Lesson 9 of 11 · 19 min
Types of unemployment, the NAIRU and their costs
Classify cyclical, structural, frictional, seasonal, hidden and long-term unemployment and underemployment, explain the natural rate and the NAIRU, and explain the effects, benefits and costs of unemployment for different groups.
What you will be able to do
- Describe and classify the types of unemployment the syllabus names, with their causes.
- Explain the natural rate of unemployment and the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU).
- Show cyclical unemployment on the AD–AS diagram and the production possibility curve.
- Explain the effects, benefits and costs of unemployment for individuals, firms, the government and the economy.
Two people are unemployed in the same month. One is a graduate engineer who finished university in November and has interviews lined up; the other is a 52-year-old who lost a job at a factory that has closed for good. The unemployment rate counts them the same, but their situations, and the right policies to help them, are very different. That is why economists sort unemployment by its cause.
| Type | Cause | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Cyclical | Too little aggregate demand in a downturn: firms sell less and need fewer workers | Retail and hospitality jobs lost when household spending falls in a recession |
| Structural | A lasting change in the structure of the economy (technology, competition from imports, changing demand) leaves workers whose skills or location no longer match the jobs available | Car assembly workers after the last Australian car plants closed in 2017; workers replaced by automation |
| Frictional | Time spent moving between jobs or looking for a first job, while job seekers and employers find each other | A graduate searching for a first job; a worker who resigns to move to Townsville and is looking there |
| Seasonal | Demand for some work rises and falls at the same time each year | Fruit pickers between harvests; extra retail staff after Christmas; tourism workers in the off-season |
| Hidden | People who want work but are not counted as unemployed because they have stopped looking (discouraged job seekers) or are not available to start | A 60-year-old who gives up searching after a year of rejections |
| Long-term | Unemployed for 52 weeks or more; often follows a deep downturn or structural change | The worker from the closed factory, still searching a year later |
| Underemployment | Employed, but wanting and available for more hours than they work | A part-time café worker on 12 hours a week who wants 30 |
Definition
The natural rate and the NAIRU
The natural rate of unemployment is the unemployment that remains when the economy is at full employment: frictional, structural and seasonal unemployment, with no cyclical unemployment. It is never zero.
The non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU) describes the same point through inflation: the lowest unemployment rate the economy can sustain without inflation rising. Push unemployment below it and employers compete for scarce workers, wages grow faster than productivity, and inflation accelerates. The NAIRU cannot be observed; the RBA estimates it from models, and the estimates are uncertain and change as the economy changes.
Which types of unemployment make up the natural rate of unemployment?
Cyclical unemployment on the diagrams. On the AD–AS diagram, cyclical unemployment is the recessionary gap: real GDP below potential means fewer workers are needed. On the production possibility curve it is a point inside the curve: the resources exist but are idle. Policies that raise AD reduce cyclical unemployment; they do little for structural unemployment, which needs retraining, relocation support or better job matching.
Real GDP below potential: the output gap is matched by cyclical unemployment.
Classify each person's situation by the main type of unemployment it shows.
Worked example
Classify unemployment from a scenario
A Brisbane call centre closes because its owner moves the work to software that answers customer calls automatically. Two hundred staff lose their jobs. Six months later 40 of them are still looking for work, mostly older workers with no recent training. Identify the type of unemployment and suggest a policy that would address it.
Step 1: Find the cause
The jobs were lost because of a lasting change in technology, not a fall in total spending: the work will not come back when the economy improves.
Step 2: Name the type
This is structural unemployment: the workers' skills no longer match the jobs available.
Cyclical unemployment would end when AD recovers; this will not.
Step 3: Note the duration
If the 40 are still unemployed after 52 weeks, they will also be long-term unemployed, which makes finding work harder still.
Step 4: Match a policy
Policies that raise AD will not fix a skills mismatch. Retraining (for example, subsidised TAFE courses in growing industries), help with job search and wage subsidies for employers who hire the long-term unemployed address the cause.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Structural unemployment (technological change), at risk of becoming long-term; addressed by retraining and job-matching help rather than by raising AD.
Method
Ask why the job was lost: spending, a lasting change, moving between jobs, or the season.
Add duration (long-term) or hours (underemployment) if the scenario gives them.
Match the policy to the cause.
Watch out for
Calling it cyclical because the economy might be weak too. Look for what caused this job loss.
Long-term unemployment is measured by duration, not cause: anyone unemployed for 52 weeks or more. It is the most damaging kind. Skills fade, contacts are lost, employers grow wary of long gaps, and confidence and health suffer, so the longer someone is unemployed the harder it becomes to find work. Economists call this hysteresis: a deep downturn can leave unemployment higher even after demand recovers, raising the natural rate.
Of 620 000 unemployed people, 124 000 have been unemployed for 52 weeks or more. What percentage of the unemployed are long-term unemployed?
Effects, benefits and costs
| Group or agent | Costs of unemployment | Benefits (limited) |
|---|---|---|
| Unemployed people and their families | Lost income and savings; financial stress; worse physical and mental health; skills fade; risk of long-term unemployment | Time to search for a job that suits them (frictional) |
| Firms | Lower sales as spending falls | Easier to hire; less pressure on wages |
| Government | Lower income tax revenue and higher spending on JobSeeker Payment, pushing the budget towards deficit | Less inflationary pressure |
| The economy | Lost output that can never be recovered (a point inside the PPC); lower living standards; less investment | Some unemployment lets labour move to where it is most productive |
| Society and regions | Inequality widens; crime and social problems rise; whole towns suffer when a large employer closes | — |
The main point is that unemployment is costly. The only "benefits" come from a little frictional unemployment, which helps workers find good matches, and from slack in the labour market, which keeps wages and inflation in check.
Common mistake
Long-term is not a cause
Long-term unemployment and underemployment describe how long or how much, not why. A long-term unemployed person may first have lost a job for cyclical or structural reasons. If a question asks for the type of unemployment from a scenario, look for the cause; mention duration as well if the scenario gives it.
Exam tip
Match the policy to the type
Explaining the type earns the comprehension marks; matching it to a remedy shows analysis. Cyclical: policies that raise AD (lower interest rates, expansionary fiscal policy). Structural: education and training, relocation help, wage subsidies for the long-term unemployed. Frictional: better job-matching services. Seasonal: little to fix; it is expected.
Summary
Cyclical (too little AD), structural (skills or location mismatch after lasting change), frictional (between jobs) and seasonal (time of year) are causes.
Hidden unemployment is not counted; long-term (52 weeks or more) and underemployment describe duration and hours.
The natural rate is frictional + structural + seasonal; the NAIRU is the lowest rate that does not push up inflation, and is estimated.
Cyclical unemployment is a recessionary gap on the AD–AS diagram and a point inside the PPC.
Costs fall on the unemployed (income, health, skills), the government (less tax, more JobSeeker), the economy (lost output) and society (inequality).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.