Lesson 11 of 11 · 19 min
Automatic stabilisers and discretionary fiscal policy
Explain how automatic stabilisers and discretionary budget decisions influence aggregate demand and stabilise the cycle, separate structural from cyclical deficits, and show both on AD–AS diagrams.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how progressive income tax and unemployment benefits act as automatic stabilisers.
- Explain discretionary fiscal policy and give Australian examples.
- Distinguish the cyclical and structural components of the budget balance.
- Apply both to AD–AS diagrams: in a downturn and in an inflationary boom.
Fiscal policy is the government's use of its budget, spending ( and transfer payments) and taxation (), to influence aggregate demand. It works in two ways. Some parts of the budget change by themselves as the economy moves through the cycle: these are automatic stabilisers. Other changes need a decision: these are discretionary fiscal policy.
Definition
Automatic stabilisers
Features of the budget that change revenue and spending with the economic cycle without any new government decision, pushing against the swing in aggregate demand.
In a downturn, as incomes and jobs fall:
- Progressive income tax: people whose incomes fall drop into lower tax brackets, so tax receipts fall faster than incomes and households keep more of what they earn. Company tax receipts fall with profits.
- Unemployment benefits and other means-tested payments: more people qualify for the JobSeeker Payment and family payments, so government spending on them rises.
Both keep disposable income, and therefore consumption, from falling as far as it otherwise would. AD still falls, but by less.
In a boom the same features work in reverse: rising incomes move into higher brackets and fewer people receive JobSeeker, so tax receipts rise faster than incomes and transfer spending falls, restraining the growth of AD and the risk of inflation.
In a downturn, AD shifts left. Automatic stabilisers make the shift smaller than it would otherwise be (here a small shift instead of a large one), so real GDP and employment fall less.
The economy enters a recession and unemployment rises. With no new government decisions, what happens to the budget?
Discretionary fiscal policy
Discretionary fiscal policy is a deliberate decision to change spending or taxes to influence AD. An expansionary stance (more spending, lower taxes) shifts AD right; a contractionary stance (less spending, higher taxes) shifts it left. Australian examples:
- 2008–09, the global financial crisis. Cash payments to households (from December 2008) and the Nation Building and Jobs Plan (February 2009), including school buildings and the home insulation program, kept spending up as world demand collapsed. Australia avoided a recession while most advanced economies had one.
- 2020, COVID-19. JobKeeper, a wage subsidy paid through employers from 30 March 2020 to 28 March 2021 ($1500 a fortnight per worker for the first six months, then at lower rates), kept millions of workers attached to their jobs; temporary increases to unemployment payments and HomeBuilder grants supported spending.
- Contractionary choices, such as cutting spending growth or letting bracket creep raise revenue, slow AD and are used when the economy is at or above capacity.
Choose a policy, or wait and watch wages and prices adjust slowly. Automatic stabilisers lean against the gap either way.
The economy has a recessionary gap. The government announces $20 billion of extra spending on infrastructure. Show the effect on the AD–AS diagram.
Worked example
Fiscal policy in the 2020 recession, applied with a diagram
Using the data and an AD–AS diagram, analyse the roles of automatic stabilisers and discretionary fiscal policy in Australia's 2020 recession.
| Indicator | Value |
|---|---|
| Real GDP growth, June quarter 2020 (on the previous quarter) | −6.8% |
| Unemployment rate, March 2020 → July 2020 | 5.2% → 7.4% |
| Underlying cash balance, 2018–19 | about 0.0% of GDP |
| Underlying cash balance, 2020–21 | −6.4% of GDP (a deficit of $134.2 billion) |
| Underlying cash balance, 2022–23 | +0.9% of GDP (a surplus of $22.1 billion) |
Discretionary stimulus shifts AD right, towards potential output.
Step 1: The shock
Lockdowns cut household consumption and business investment, shifting AD left: real GDP fell 6.8% in the June quarter 2020 and unemployment rose from 5.2% to 7.4%, opening a large recessionary gap.
