Lesson 3 of 10 · 16 min
Why bystanders hold back
Use the five steps of the decision to help to explain how diffusion of responsibility, audience inhibition, social influence and cost–benefit analysis stop a bystander helping.
What you will be able to do
- List the five steps a bystander must pass through before helping.
- Describe diffusion of responsibility, audience inhibition, social influence and cost–benefit analysis, and the step each one acts on.
- Use these factors to explain a bystander's behaviour in a new scenario.
Latané and Darley argued that helping is not one decision but a series of them. A bystander has to say "yes" at every step; a "no" at any step means no help. Other people can push a bystander towards "no" at several steps, which is why the bystander effect is so strong.
The decision to help (Latané & Darley). A "no" at any step ends in no help.
Put the steps of Latané and Darley's decision to help in order.
Social influence. Emergencies are rare and often unclear. Is that smoke or steam? Is that person ill or asleep? When we are unsure, we look at other people to work out what is going on. If they look calm, we conclude that nothing is wrong. The trouble is that everyone else is doing the same thing, and everyone is trying to look calm. Each person privately wonders, but sees only calm faces, so the whole group decides there is no emergency. This is called pluralistic ignorance. Social influence acts at the interpret step. It is why the passive confederates in the smoke study were so powerful: only 1 of 10 participants beside them reported the smoke.
Diffusion of responsibility. Once you know there is an emergency, you still have to decide that it is your job to help. Alone, all of the responsibility is yours. With others present, it is shared, or diffused: "someone else will help", "someone has probably already called". The more bystanders, the smaller each person's share. Diffusion of responsibility acts at the take responsibility step. It explains the seizure study, where participants could not see the others and so could not be influenced by their calm: they could only assume someone else was acting.
Audience inhibition. Each bystander watches the others, but also knows the others are watching them. Nobody wants to overreact to something that turns out to be nothing and look foolish, so each person keeps a calm face until they are sure. That calm is exactly what the others read as "nothing is wrong", so audience inhibition feeds social influence. In Latané and Darley's (1969) review, which the syllabus cites, it acts at the interpret step, and they suggest people fear embarrassment less in front of friends than strangers, which fits the lady in distress study. Later accounts (Latané & Nida, 1981) also place it at the act step: someone who knows help is needed may still hold back for fear of helping badly in front of others.
Cost–benefit analysis. Even when someone takes responsibility, they weigh up the costs and benefits of helping and of not helping. The costs of helping include time, effort, danger and embarrassment; the costs of not helping include guilt, blame from others and the victim's continued suffering. Piliavin and colleagues (1981) predicted what a bystander will do from the two kinds of cost.
| Cost of helping | Cost of not helping is high | Cost of not helping is low |
|---|---|---|
| Low | Direct help | Helping depends on the person and the norms of the situation |
| High | Indirect help (call 000, find someone qualified), or reinterpret the situation so it seems less serious | Leave, ignore or deny the situation |
A man with a bleeding head wound is being shouted at by two aggressive people outside a pub late at night. A passer-by sees him clearly. Using cost–benefit analysis, what is the most likely response of the passer-by?
Switch on what is true for the bystander, run their decision, and see which step each factor stops them at.
| Factor | What happens | Step it blocks | Clearest evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Social influence | Others look calm, so you decide it is not an emergency | Interpret | Smoke study: 10% reported with passive confederates |
| Diffusion of responsibility | Responsibility is shared, so you feel less obliged to act | Take responsibility | Seizure study: 85% → 31% helped in time as others increased |
| Audience inhibition | Fear of overreacting and looking foolish in front of others, so you stay calm and wait | Interpret (later accounts: also act) | Lady in distress: pairs of friends helped more than pairs of strangers |
| Cost–benefit analysis | Costs of helping outweigh the costs of not helping | Decide how to help, act | Piliavin et al.'s model of when people help directly, indirectly or not at all |
Worked example
Explain a failure to help with the decision model
On a crowded train platform at peak hour, a man sits slumped against a pillar. Dozens of commuters walk past. Later, one commuter, Tess, says: "I did see him. I thought he might be drunk or asleep, because nobody else was doing anything. Then I realised he was grey and sweating, but there were so many people around, I figured someone would have called it in. I also didn't want to make a fuss and look silly in front of everyone."
Use Latané and Darley's decision model to explain why Tess did not help.
Step 1: Notice
Tess noticed the man ("I did see him"), so she passed the first step.
Step 2: Interpret
At first she interpreted it as not an emergency because "nobody else was doing anything". That is social influence: she used others' calm as information (pluralistic ignorance).
Step 3: Take responsibility
Once she realised he was unwell (grey and sweating), she assumed "someone would have called it in". That is diffusion of responsibility: with many bystanders she felt little personal responsibility.
Step 4: Audience inhibition
She "didn't want to make a fuss and look silly in front of everyone": audience inhibition. Not wanting to overreact in front of others kept her calm and waiting. In Latané and Darley's (1969) account this works at the interpret step, alongside social influence; later accounts would say it also held her back from acting.
Step 5: Conclude
Tess was held back at several steps by three processes, each caused by the presence of others: the bystander effect.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Tess noticed the man, but social influence first stopped her interpreting it as an emergency; once she did, diffusion of responsibility stopped her taking responsibility, and audience inhibition (not wanting to make a fuss in front of everyone) kept her calm and waiting.
Method
Go through the five steps in order.
Quote the detail that shows each step passed or blocked.
Name the process that blocked it.
Watch out for
Calling everything "the bystander effect". Name the specific process at each step.
Putting diffusion of responsibility before she knew it was an emergency.
Common mistake
Diffusion of responsibility needs a known emergency
If the bystander does not think anything is wrong, responsibility has not been diffused: they have been misled at the interpret step (social influence). Only once they know it is an emergency can "someone else will do it" stop them.
At a crowded beach, a swimmer is waving and shouting from the water. Jordan sees it and thinks "That might be someone in trouble", but looks around and sees nobody else reacting, and decides they must be playing around. Which factor best explains Jordan's decision?
Tip
Breaking the bystander effect
First-aid courses teach you to make the situation unambiguous ("This person needs help") and to give one person a specific job ("You in the blue shirt, call 000"). That removes social influence and diffusion of responsibility at once. Knowing how to help (competence) reduces audience inhibition too.
Summary
Helping needs a "yes" at five steps: notice, interpret as an emergency, take responsibility, decide how to help, act.
Social influence (pluralistic ignorance) blocks the interpret step: calm faces suggest no emergency.
Diffusion of responsibility blocks the responsibility step: someone else will help.
Audience inhibition blocks the interpret step: fear of overreacting in front of others keeps everyone calm (later accounts add the act step).
Cost–benefit analysis: high costs of helping with low costs of not helping lead to no help; both high lead to indirect help.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.