Lesson 2 of 10 · 18 min
Plasticity, environments and critical periods
Explain neural plasticity in development with enriched and deprived environments, critical and sensitive periods, and how biology and culture interact in adolescence.
What you will be able to do
- Define neural plasticity and explain why a developing brain is especially plastic.
- Explain the effects of enriched and deprived environments on the developing brain, using animal research.
- Distinguish critical periods from sensitive periods, with examples.
- Discuss how biologically defined periods interact with social and cultural contexts in adolescence.
Pruning keeps the connections a child uses. That means the brain a person ends up with depends on what happens to them: what they see, hear, practise and feel. The brain's ability to change its structure and function in response to experience is neural plasticity.
Definition
Neural plasticity
Neural plasticity is the ability of the brain to change its structure and function in response to experience, learning or damage.
Plasticity lasts a lifetime, but it is greatest in infancy and early childhood, when synapses are being formed and pruned fastest.
Enriched and deprived environments. In a classic series of experiments, Mark Rosenzweig, Edward Bennett and Marian Diamond raised young rats in three kinds of cage:
- an enriched cage: a large cage shared by a group of 10 to 12 rats, with toys, ladders and tunnels changed every day
- a standard cage: three rats, no toys
- an impoverished (deprived) cage: one rat alone, no toys.
After weeks in these cages, the rats' brains were examined. Compared with the impoverished rats, the enriched rats had a heavier, thicker cerebral cortex, larger neurons with more extensive dendritic branching, and more synapses. They also learnt mazes faster.
Switch between environments and compare the dendrites and synapses. The drawing is schematic.
In the enriched, standard and impoverished cage experiments, what was the independent variable?
Note
Rats are not children
These experiments could never be run on children, because deliberately depriving a child would breach the principle of protection from harm. Animal studies show how experience can change a brain, but generalising to humans needs care: a rat's brain, development and environment differ from a child's. Evidence from children comes from studies that observe children who were already deprived, such as children raised in large institutions (a later lesson).
Plasticity doesn't end in childhood. When adults learnt to juggle three balls over three months, brain scans showed more grey matter in areas that process visual motion; after three months without juggling, it had partly reversed (Draganski et al. 2004). The adult brain changes too, but less, and more slowly, than a child's.
Critical and sensitive periods. For some abilities, timing matters. The brain is ready to be shaped by a particular experience during a window, and the window can be narrow and fixed, or wide and gradual.
Critical period
A fixed, limited time in development when a particular experience must happen for an ability to develop normally.
Missing it causes lasting, often permanent, effects.
Example: goslings imprint on the first moving object they see in a short window soon after hatching (Lorenz 1937). Kittens with one eye kept closed in their first months never develop normal vision through it; the same closure in an adult cat has little effect (Hubel & Wiesel).
Sensitive period
A time when the brain is especially responsive to a particular experience, so learning is easiest.
Learning can still happen later, but less easily or completely.
Example: children who move to a new country before about age 7 learn its grammar as well as native speakers; the later they arrive up to puberty, the less native-like their grammar tends to be, and adult arrivals vary widely (Johnson & Newport 1989). Human attachment also forms most easily in infancy (Bowlby 1969).
Move the arrival of the experience. Compare the sharp edge of a critical period with the gradual slope of a sensitive period.
An adult who started learning the violin at 30 plays well, but less fluently than people who started as young children. This is best explained as
Worked example
Classify periods as critical or sensitive
For each case, decide whether it shows a critical period or a sensitive period, and justify your answer.
(a) Kittens raised with one eye kept closed for their first three months never develop normal vision through that eye, but closing one eye of an adult cat for the same time has little effect.
(b) A girl who moved from Japan to Brisbane at age 12 learnt to speak English fluently, though with a noticeable accent, while her younger brother, who arrived at age 4, sounds like a native speaker.
Step 1: Recall the difference
A critical period is a fixed window when an experience must occur; missing it causes lasting, often permanent, effects. A sensitive period is a time when learning is easiest, but it can still happen later.
Step 2: (a) Apply it to the kittens
Vision through the closed eye never develops normally, and only deprivation during the early window has this effect. This is a critical period.
Step 3: (b) Apply it to language
The girl did learn English fluently at 12, so the window had not closed, but her brother, who started earlier, learnt the sound system more completely. This is a sensitive period.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Critical period: missing visual experience in the early window causes a permanent effect that the same experience later does not. (b) Sensitive period: language can still be learnt at 12, but is learnt most completely when started early.
Method
Ask: can the ability still develop if the experience comes late?
No (or not normally) → critical period. Yes, but less easily → sensitive period.
Watch out for
Calling any age effect a critical period. If learning is still possible later, it is a sensitive period.
Adolescence: biology meets culture. Adolescence has its own biologically defined changes: puberty, and pruning and myelination of the prefrontal cortex. Researchers such as Sarah-Jayne Blakemore argue that adolescence is a sensitive period for social learning. The brain is especially responsive to peers, status and belonging, which helps young people learn the skills of adult social life.
But what an adolescent actually learns depends on the social and cultural context they are in:
- Peers. In a driving game, having friends watching increased risky driving far more for adolescents than for adults (Gardner & Steinberg 2005). The same sensitivity to peers can be used for good: peer mentoring and team sport.
- Culture and roles. Cultures differ in when young people are expected to work, marry, care for others or make their own decisions. Responsibilities given early can build planning and self-regulation; protected environments give more time for exploration.
- Timing. In many countries puberty now starts earlier than a century ago, while full independence (finishing study, a first full-time job) comes later. The gap between biological and social adulthood has widened.
Key idea
Neither biology nor context alone
A biologically defined period gives the readiness; the social and cultural context decides what experiences fill it. The same brain changes can lead to risk-taking in one setting and fast learning, creativity and close friendships in another.
Which statement best shows an interaction between a biologically defined period and social context in adolescence?
Summary
Neural plasticity is the brain's ability to change its structure and function with experience, learning or damage; it is greatest early in life.
Rats raised in enriched environments developed thicker, heavier cortex with more dendritic branching and synapses than rats raised in deprived environments.
A critical period is a fixed window when an experience must happen (imprinting, binocular vision); missing it has lasting effects.
A sensitive period is a time of easiest learning (language, attachment); learning is still possible later.
In adolescence, biological readiness (sensitivity to peers and social learning) interacts with social and cultural contexts to shape development.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.