Lesson 10 of 11 · 19 min
Types of inflation: causes, effects, winners and losers
Distinguish headline and underlying inflation, explain demand-pull, cost-push and imported inflation and the role of inflation expectations, and explain who gains and who loses from inflation.
What you will be able to do
- Distinguish headline inflation from underlying inflation, and explain why the RBA watches both.
- Explain demand-pull, cost-push and imported inflation with AD–AS diagrams.
- Explain how inflation expectations can make inflation persist.
- Explain the effects, benefits and costs of inflation for borrowers, savers, people on fixed incomes, workers, firms, exporters and the government.
Between 2021 and 2023 Australians saw prices rise faster than at any time since 1990: headline inflation reached 7.9% over the year to the December quarter 2022 (first published as 7.8%), far above the RBA's 2–3% target. Petrol, electricity, rents, building costs and groceries all jumped, but for different reasons. Telling those reasons apart, and knowing who is hurt, is what this lesson is about.
Headline and underlying inflation
Headline inflation is the percentage change in the whole CPI. It is what households feel, but it jumps around with volatile prices: fuel, fruit and vegetables after a flood, or a one-off government rebate on electricity bills.
Underlying inflation removes the most volatile price changes to show the trend. The ABS publishes two measures the RBA watches closely:
- the trimmed mean: rank every item's price change and leave out the 15% of the basket (by weight) with the largest rises and the 15% with the largest falls, then average the rest;
- the weighted median: the price change in the middle of the ranked basket.
In one quarter, petrol prices fall 12% as world oil prices slump, but most other prices rise steadily. What is likely to happen to the inflation measures?
Causes of inflation
Demand-pull inflation happens when aggregate demand grows faster than the economy's capacity to produce. Near full employment firms cannot raise output much, so extra spending bids up prices. On the AD–AS diagram, AD shifts right into the steep part of SRAS: the price level rises a lot, real GDP a little.
Cost-push inflation happens when the costs of production rise: wages growing faster than productivity, higher energy and raw material prices, higher indirect taxes. Firms pass the costs on. SRAS shifts left: the price level rises and real GDP falls.
Imported inflation is inflation caused by dearer imports: higher world prices, or a depreciation of the Australian dollar that makes every import cost more in Australian dollars. Imported consumer goods raise the CPI directly; imported inputs such as fuel and machinery raise firms' costs, a form of cost-push.
A depreciation works on both sides of the model at once: it makes exports cheaper abroad and imports dearer here, so net exports rise (AD right), and it raises the cost of imported inputs (SRAS left). Which effect to draw is a judgement about the question: for its effect on spending and growth, show AD; for imported inflation through firms' costs, show SRAS, and say that the other effect also operates.
Shift SRAS with a cost change and compare with a shift of AD.
Demand-pull
- Cause: AD grows faster than capacity (strong consumption, low interest rates, a spending boom, a commodity boom).
- Diagram: AD shifts right.
- Price level rises; real GDP rises; unemployment falls.
- Usual response: higher interest rates or a tighter budget to slow AD.
Cost-push
- Cause: production costs rise (energy, wages above productivity, imported inputs, natural disasters).
- Diagram: SRAS shifts left.
- Price level rises; real GDP falls; unemployment rises (stagflation).
- Dilemma: slowing AD fights inflation but deepens the fall in output.
Inflation expectations. If workers expect prices to rise 6% next year, they bargain for 6% pay rises; if firms expect their costs and competitors' prices to rise, they raise their own prices sooner. Those wage and price rises then cause the inflation that was expected, and the expectation becomes self-fulfilling: a wage–price spiral. Expectations are why the RBA works to keep inflation near its target: once people believe inflation will return to 2–3%, they set wages and prices that way, and it does.
Classify the main type of inflation in each scenario.
Worked example
What kind of inflation did Australia have in 2022?