Step 2: Automatic stabilisers
As incomes and profits fell, income and company tax receipts fell, and more people received JobSeeker. Without any decision, these changes pushed the budget towards deficit and limited the fall in disposable income, so AD fell less than it otherwise would have.
Step 3: Discretionary policy
The government added large discretionary stimulus: JobKeeper wage subsidies kept workers attached to their employers and their incomes up, and temporary increases to payments supported consumption. This shifted AD right (the diagram), towards potential output.
Step 4: The budget data
The underlying cash balance moved from about balance in 2018–19 to a deficit of 6.4% of GDP in 2020–21: partly cyclical (the stabilisers) and partly discretionary (the stimulus). As the economy recovered and the temporary measures ended, it returned to a surplus of 0.9% of GDP in 2022–23, showing much of the deficit was cyclical and temporary rather than structural.
Step 5: Link to the objectives
By supporting AD, fiscal policy limited cyclical unemployment and the loss of output. Unemployment fell back to 5.0% by June 2021, faster than after earlier recessions, though the stimulus also added to the demand pressure behind the 2022 rise in inflation.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The shock shifted AD left. Automatic stabilisers (falling tax receipts, rising JobSeeker) cushioned the fall; discretionary policy such as JobKeeper shifted AD back right. The deficit of 6.4% of GDP in 2020–21 was largely cyclical and temporary, as the return to surplus in 2022–23 shows.
Method
Describe the shock as a shift of AD, with data.
Explain the automatic stabilisers (no decision) and the discretionary measures (decisions) separately.
Use the budget balance to separate cyclical from structural effects.
Link the outcome to the objectives.
Watch out for
Treating the whole deficit as discretionary stimulus. Part of it was the automatic stabilisers.
Drawing the diagram without explaining it in words, or explaining without a diagram when one is asked for.
Cyclical and structural budget balances
The budget balance is revenue minus spending: positive is a surplus, negative a deficit. Part of any deficit is caused by the cycle: in a downturn the automatic stabilisers lower revenue and raise spending. That part, the cyclical deficit, disappears as the economy recovers. The rest comes from the government's own settings of tax rates and spending programs: the structural balance, the balance the budget would have if the economy were at full employment.
A structural deficit means spending exceeds revenue even at full employment. It does not fix itself as the economy grows: debt keeps rising and interest costs with it, and there is less room to respond to the next downturn. Topic 3 returns to structural deficits as a limit on fiscal policy.
In a downturn the government's budget shows a deficit of $46 billion. Treasury estimates that $30 billion of it is due to the automatic stabilisers. What is the structural deficit?
Classify each change in the budget as an automatic stabiliser or discretionary fiscal policy.
Common mistake
A deficit is not automatically expansionary policy
A budget can move into deficit because a recession has cut revenue (the stabilisers at work) without the government deciding anything. To judge the stance of discretionary policy, look at the decisions, or at the change in the structural balance, not at the headline deficit alone.
Exam tip
Applying fiscal policy "using diagrams"
The syllabus says "apply using diagrams". For a downturn: draw AD shifting left to show the fall in demand, explain that stabilisers limit the shift, then draw discretionary stimulus moving AD back right towards LRAS. For a boom: AD beyond LRAS (an inflationary gap) and contractionary policy moving it left. Name the components (, through disposable income) and the multiplier, and mention the time lags: discretionary policy takes time to recognise the problem, decide, legislate and spend.
Summary
Automatic stabilisers (progressive income tax, company tax, JobSeeker and other means-tested payments) change the budget with the cycle without a decision, softening swings in AD.
Discretionary fiscal policy is a deliberate change in spending or taxes: expansionary shifts AD right, contractionary shifts it left.
Australian examples: the 2008–09 stimulus packages; JobKeeper in 2020–21.
Budget balance = cyclical component + structural component; a structural deficit remains even at full employment.
On the AD–AS diagram: stabilisers shrink the shift of AD; stimulus moves AD right to close a recessionary gap; contraction moves it left to close an inflationary gap.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.