Lesson 4 of 10 · 16 min
Imprinting and contact comfort
Describe how Lorenz's imprinting and Harlow's surrogate mothers changed ideas about attachment, and evaluate the studies, including the ethics of animal research.
What you will be able to do
- Define attachment and explain why researchers asked what it is based on.
- Describe Lorenz's (1937) research on imprinting and the idea of a critical period.
- Describe Harlow & Zimmermann's (1958) research and explain how it challenged the idea that infants attach to whoever feeds them.
- Evaluate both studies, including generalising from animals and the ethics of Harlow's research.
A frightened toddler runs to one particular person. Strangers won't do, even kind ones. That strong, lasting emotional bond between an infant and a caregiver is attachment.
In the 1940s and 50s many psychologists thought they knew what attachment was: cupboard love. On this learning theory view, an infant becomes attached to whoever feeds them, because the caregiver is linked with the pleasure of food. Two researchers working with animals gave very different answers.
Definition
Attachment
Attachment is a strong, lasting emotional bond between an infant and a caregiver, shown by the infant seeking to be near the caregiver, especially when frightened, tired or unwell.
Konrad Lorenz (1937): imprinting. Lorenz, an Austrian zoologist, studied greylag geese. He divided a clutch of eggs: half hatched beside their mother, and half in an incubator, where the first moving thing the goslings saw was Lorenz himself. The mother-reared goslings followed their mother. The incubator goslings followed Lorenz, and kept following him wherever he went.
Lorenz called this imprinting: a rapid, automatic attachment to the first suitable moving object seen after hatching. He argued that it happens only during a short critical period soon after hatching, that it is very hard to reverse, and that it later shapes which birds the goose chooses as a mate. Later researchers challenged parts of this: the window turned out to be less fixed than Lorenz thought, and imprinting can sometimes happen later or be reversed.
Read each view, then compare what each researcher said attachment is based on.
Lorenz's research suggested that attachment in geese
Harry Harlow (Harlow & Zimmermann 1958): contact comfort. Harlow worked with infant rhesus monkeys, which are much closer to humans than geese. Infants were taken from their mothers soon after birth and raised in cages with two surrogate (substitute) mothers: one made of bare wire mesh, and one of wire covered in soft terry-towelling cloth. For some infants, only the wire mother had a feeding bottle; for others, only the cloth mother.
Whichever mother gave milk, the infants spent most of each day clinging to the cloth mother. They went to the wire mother only to feed. When a noisy mechanical toy frightened them, they ran to the cloth mother and clung to her. In a strange room with the cloth mother present, they explored and returned to her now and then; without her, they froze, crouched and cried.
The design of the surrogate mother research and its central result.
Key idea
How Harlow challenged earlier ideas
If infants attached to whoever fed them, the monkeys fed by the wire mother should have preferred her. They didn't. Harlow concluded that contact comfort, soft physical contact, matters more than food, which challenged the learning theory (cupboard love) view of attachment. The cloth mother also acted as a secure base for exploring, an idea Bowlby and Ainsworth would build on.
Harlow's later work showed the cost. Monkeys raised without a real mother, and especially those kept alone, grew into adults with serious social problems: they were fearful or aggressive with other monkeys, and many later neglected or mistreated their own infants. A cloth mother gave comfort, but not the responsive interaction a real mother gives.
Worked example
Explain how Harlow challenged earlier ideas
Explain how Harlow & Zimmermann's (1958) research with infant rhesus monkeys challenged the learning theory view of attachment, and evaluate the research on one ethical and one methodological point.
Step 1: State the learning theory view
Learning theory ("cupboard love") held that an infant becomes attached to whoever feeds them, because the caregiver is associated with food.
Step 2: Describe the procedure
Infant monkeys were raised with a bare wire surrogate mother and a soft cloth surrogate. For some, only the wire mother held a feeding bottle.
Step 3: Describe the findings
Even when only the wire mother gave milk, the infants spent most of their time on the cloth mother, ran to her when frightened, and used her as a base for exploring.
Step 4: State the challenge
If food were the basis of attachment, the infants fed by the wire mother would have preferred it. They didn't, so contact comfort, not food, was the basis of the bond.
Step 5: Evaluate ethically
The infants were separated from their mothers and deliberately frightened, causing distress and lasting social harm. Under today's animal research codes, the harm would not be justified.
Step 6: Evaluate methodologically
Rhesus monkeys are not humans, and surrogate mothers are unlike real caregivers, so generalising to human infants is limited.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Infants preferred the cloth mother even when the wire mother fed them, showing that contact comfort, not food, underlies attachment, which challenged learning theory. Ethically, the infants suffered distress and lasting harm; methodologically, results from monkeys with surrogates may not generalise to human infants.
Method
State the earlier view.
Describe the procedure and the key result.
Show why the result contradicts the earlier view.
Evaluate with one ethical and one methodological point.
Watch out for
Saying the monkeys preferred the cloth mother "because it fed them". The point is that they preferred it even when it didn't.
History
The ethics of Harlow's research
Harlow's research caused infant monkeys lasting distress and harm: separation from their mothers at birth, deliberate frightening, and in later studies long periods of isolation. It would not be approved today. In Australia, animal research must follow the Australian code for the care and use of animals for scientific purposes (NHMRC 2013, updated 2021): an animal ethics committee must approve it, the benefits must justify any harm, and researchers must replace animals where they can, reduce the number used and refine procedures to minimise suffering. The research did change how hospitals and orphanages cared for children, which is part of why it is still discussed.
Select all the reasons we should be careful generalising Lorenz's and Harlow's findings to human infants.
Summary
Attachment is a strong, lasting emotional bond between an infant and a caregiver.
Lorenz (1937): goslings imprinted on the first moving object they saw, in a critical period after hatching, with no food involved.
Harlow & Zimmermann (1958): infant monkeys preferred a soft cloth mother to a wire mother that fed them, ran to her when frightened and used her as a secure base.
Both challenged the learning theory view that attachment is based on food; Harlow showed the importance of contact comfort.
Generalising from geese and monkeys to humans needs care, and Harlow's studies caused harm that today's ethical codes would not allow.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.