Lesson 9 of 10 · 20 min

Attraction

Describe biological and cultural explanations of attraction with Buss et al.'s (1990) study of 37 cultures, and the social and cognitive origins of attraction (proximity, reciprocity, similarity and self-disclosure).

What you will be able to do

  • Describe a biological (evolutionary) explanation of attraction and the cultural explanation.
  • Interpret Buss et al.'s (1990) findings on mate preferences across 37 cultures.
  • Describe how proximity, reciprocity, similarity and self-disclosure draw people together.
  • Explain how cultural norms and expectations shape how relationships form.

Why are we drawn to some people and not others? Psychologists give two kinds of answer. One looks at why humans might have evolved to prefer certain qualities in a partner, and how culture shapes those preferences. The other looks at how attraction actually develops between two people who meet: who we see often, who likes us back, who is like us and who we open up to. This lesson covers both, for friendships and romantic relationships of every kind.

A biological explanation. Evolutionary psychology argues that preferences which helped our ancestors to have children who survived would have been passed on. Parental investment theory points out that in humans, the biological cost of having a child is greater for women (pregnancy, birth and breastfeeding) than for men. From this it predicts that, on average, men will value signs of youth and health (cues to fertility, such as good looks), and women will value signs that a partner can and will provide resources (such as good financial prospects and ambition). It also predicts that some preferences, such as kindness and dependability, matter to everyone.

A cultural explanation. Cultures have different norms and expectations about relationships: who chooses a partner (the couple or their families), what makes a good partner, the roles partners are expected to play, and the value placed on things like religion or virginity. On this view, preferences are learned through socialisation and differ from culture to culture.

Buss et al. (1990) tested both. Researchers in 33 countries surveyed 9,474 people in 37 samples on six continents and five islands, from Nigeria and China to Sweden and Australia. Each participant rated 18 characteristics from 0 (irrelevant or unimportant) to 3 (indispensable) and ranked 13 others from 1 (most desirable) to 13 in a potential marriage partner. The questionnaires were translated into each language and back-translated to check the meaning held.

Mean importance ratings across all 37 samples (0 = irrelevant, 3 = indispensable). Violet: men; amber: women. Love is "mutual attraction–love", money is "good financial prospect" and cooking is "good cook and housekeeper" (Buss et al., 1990, Table 4).

Selected findings of Buss et al. (1990)
FindingThe dataSupports
Both sexes, nearly everywhere, put love and character first"Mutual attraction–love" was rated highest by men (2.81) and women (2.87); "kind and understanding" was ranked first by both (mean ranks 2.82 and 2.51)Shared human preferences (both explanations allow this)
Men valued good looks moreRated 1.91 by men and 1.46 by women; ranked 5th of 13 by men and 7th by womenBiological explanation
Women valued good financial prospects moreRated 1.76 by women and 1.51 by men; "good earning capacity" ranked 9th by women and 12th by menBiological explanation
Cultures differed, most of all on chastityMen in China ranked chastity 3rd of 18 and women 6th; in the Netherlands both ranked it 18th, lastCultural explanation
Cultures lined up from traditional to modernChina, India, Iran and Nigeria at one end; the Netherlands, Great Britain, Finland and Sweden at the otherCultural explanation
Interactive

Mate preferences across cultures

Compare where one characteristic ranks in each culture, then switch between a biological and a cultural explanation to see which results support each.

Which finding of Buss et al. (1990) most strongly supports a cultural explanation of attraction?

Choose one answer

Note

Evaluating Buss et al. (1990)

Strengths: a very large, cross-cultural sample; the same instruments everywhere, carefully translated and back-translated. Limitations: the samples were mostly urban and educated, so they are not representative of each country; the instruments were developed in the United States, so they may have missed characteristics that matter elsewhere; it measured stated preferences by self-report, not actual choices; it asked only about opposite-sex marriage partners; and the data are from the 1980s. The sex differences can also be explained socially: Eagly and Wood (1999) reanalysed the data and found the sex differences were smaller in countries where women and men had more equal social and economic roles.

Social and cognitive origins of attraction. Whatever we prefer in theory, attraction develops in everyday encounters. Four factors are named in the syllabus.

  • Proximity. We become friends and partners with people we see often. In a study of student housing, residents were most often friends with the people who lived next door and least often with those at the other end of the building (Festinger, Schachter & Back, 1950). Proximity gives us chances to interact, and the mere exposure effect means we tend to like what is familiar. Today proximity is also functional: being in the same online group chat or game counts too.
  • Reciprocity. We like people who show that they like us. Liking someone who likes us back is rewarding and feels safe: it lowers the risk of rejection.
  • Similarity. We are attracted to people who share our attitudes, values, interests and background (Byrne, 1971). Similar people validate our views, are easier to predict and get on with, and often meet in the same places.
  • Self-disclosure. Revealing personal thoughts, feelings and experiences builds closeness when it is gradual and mutual: each person discloses a little more as trust grows (social penetration theory; Altman & Taylor, 1973). People who disclose are liked more, and we like people we have disclosed to (Collins & Miller, 1994). Disclosing too much, too soon, or one-sidedly, can push people away.
Interactive

The levers of attraction

An illustrative model of two housemates getting to know each other. Change one factor at a time.

Identify the origin of attraction shown in each situation.

Worked example

Use Buss et al. (1990) to evaluate two explanations

  • Complex unfamiliar

In Buss et al. (1990), 9,474 people in 37 samples ranked 13 characteristics of a potential partner from 1 (most desirable) to 13. Mean ranks across all samples:

CharacteristicMenWomen
Kind and understanding2.822.51
Physically attractive5.577.29
Good earning capacity9.867.97

In addition, chastity was the characteristic on which cultures varied most: men in China rated it the 3rd most important of 18 characteristics, while men in the Netherlands rated it last (18th).

Evaluate how well these data support a biological and a cultural explanation of attraction.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Check which direction the scale runs.

  2. Match each finding to the explanation it supports.

  3. Weigh the evidence and its limitations before judging.

Watch out for

  • Treating a higher mean rank as more important. Rank 1 is most desirable.

  • Concluding that biology explains attraction because of the sex differences, ignoring the larger shared preferences and cultural variation.

Culture shapes how relationships form. Cultural norms and expectations decide who has a say, where people meet and what counts as a good match. In many cultures families play a large part in arranging or approving marriages, and compatibility between families matters as much as romantic attraction; in others, partners choose each other and romantic love is expected to come first. Norms about dating, about how quickly to disclose personal information, about age gaps, and about same-sex relationships also differ between cultures and change over time. Even the social and cognitive origins work through culture: who you are near, and who counts as "similar", depends on the communities you belong to.

Exam tip

Use the data

For "describe with reference to Buss et al. (1990)", give at least one sex difference with its numbers (looks, financial prospects) as evidence for the biological explanation, and the cultural variation (chastity, traditional versus modern) as evidence for the cultural one. Then note that love and kindness topped both sexes' lists.

Summary

  • Biological (evolutionary) explanation: different parental investment predicts men valuing looks and youth, women valuing resources, and everyone valuing kindness.

  • Cultural explanation: preferences are learned norms and differ between cultures.

  • Buss et al. (1990), 9,474 people in 37 samples: consistent sex differences in looks and financial prospects; large cultural differences, especially chastity; love and kindness top for both sexes.

  • Limitations: urban, educated samples; US-made instruments; stated preferences; opposite-sex marriage only; a social-role reanalysis explains some sex differences.

  • Social and cognitive origins: proximity, reciprocity, similarity and gradual, mutual self-disclosure.

  • Cultural norms and expectations shape who forms relationships with whom, and how.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 9 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account