Lesson 4 of 10 · 14 min
Groupthink
Describe groupthink, identify its conditions and eight symptoms in a group's decision, and explain how it changes what individual members say and do.
What you will be able to do
- Define groupthink and describe the conditions that make it likely.
- Identify the symptoms of groupthink in what group members say and do.
- Explain how groupthink changes individual behaviour and suggest ways to prevent it.
Bystanders hold back when they are among strangers. Groupthink is the opposite problem: it happens when people are too close. In 1961 a small group of expert advisers to the United States President approved a plan to land 1,400 Cuban exiles at the Bay of Pigs to overthrow Cuba's government. The plan failed within three days. Several advisers had private doubts. None said so clearly in the meetings.
The psychologist Irving Janis studied decisions like this and called the process groupthink: a mode of thinking in a cohesive group, in which the members' drive for agreement overrides a realistic appraisal of the alternatives.
Definition
Groupthink
Groupthink is a way of thinking in a highly cohesive group in which the wish to agree and keep the group together becomes more important than testing ideas critically, so the group makes a poor decision.
Conditions that make groupthink likely (Janis called them antecedents):
- High cohesiveness: members like each other and value belonging to the group.
- Structural faults: the group is insulated from outside opinion, has a directive leader who states a preference early, has no procedure for weighing options, and its members share similar backgrounds and views.
- A stressful situation: pressure from outside, a deadline, and little hope of a better answer than the leader's.
| Type | Symptom | What it sounds like |
|---|---|---|
| Overestimating the group | Illusion of invulnerability | "We can't fail. We've never got one of these wrong." |
| Overestimating the group | Belief in the group's inherent morality | "We're doing this for the right reasons, so it will be fine." |
| Closed-mindedness | Collective rationalisation | "Those warnings are just people being negative. They don't apply to us." |
| Closed-mindedness | Stereotyped views of outsiders | "The other team is too disorganised to cause any trouble." |
| Pressure to agree | Self-censorship | A member with doubts stays silent. |
| Pressure to agree | Illusion of unanimity | "Good, so we all agree," after one person speaks and the rest say nothing. |
| Pressure to agree | Direct pressure on dissenters | "Come on, don't be the one to hold us back." |
| Pressure to agree | Self-appointed mindguards | A member keeps a critical email away from the leader "so we don't lose momentum". |
A school formal committee is choosing an outdoor venue a week before the event. Match each comment from the meeting to the symptom of groupthink it shows.
Switch the conditions on and off, find the symptoms in what members say, and try the remedies.
How groupthink changes individual behaviour. Groupthink is a social and cognitive factor acting on each member. Socially, members want to keep their place in a group they value, so they conform to what seems to be the group's view and avoid conflict. Cognitively, they stop searching for information and weighing alternatives, and they explain away warnings. A person who would think carefully alone says nothing, or argues for a plan they doubt.
The result is a defective decision: few alternatives considered, risks not examined, expert advice not sought, and no back-up plan.
Worked example
Identify groupthink in a group's decision
The four founders of a small app company have worked together for years and are close friends. Their investors want the app launched before a big trade show in two weeks. At a meeting, the chief executive says, "We've never missed a launch and we're not starting now." The tester, Dev, has found serious bugs, but the chief executive's deputy decides not to forward Dev's report "so it doesn't kill the mood". When the designer asks whether they should delay, the others tell her to stop being negative. Nobody else raises a concern, and the chief executive says, "Great, we're all agreed."
(a) Identify two conditions that made groupthink likely. (b) Identify four symptoms of groupthink, with evidence. (c) Suggest two ways the group could have avoided it.
Step 1: (a) Conditions
High cohesiveness: close friends who have worked together for years. Stress and time pressure: investors demanding a launch in two weeks. (A directive leader who states a view early is a third.)
Step 2: (b) Symptoms
"We've never missed a launch": illusion of invulnerability. The deputy holding back Dev's report: self-appointed mindguard. Telling the designer to stop being negative: direct pressure on dissenters. "We're all agreed" when others said nothing: illusion of unanimity (and others staying silent is self-censorship).
Step 3: (c) Prevention
The chief executive could hold back their view until others have spoken, and the group could appoint a devil's advocate or ask the tester to present findings directly; a second-chance meeting before deciding would let doubts surface.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) High cohesiveness; external pressure and a deadline. (b) Illusion of invulnerability, mindguard, direct pressure on dissenters, illusion of unanimity (also self-censorship). (c) Leader speaks last, devil's advocate, outside or expert input (Dev's report), second-chance meeting.
Method
Look for the conditions (cohesion, insulation, directive leader, stress).
Match each quoted behaviour to one of the eight symptoms.
Suggest remedies that target the symptoms you found.
Watch out for
Listing symptoms without quoting the evidence for each.
Calling the deputy's action self-censorship. Hiding someone else's information from the group is mindguarding.
Tip
Preventing groupthink
Janis suggested that the leader should hold back their own preference at first, that every member should be asked to act as a critical evaluator, that one member should play devil's advocate at each meeting, that outside experts should be invited to challenge the plan, and that the group should hold a "second-chance" meeting to air remaining doubts before deciding. Anonymous voting also reduces pressure to agree.
Which change would do most to reduce self-censorship in the formal committee?
Note
How strong is the evidence?
Janis built the idea from case studies of real decisions, which are rich but cannot isolate causes. Laboratory experiments have given mixed support: some symptoms appear reliably, but not always together or only under the conditions Janis named (Esser, 1998). Treat groupthink as a useful description of how cohesive groups go wrong, not a law that always applies.
Summary
Groupthink: in a cohesive group, the drive for agreement overrides realistic appraisal, leading to a poor decision (Janis).
Conditions: high cohesiveness, insulation, a directive leader, similar members, stress and time pressure.
Eight symptoms: invulnerability, inherent morality, collective rationalisation, stereotyped outsiders, self-censorship, illusion of unanimity, direct pressure on dissenters, mindguards.
It changes individuals: members conform, stay silent and stop testing ideas.
Prevent it with an impartial leader, a devil's advocate, outside experts, anonymous input and a second-chance meeting.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.