Lesson 5 of 10 · 18 min

Bowlby, Ainsworth and attachment types

Describe Bowlby's theory of attachment and Ainsworth's Strange Situation, classify an infant's attachment as secure, avoidant or resistant, and explain the role of attachment in later development.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe Bowlby's (1969) theory: an evolved attachment system, monotropy, a sensitive period, the secure base and internal working models.
  • Explain how Bowlby built on Lorenz and Harlow, and how Ainsworth built on Bowlby.
  • Describe the Strange Situation and classify an infant as securely, avoidantly or resistantly attached.
  • Describe the role of attachment in later psychological development.

John Bowlby was a British psychiatrist who had worked with children separated from their families during and after the Second World War. He read Lorenz and Harlow and asked what their animal research meant for human infants. His answer, in Attachment (1969), became the foundation of attachment theory.

Key idea

Bowlby's attachment theory (1969)

  • An evolved system. Infants are born with behaviours (crying, smiling, clinging, following) that keep a caregiver close. Staying close to an adult protected infants from danger, so the tendency evolved.
  • Monotropy. An infant forms one main attachment, usually to the primary caregiver, which is more important than any other.
  • A sensitive period. Attachment forms most easily in roughly the first two to three years; after that it is much harder.
  • Secure base. The attachment figure is a safe place to explore from and return to.
  • Internal working model. From early care, the infant builds a mental model of relationships (am I worth caring for, can others be trusted?) that guides later relationships.

Building on and challenging. Bowlby built on Lorenz's idea that attachment is biological and time-limited, but softened the critical period of geese to a sensitive period for humans. He built on Harlow's finding that attachment is about comfort and security, not food, which challenged learning theory. Later researchers challenged Bowlby in turn: Schaffer & Emerson (1964) found that most infants had formed attachments to several people by 18 months, which questions monotropy.

Which statement best describes how Bowlby (1969) built on Lorenz (1937)?

Choose one answer

Mary Ainsworth: measuring attachment. Ainsworth worked with Bowlby and set out to test his ideas by observing real infants, first at home in Uganda and then in Baltimore in the United States. To compare infants fairly she designed a standardised laboratory observation, the Strange Situation (Ainsworth, Blehar, Waters & Wall 1978).

An infant of about 12 to 18 months and their caregiver go through eight short episodes, most of them about three minutes, in an unfamiliar playroom. The stress builds gradually: a stranger arrives, the caregiver leaves, the infant is left alone. Observers behind a one-way mirror record the infant's exploration, separation distress, reaction to the stranger and, above all, behaviour on reunion.

The eight episodes of the Strange Situation
EpisodeWhat happensWhat it tests
1Caregiver and infant are shown into the roomSettling in
2Caregiver and infant alone; the infant can explore the toysUse of the caregiver as a secure base
3A stranger enters, talks to the caregiver, then approaches the infantReaction to a stranger
4Caregiver leaves; stranger stays with the infantSeparation distress
5Caregiver returns; stranger leavesReunion behaviour
6Caregiver leaves the infant aloneSeparation distress
7Stranger returns and stays with the infantComfort from a stranger
8Caregiver returns; stranger leavesReunion behaviour

Secure (type B)

Explores freely, using the caregiver as a secure base.

May or may not be upset when the caregiver leaves; prefers the caregiver to the stranger.

On reunion greets the caregiver or seeks contact, is quickly comforted, and goes back to playing.

Insecure (types A and C)

Avoidant (A): explores with little reference to the caregiver, shows little distress at separation, and ignores or turns away from the caregiver on reunion.

Resistant (C), also called ambivalent: explores little and clings, is very distressed at separation, and on reunion both seeks contact and resists it (reaching to be picked up, then pushing away), and is hard to settle.

Interactive

Classify an infant

The infants are fictional. Watch the reunions closely before you decide.

