Lesson 8 of 10 · 17 min
Media and aggression
Explain how advertising, video games and social media can influence aggression, using the general aggression model and social learning, and state what the evidence does and does not show.
What you will be able to do
- Explain short-term and long-term effects of media on aggression using the GAM.
- Explain how advertising, video games and social media can each influence aggression.
- State what the research evidence shows without overclaiming, and interpret correlational data.
After a violent crime, someone usually asks whether the offender played violent games or spent too long online. Psychology can say something careful about this, and the GAM gives you the structure: media can act as a situation input in a single episode, and as repeated learning across many.
Short-term (a single episode)
Violent or hostile media act as a situation input. They can prime aggressive thoughts and scripts (cognition), raise arousal, and stir hostile feelings (affect). For a short time afterwards, an ambiguous event is more likely to be appraised as hostile.
Long-term (multiple episodes)
Repeated exposure is rehearsal. It can build aggressive beliefs ("violence solves problems"), hostile perceptual and expectation schemata, aggressive scripts and desensitisation, which become person inputs for later episodes.
Social learning (from Unit 3) adds a second mechanism: people imitate aggression they observe, especially when the model is attractive or similar to them and the aggression is rewarded or goes unpunished (vicarious reinforcement), as in Bandura's Bobo doll studies.
Advertising. Advertisements can influence aggression in several ways that fit these mechanisms. Some advertisements show aggression as funny, cool or rewarded and without consequences, which is the kind of modelling social learning predicts will be imitated. Advertisements for violent films and games repeat their most violent moments as short, arousing clips, and some products are sold with weapons or fighting as aggressive cues. Advertising for alcohol promotes a drug that, as a situation input, reduces the resources needed to reappraise. Advertising can also push the other way: public campaigns against violence present aggression as harmful and unrewarded. The research on advertising specifically is thinner than for games: much of it describes what advertisements show, rather than measuring their effect on viewers' behaviour, so claims about advertising should be made cautiously.
Video games. The GAM predicts that violent video games could have stronger effects than watching violence, because the player is active (rehearsing the aggressive script, not just watching it), is often rewarded for violence with points or progress, identifies with their character, and plays for many hours, which is exactly the repetition the multiple-episode model describes.
What the evidence shows: experiments find that playing a violent game produces short-term increases in aggressive thoughts, hostile feelings, arousal and aggressive behaviour on laboratory measures. Longitudinal and correlational studies find a small association between violent game use and later aggression. In 2020 the American Psychological Association concluded that there is a small, reliable association between violent video game use and aggressive outcomes such as yelling and pushing, but insufficient scientific evidence that violent video games cause violent behaviour such as criminal violence, and that violence such as mass shootings should not be blamed on video games. Researchers still disagree about the size of the effect.
Common mistake
Aggression is not the same as violence
Most research measures aggression: hostile thoughts, angry feelings, insults, a louder noise blast in a laboratory task. Violence is extreme aggression that could cause serious injury. Evidence that games increase aggression on these measures is not evidence that they cause violent crime. Write "is associated with increased aggression", not "causes violence".
Social media. Social media brings new features into the GAM.
- Provocation at scale: hostile comments, insults and pile-ons are situation inputs that arrive often and publicly.
- Disinhibition: anonymity, not seeing the other person's reaction and the delay between posting and response reduce the restraint people show face to face (the online disinhibition effect; Suler, 2004), so people say things they would not say in person.
- Reinforcement: likes and shares reward hostile posts. Users whose outraged posts received more likes and shares went on to express more outrage (Brady et al., 2021), the operant learning that builds habits.
- Exposure and repetition: violent clips and hostile content can be seen over and over, the repetition that builds knowledge structures and desensitisation.
Cyberbullying is aggression on social media: deliberately harming someone through posts, messages or exclusion. Most studies of social media and aggression are correlational, so they show association, not cause.
A teenager posts a cruel comment under a classmate's video. It gets dozens of likes, and the next week they post more cruel comments. Which mechanism best explains the increase?
Reading the evidence: a correlational study. A researcher asked 12 Year 11 students how many hours a week they spent playing violent video games and gave each an aggression questionnaire (scores out of 40). The results are below.
Illustrative data. Drag a point to see how one student changes r and p.
Tip
Describing a correlation
Give the direction (positive or negative, from the sign of ) and the strength (from its size). As a guide, of 0.75 or more is strong, 0.5 to 0.75 moderate, 0.25 to 0.5 weak, and below 0.25 there is no correlation (no linear relationship). Then say whether it is significant, using the p-value from with .
Worked example
Interpret a correlation between gaming and aggression
A researcher recorded the weekly hours of violent video game play and aggression questionnaire scores (out of 40) of 12 Year 11 students. Illustrative data: Pearson's .
(a) Describe the correlation. (b) Calculate using , to 2 decimal places. (c) With , . State whether the correlation is significant. (d) Give two reasons this study cannot show that violent gaming causes aggression.
Step 1: (a) Describe r
is a moderate positive correlation: students who played more violent games tended to have higher aggression scores.
Step 2: (b) Substitute
Step 3: (b) Calculate
(2 d.p.). (Using the unrounded from the data gives 2.69.)
Step 4: (c) Significance
, so the correlation is statistically significant.
Step 5: (d) Why not cause
It is correlational: the IV was not manipulated. Reverse causation: students who are already aggressive may choose violent games. Third variables: something else, such as family conflict or low supervision, could increase both. The sample is also small (12) and unrepresentative.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Moderate positive. (b) . (c) Significant (). (d) Correlational design: possible reverse causation and third variables; small sample.
Method
Describe direction and strength of r.
Use with .
Compare with 0.05.
Explain why correlation does not show cause.
Watch out for
Concluding "gaming causes aggression" from a significant r.
Using instead of inside the square root.
In the study above, and . Which conclusion is justified?
Exam tip
Words that keep you accurate
Use "can influence", "increases the likelihood of", "is associated with", "short-term increases in aggressive thoughts and feelings". Name the mechanism (priming, arousal, social learning, reinforcement, knowledge structures, desensitisation, disinhibition) and say whether the evidence is experimental (short-term, cause) or correlational (association).
Summary
Short term, media act as a GAM situation input: priming aggressive thoughts, raising arousal and hostile affect.
Long term, repeated exposure builds aggressive beliefs, schemata, scripts and desensitisation (multiple episodes).
Advertising can model rewarded aggression, show aggressive cues and promote alcohol; research on its effects is limited.
Video games add active rehearsal, reward and repetition. The APA (2020) found a small, reliable association with aggression, but insufficient evidence that they cause violent behaviour.
Social media adds provocation, disinhibition, reinforcement by likes and repeated exposure; most of the evidence is correlational.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.