Lesson 1 of 7 · 18 min
Implicit differentiation
Find for curves such as without solving for , by differentiating every term with respect to and using the chain rule on each term.
What you will be able to do
- Differentiate an equation in implicit form term by term with respect to , using the chain rule on functions of .
- Use the product rule on terms such as and .
- Solve for and use it to find gradients, tangents, and horizontal and vertical tangents.
So far every curve you have differentiated was written as . Plenty of curves are not. The circle fails the vertical line test, so it is not a function at all, yet it clearly has a tangent and a gradient at almost every point.
You could split the circle into and and differentiate each half. For a curve like there is no tidy way to do that. Implicit differentiation avoids the problem: you differentiate the equation as it stands.
Drag the point round the top half of the circle . At the gradient is , and at it is . Can you see the pattern ?
Key idea
The chain rule on a function of y
Treat as an unknown function of . Then any expression in is a composite function, and the chain rule gives
For example, and . Terms in alone differentiate as usual.
Here is the circle. Differentiate every term on both sides with respect to :
Solving for the derivative gives , the pattern from the widget. The answer is in terms of both and , which is normal: you need both coordinates to say which point of the curve you mean.
Treating as a function of , what is ?
Implicit differentiation
Put in front of every term on both sides
Constants differentiate to zero.
Differentiate term by term
Terms in as usual. Terms in pick up a factor of . Products such as need the product rule.
Collect the terms on one side
Move everything else to the other side.
Factorise and divide
Take out as a common factor and divide by what is left.
Common mistake
Products of x and y
is a product of two functions of , so
Writing or alone is the most common error in this topic.
Determine for the ellipse , in terms of and .
Worked example
Tangent to at
The point lies on the curve . Determine the equation of the tangent to the curve at .
Step 1: Check the point is on the curve
. ✓
Step 2: Differentiate every term with respect to
Use the product rule on and the chain rule on :
is a product of and , both functions of . by the chain rule.
Step 3: Solve for
Step 4: Evaluate the gradient at
Step 5: Write the tangent
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The tangent is , or .
Method
Differentiate both sides with respect to : chain rule on terms, product rule on mixed terms.
Collect the terms and solve.
Substitute the point to get the gradient.
Use .
Watch out for
Differentiating as : the product rule gives two terms.
Forgetting that the derivative of the constant is .
The point lies on the curve . Determine the gradient of the curve at .
Because is a fraction in and , it tells you where the tangents are horizontal and vertical.
- Horizontal tangent: the numerator is zero (and the denominator is not).
- Vertical tangent: the denominator is zero (and the numerator is not).
Each condition gives a relationship between and . Solve it simultaneously with the curve's equation to find the points.
Worked example
Horizontal and vertical tangents of
The curve is an ellipse tilted at .
(a) Show that .
(b) Determine the coordinates of the points where the tangent is horizontal, and where it is vertical.
Step 1: Differentiate implicitly
The product rule gives , and the whole of it is subtracted.
Step 2: Collect and solve for
as required.
Step 3: Horizontal tangents: numerator
, so . Substitute into the curve: , so .
Step 4: Check the denominator there
At , ; at , . So both tangents really are horizontal.
If numerator and denominator were both zero, would be undefined there, not zero.
Step 5: Vertical tangents: denominator
, so . Then , so . The numerator at these points.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Horizontal tangents at and ; vertical tangents at and .
Method
Find as a fraction in and .
Horizontal: set the numerator to zero. Vertical: set the denominator to zero.
Solve each condition simultaneously with the equation of the curve.
Check the other part of the fraction is not also zero.
Watch out for
Solving without substituting into the curve, which gives a line, not points.
Forgetting the negative square root: gives .
Without technology
Differentiate implicitly, solve for and substitute the point. Leave gradients exact, such as .
With technology
A CAS calculator has an implicit differentiation command (for example impDiff), and it can graph implicit curves so you can see the tangent. Still write the derivative you used.
Exam tip
Show the chain-rule factor
Markers look for the line where each term gains its . Write it in full before you rearrange, and give the final gradient exactly unless the question asks for a decimal.
Summary
Implicit differentiation finds without first making the subject.
Differentiate every term with respect to . Each term gains a factor of : .
Use the product rule on mixed terms: .
Collect the terms, factorise and divide. The result usually involves both and .
Horizontal tangents: numerator zero. Vertical tangents: denominator zero. Solve with the curve's equation.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.