Use the data and information to identify the types of inflation in Australia in 2022.
| Year to the December quarter 2022 | |
|---|---|
| Headline CPI inflation | 7.9% |
| Trimmed mean inflation | 6.8% |
| Wage price index growth | 3.3% |
| Unemployment rate (October 2022) | 3.4% |
Information: after the 2020–21 lockdowns, household spending rebounded strongly, supported by savings built up in 2020 and a cash rate of 0.10% until May 2022. Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 drove up world energy and grain prices, and floods on the east coast in 2022 damaged crops. Shipping costs and supply chain delays raised the cost of imported goods.
Step 1: Headline against underlying
Trimmed mean inflation of 6.8% shows the rise was broad-based, not just a few volatile prices; the 1.1-point gap to headline shows volatile items (fuel, fruit and vegetables) added more.
Step 2: Demand-pull
Strong spending, high savings, a 0.10% cash rate and an unemployment rate of only 3.4% show AD pressing against capacity: demand-pull inflation.
Step 3: Cost-push and imported
Higher world energy and grain prices, flood damage and higher shipping costs raised production costs (cost-push); much of this came through the prices of imports (imported inflation).
Step 4: Expectations
Wage growth of 3.3% was far below inflation, so wages were not the driver in 2022: there was no wage–price spiral yet. The RBA's worry was that expectations of high inflation could start one.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both demand-pull (a spending rebound with low interest rates and very low unemployment) and cost-push, much of it imported (energy, grain, floods, shipping). Wages lagged prices, so inflation expectations had not yet driven a wage–price spiral.
Method
Compare headline and underlying inflation to see how broad the rise is.
Look for evidence on AD (spending, unemployment) and on costs (energy, imports, disasters).
Check wages against inflation for signs of a wage–price spiral.
Watch out for
Naming one cause only. Real episodes usually mix demand and supply causes, and good answers use the data to weigh them.
Who gains and who loses
Inflation redistributes purchasing power, and it does so most when it is unexpected: people who have locked in contracts in dollars cannot adjust.
| Group or agent | Effect of inflation |
|---|---|
| Borrowers (fixed-rate loans) | Gain when inflation is unexpected: the real value of their debt falls. They lose if the RBA then raises interest rates on variable loans. |
| Savers and lenders | Lose when interest rates are below inflation: the real value of savings falls (a negative real interest rate). |
| People on fixed incomes | Lose: income that does not rise with prices, such as some superannuation annuities, buys less. Age pensions are indexed, but with a lag. |
| Workers | Lose when wage growth lags inflation, as real wages fall; lower-paid workers whose wages are reset only once a year are hit hardest. |
| Lower-income households | Lose most: they spend a larger share of income on essentials like food, energy and rent, which often rise fastest. |
| Firms | Higher uncertainty makes planning and investment harder; menu costs of changing prices; some firms gain if prices rise faster than their costs. |
| Exporters | Lose competitiveness if Australian prices rise faster than other countries' (unless the dollar falls). |
| Government | Gains revenue from bracket creep: as nominal incomes rise, more income falls into higher tax brackets, so the average tax rate rises even when real incomes do not. |
Benefits of low, stable inflation. A little inflation is preferred to none: it gives the RBA room to cut real interest rates below zero in a downturn, it lets real wages adjust without nominal pay cuts, and it keeps the economy safely away from deflation. That is why the target is 2–3%, not 0%.
Inflation turns out to be 6% in a year when most people expected 2%. Which group is most likely to gain?
Common mistake
High prices are not inflation
Inflation is a sustained rise in the general price level. One good becoming expensive (avocados after a cyclone) is a relative price change; it adds to inflation only through its weight in the basket. And a one-off rise in the price level that then stops is not ongoing inflation: inflation measures the rate at which prices keep rising.
Summary
Headline inflation is the change in the whole CPI; underlying inflation (trimmed mean, weighted median) removes volatile items to show the trend.
Demand-pull: AD shifts right, prices and output rise. Cost-push: SRAS shifts left, prices rise and output falls (stagflation).
Imported inflation comes from higher world prices or a depreciation of the dollar.
Expectations of inflation feed into wages and prices and can make inflation self-fulfilling.
Losers: savers, fixed-income earners, workers whose wages lag, lower-income households, exporters. Gainers: borrowers on fixed rates, the government (bracket creep).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.