Worked example

Classify an infant in the Strange Situation

  • Simple familiar

Observers record 14-month-old Leo in the Strange Situation. He stays close to his mother and explores very little. When she leaves he cries loudly and can't be calmed by the stranger. When she returns he reaches to be picked up, then arches his back and pushes her away, and keeps crying for several minutes.

Classify Leo's attachment, and justify your answer with evidence from the observation.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Describe exploration, separation, reaction to the stranger and reunion.

  2. Use the reunion to decide between secure, avoidant and resistant.

Watch out for

  • Calling Leo securely attached because he wants his mother. A secure infant is comforted quickly on reunion.

In the Strange Situation, Mika plays with the toys without looking at her father, doesn't cry when he leaves, and plays on without looking up when he comes back. Classify her attachment.

Choose one answer

Sensitivity. In Ainsworth's home observations, the caregivers of securely attached infants had responded more sensitively to their signals in the first year: noticing them, interpreting them correctly and responding promptly and appropriately. Across 18 samples from the United States (1,230 infants), about 65 per cent of infants were classified secure, 21 per cent avoidant and 14 per cent resistant (van IJzendoorn & Kroonenberg 1988). The 105 infants of Ainsworth et al.'s (1978) own samples, as that review tabulates them, were similar: 67 per cent secure, 21 per cent avoidant and 12 per cent resistant.

Researchers later built on and challenged Ainsworth's work. Some infants fitted none of her three types, and a fourth, disorganised, pattern was added (Main & Solomon 1990). Studies in other countries found different proportions: more avoidant infants in German samples and more resistant infants in Japanese samples (van IJzendoorn & Kroonenberg 1988), though secure was the most common type in every country, and samples within one country differed more than the countries did. The differences may arise because cultures differ in how often infants are separated from caregivers and in what behaviour is encouraged. That raises a question about whether a test designed in the US measures the same thing everywhere.

Worked example

Compare a sample's attachment types with the standard pattern

  • Simple familiar
  • Technology active

In an illustrative study, researchers classify 80 infants from one city using the Strange Situation: 50 are secure, 22 avoidant and 8 resistant.

(a) Calculate the percentage of infants in each category. (b) Compare the results with the pooled US samples in van IJzendoorn and Kroonenberg's (1988) review (about 65% secure, 21% avoidant, 14% resistant). (c) Suggest one reason a sample from another culture might differ.

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Percentage = count ÷ total × 100; check the percentages add to 100.

  2. Compare each category, naming the direction and size of the differences.

Watch out for

  • Dividing by the wrong total, for example by the number of insecure infants.

The role of attachment in psychological development. Attachment is not only about comfort in infancy:

  • A secure base for exploring. A securely attached child explores and plays more freely, which gives them the experiences that drive cognitive development.
  • Managing emotions. Being comforted reliably teaches an infant that distress can be eased, and over time they learn to calm themselves.
  • An internal working model. Expectations about whether others are reliable and whether they are worth caring for carry into friendships and later relationships. In long-term studies, children who were securely attached as infants tend, on average, to be more socially competent and confident later.

Common mistake

Insecure attachment is not a disorder, and it is not destiny

Avoidant and resistant attachment are common patterns, not diagnoses. Attachment links to later development on average, and the links are modest. Attachment can change when a child's circumstances change, and later relationships, such as with a teacher or a partner, can build security.

Summary

  • Bowlby (1969): attachment is an evolved system; monotropy; a sensitive period in the first years; the caregiver is a secure base; early care forms an internal working model of relationships.

  • Bowlby built on Lorenz and Harlow; Schaffer & Emerson challenged monotropy with evidence of multiple attachments.

  • Ainsworth et al. (1978) measured attachment with the Strange Situation: eight episodes of separations and reunions.

  • Secure infants are comforted quickly on reunion; avoidant infants ignore the caregiver; resistant infants are very distressed and both seek and resist contact.

  • Attachment supports exploration, emotion regulation and later relationships, on average, but it can change.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 5 of 100% read

Save your progress with a free account