
Step 2: Apply the biological species concept
The populations can produce fertile offspring (evidence 2), but only in the laboratory. In nature, females choose their own population's call, so the populations rarely interbreed where they meet (evidence 3). They are reproductively isolated by behaviour in natural conditions, which points to two species.
The biological concept is about interbreeding in natural populations. Laboratory crosses show what is possible, not what happens.
Step 3: Apply the phylogenetic species concept
The consistent DNA difference (evidence 4) shows two separately evolving lineages that can be told apart, so by this concept they are two species.
Step 4: Weigh the evidence and conclude
Two of the three concepts, and the strongest evidence from nature (call choice and DNA), support two species that happen to look the same: cryptic species. The morphological concept fails here because the populations have diverged in behaviour and DNA, not in appearance.
Step 5: State a limitation
The conclusion rests on one gene and one contact zone. Sequencing more genes and checking whether the rare hybrids are fertile in the wild would strengthen it.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Most of the evidence supports two cryptic species: they are reproductively isolated in nature by mate choice (biological concept) and genetically distinct (phylogenetic concept), even though they look identical (which alone would suggest one species).
Method
Apply each species concept to the evidence it uses.
Under the biological concept, give more weight to what happens in nature than in the laboratory.
Weigh the concepts and reach a judgement.
State a limitation of the evidence.
Watch out for
Concluding "one species" because laboratory crosses are fertile. The biological concept asks about natural interbreeding.
Evaluating with only one concept. "Evaluate" asks you to weigh evidence and reach a justified judgement.
A microbiologist wants to decide whether two strains of soil bacteria belong to the same species. Which species concept can she apply most directly?
Exam tip
Describing a concept and its limits
For "describe the biological species concept", give all three parts: interbreeding in natural conditions, fertile offspring, reproductive isolation from other groups. For "identify a limitation", name the kind of organism it cannot handle and say why (asexual: no interbreeding to test; fossils: breeding cannot be observed).
Summary
Biodiversity has three levels: genetic (alleles within a species), species (richness and evenness) and ecosystem (variety of ecosystems).
Genetic diversity helps a population survive new diseases and changing conditions; species and ecosystem diversity keep ecosystems functioning.
The biological species concept: natural populations that interbreed to produce fertile offspring and are reproductively isolated from others.
It cannot be applied to asexual organisms or fossils, and struggles with populations that never meet, fertile hybrids, captive hybrids and ring species.
The morphological (shared features), ecological (shared niche) and phylogenetic (shared ancestry, from DNA) concepts fill the gaps, each with limits of its own.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.