Lesson 9 of 10 · 17 min
Information processing and comparing the theories
Explain how processing speed, cognitive strategies and metacognition develop with age, interpret data on them, and discuss the three theories of cognitive development together.
What you will be able to do
- Describe the information processing view of cognitive development.
- Explain how processing speed, cognitive strategies and metacognition change with age.
- Calculate and interpret descriptive statistics for data on developmental change.
- Discuss the cognitive, sociocultural and information processing theories together.
Give a six-year-old and a sixteen-year-old a list of ten pictures to remember. The sixteen-year-old will remember more. Piaget would look for a change of stage. Information processing theorists ask something more specific: which parts of the mind's processing have improved?
Key idea
The information processing view
The mind is compared to a computer: information comes in through the senses, is processed (attended to, held in working memory, worked on) and stored, and a response comes out.
Cognitive development is gradual and continuous, not a series of stages. Children get better at thinking because three things improve:
- Processing speed: how quickly information is taken in and responded to.
- Cognitive strategies: deliberate methods for learning and remembering.
- Metacognition: knowing about, monitoring and controlling one's own thinking.
Processing speed. On simple tasks, like pressing a button as soon as a light appears or deciding whether two shapes match, children's response times get faster and faster with age. The improvement is rapid in early childhood and slower in adolescence, approaching adult speeds in the mid to late teens (Kail 1991). Faster processing frees up working memory and attention for the rest of a task. Part of the reason is biological: as axons are myelinated, impulses travel faster.
Cognitive strategies. Older children use better strategies:
- Rehearsal: repeating information to keep it in mind. When asked to remember a set of pictures, few 5-year-olds rehearsed (whispered or moved their lips), and most 10-year-olds did (Flavell, Beach & Chinsky 1966).
- Organisation: grouping items by category (all the animals, all the foods).
- Elaboration: linking new information to what you already know, or making a mental image or story.
Younger children often don't produce a strategy on their own, though they can use it when told to. Later they use it spontaneously but it doesn't help much yet, and finally it helps fully.
Metacognition. Metacognition is thinking about your own thinking: knowing how memory works (lists are easier to learn grouped), monitoring how well you are learning, and controlling it (deciding to re-read). Preschoolers greatly overestimate how much they will remember, while older children predict their recall more accurately (Flavell, Friedrichs & Hoyt 1970). Adolescents start to plan their study, notice when they haven't understood, and change strategy.
The children are fictional and the curves are schematic: they show the direction of change with age, not measured values.
Before a test, Jordan reads his notes and thinks, "I know the definitions, but I keep mixing up the stages. I'll make flashcards for those." Which aspect of information processing does his thought best show?
Worked example
Analyse recall data for two age groups
Illustrative data: six 5-year-olds and six 10-year-olds were shown 12 pictures and asked to recall them after a short delay. Observers noted that none of the 5-year-olds rehearsed aloud and five of the 10-year-olds did.
| Pictures recalled | |
|---|---|
| 5-year-olds | 4, 5, 3, 6, 4, 5 |
| 10-year-olds | 8, 9, 7, 10, 8, 9 |
(a) Calculate the mean and the sample standard deviation for each group, to 2 decimal places. (b) Identify the research design. (c) Explain the difference in recall using information processing theory.
Step 1: (a) Means
5-year-olds: . 10-year-olds: .
Step 2: (a) Standard deviations
For the 5-year-olds the deviations are ; their squares sum to . . The 10-year-olds' scores are each exactly 4 more, so their deviations, and , are the same: .
Adding the same amount to every score shifts the mean but not the spread.
Step 3: (b) Design
Age is a characteristic the researcher can't allocate, and the two age groups are different children: a quasi-experiment comparing groups (cross-sectional).
Step 4: (c) Explain
The 10-year-olds recalled 4 more pictures on average, with the same spread. Most of them rehearsed, a cognitive strategy that keeps information active in memory, while the 5-year-olds didn't use it spontaneously. Faster processing speed and better metacognition (knowing they needed to try to remember) may also contribute.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) 5-year-olds: mean 4.50, SD 1.05. 10-year-olds: mean 8.50, SD 1.05. (b) A quasi-experiment comparing two age groups. (c) Older children spontaneously used rehearsal (a cognitive strategy), helped by faster processing and better metacognition, so they recalled more.
Method
Mean: sum ÷ n. Sample SD: square the deviations, divide by n − 1, take the square root.
Name the design: a pre-existing difference such as age makes it quasi-experimental.
Explain with a named information processing factor.
Watch out for
Dividing by instead of for the sample SD (which gives 0.96).
Calling it a true experiment: age can't be randomly allocated.
Five 7-year-olds pressed a button as soon as a light came on. Their mean reaction times, in milliseconds, were:
Calculate the mean reaction time for the group.
Comparing the three theories. A "discuss" question on cognitive development usually expects you to set the theories side by side.
| Question | Piaget (cognitive) | Vygotsky (sociocultural) | Information processing |
|---|---|---|---|
| What develops? | Schemas and logical operations | Higher mental functions, through language and cultural tools | Speed, capacity, strategies and metacognition |
| Continuous or in stages? | Four universal stages | Continuous, shaped by interaction | Continuous, gradual improvement |
| What drives it? | The child's own exploration (equilibration) | Social interaction in the ZPD; culture | Brain maturation (for example, myelination), practice and learning strategies |
| Role of others | Small: others provide experiences | Central: the MKO scaffolds learning | Moderate: strategies can be taught |
| Main limitation | Underestimated young children; stages too tidy | ZPD hard to measure; vague about internal change | The computer analogy leaves out emotion, motivation and culture |
A teacher notices that her Year 3 students recall more spelling words when she teaches them to group the words by sound pattern. Which theory explains the improvement most directly?
Exam tip
Discussing the theories
A "discuss" answer gives the key ideas of each theory, how they differ (stages or continuous; individual or social), how later researchers built on or challenged earlier ones, and a supported judgement. The theories aren't rivals in every respect: each explains a different part of development.
Summary
Information processing theory sees cognitive development as gradual, continuous improvement in how information is processed.
Processing speed rises quickly in childhood and more slowly in adolescence, partly because of myelination.
Older children use cognitive strategies such as rehearsal, organisation and elaboration spontaneously and effectively.
Metacognition, knowing and monitoring one's own thinking, improves with age: young children overestimate their memory.
Piaget (stages, the child alone), Vygotsky (social and cultural, the ZPD) and information processing (continuous, speed, strategies, metacognition) each explain a different side of development.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.