Lesson 3 of 8 · 16 min
Placing the economy on the economic cycle
Read a set of past indicators to place the Australian economy in a phase of the economic cycle, using the global financial crisis, the 2020 pandemic and the 2022 inflation as cases.
What you will be able to do
- Describe what the main indicators typically show in each phase of the economic cycle.
- Use leading, coincident and lagging indicators together to place the economy in a phase at a past point in time.
- Support the placement with dated data, and say what the evidence cannot show.
The economic cycle is the economy's pattern of faster and slower growth around its trend. In Topic 1 you met its four phases. Here you work the other way: given the indicators for a quarter in the past, which phase was the economy in?
No single indicator answers that. Real GDP is revised, unemployment lags, and inflation can be pushed around by oil prices or a drought. So you read several indicators together, over several quarters, and look for the pattern.
The four phases around the trend. Real GDP keeps growing in most contractions in Australia; it is the rate of growth that falls below trend.
| Phase | Real GDP growth | Unemployment rate | Inflation | Leading indicators |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expansion | Positive and rising towards or above trend | Falling | Steady, starting to rise | Rising |
| Peak | At its fastest, above trend; capacity stretched | At its lowest | Rising, often above target | Turning down |
| Contraction | Slowing below trend, possibly negative | Rising | Easing, with a lag | Falling |
| Trough | At its lowest | At or near its highest (it lags) | Low | Turning up |
Key idea
Read the indicators in order of timing
- Coincident indicators (real GDP growth, hours worked) say what the economy is doing now: growing faster or slower than trend.
- Lagging indicators (unemployment, inflation, wage growth) confirm what has already happened. Unemployment still rising when GDP has started to recover is the signature of a trough.
- Leading indicators and policy (approvals, confidence, the cash rate) show which way the economy is turning.
The global financial crisis, 2008–09. In 2007 the economy was running hot: real growth near 4½% and unemployment falling to 4.0% in February 2008, the lowest since the monthly series began in 1978, with inflation rising. Then the global financial crisis hit world trade, confidence and credit. The figure shows what followed.
Australia, 2007 to 2010. Bars: real GDP growth, year-ended (%). Line: unemployment rate at the end of each quarter (%). Source: ABS via RBA tables H1 and H5.
Worked example
Placing the economy on the cycle, 2008 to 2009
Use the data to place the Australian economy on the economic cycle in each quarter.
| Quarter | Real GDP growth, year-ended | Unemployment rate | CPI inflation, year-ended | Cash rate target |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 2008 | 2.5% | 4.3% | 5.0% | 7.00% |
| Dec 2008 | 1.7% | 4.6% | 3.7% | 4.25% |
| Jun 2009 | 1.9% | 5.9% | 1.4% | 3.00% |
| Dec 2009 | 2.8% | 5.5% | 2.1% | 3.75% |
Source: ABS via RBA tables H1, H5, G1 and A2. Unemployment rate and cash rate at the end of the quarter.
Step 1: September quarter 2008
Inflation at 5.0% was its highest in years and unemployment near its low, but growth was slowing and the RBA had just made its first cut (in early September 2008). The economy was at or just past its peak, turning down.
Step 2: December quarter 2008
Growth fell to 1.7% (real GDP fell in the quarter), unemployment had started to rise and the RBA cut the cash rate by 275 basis points in three months: contraction.
Step 3: June quarter 2009
Growth had stopped falling (real GDP grew in the first two quarters of 2009), but unemployment, a lagging indicator, was at its highest (5.9%) and the cash rate at its lowest: the trough.
Step 4: December quarter 2009
Growth back to 2.8%, unemployment falling, and the RBA raising the cash rate from October 2009: expansion.
A central bank raises rates when it judges the recovery is secure; that is a leading signal of the phase.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
September 2008: peak (turning down). December 2008: contraction. June 2009: trough. December 2009: expansion.
Method
Coincident (GDP): what is happening now.
Lagging (unemployment, inflation): confirms what has happened.
Leading and policy (the cash rate): which way it is turning.
Watch out for
Calling June 2009 a contraction because unemployment was still rising: unemployment lags.
In the June quarter 2009, real GDP had grown in each of the two previous quarters, the unemployment rate (5.9% in June 2009) was the highest it had been since 2003, and the RBA had cut the cash rate target to 3.00% in April 2009, its lowest since it began announcing a target in 1990. Which phase best describes the economy in mid-2009?
Pick a quarter. You see only what was known then. Place it, then see what came next.
The pandemic, 2020. The COVID-19 restrictions from March 2020 were a different kind of shock: the government closed parts of the economy on purpose. Real GDP fell 6.8% in the June quarter 2020 alone (5.8% over the year), the unemployment rate rose from 5.1% in February to 7.4% in June and July, and inflation was negative (−0.3% over the year to the June quarter). That quarter was a deep trough, reached in weeks rather than years. Output then recovered fast as restrictions eased, in a sharp expansion through 2021.
Worked example
Was the economy at a peak in late 2022?
In the December quarter 2022, real GDP growth was 3.3% (year-ended), the unemployment rate was 3.5% (December), CPI inflation was 7.9% (year-ended), wage price index growth was 3.3% and rising, and the RBA had raised the cash rate target from 0.10% to 3.10% since May 2022 (ABS via RBA tables H1, H5, G1, H4, A2). Assess the position of the economy on the economic cycle.
Step 1: Coincident indicator
Real growth of 3.3% was above Australia's trend rate: the economy was producing more than it could keep up.
Step 2: Lagging indicators
Unemployment at 3.5% was a tenth of a point above October's 3.4%, the lowest since the monthly series began in 1978; inflation at 7.9% was its highest since 1990; and wage growth was picking up: all signs of an economy at or beyond full capacity.
Step 3: Policy as a signal
The RBA had raised the cash rate target by 300 basis points between May and December 2022 to slow demand: it judged the economy was overheating.
Step 4: Decide and qualify
The economy was at the peak of the cycle. Part of the inflation came from supply shocks (supply chains, energy prices), so not all of it was a sign of excess demand.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The economy was at the peak of the cycle in late 2022: growth above trend, unemployment near a record low, inflation and wage growth rising, and monetary policy tightening fast.
Method
Compare growth with trend, unemployment with full employment, inflation with the target.
Use policy as evidence of how the RBA read the cycle.
Qualify the judgement with anything that complicates it.
Watch out for
Calling it an expansion because growth was positive: at a peak growth is positive and fastest; what marks the peak is capacity stretched and inflation rising.
Where the indicators put Australia in the December quarter 2022.
Use the data to place the Australian economy in the September quarter 2024.
| Indicator | Sep quarter 2023 | Sep quarter 2024 |
|---|---|---|
| Real GDP growth, year-ended | 2.2% | 0.8% |
| Unemployment rate (September) | 3.6% | 4.0% |
| CPI inflation, year-ended | 5.3% | 2.9% |
| Cash rate target (end of quarter) | 4.10% | 4.35% |
Source: ABS via RBA tables H1, H5, G1, A2.
Common mistake
A contraction is not always a recession
In the 2008–09 and 2023–24 slowdowns, Australia's real GDP kept growing over the year. They were contractions on the cycle (growth below trend, unemployment rising) without a recession (on the usual rule of thumb, two consecutive quarters of falling real GDP). Name the phase from the pattern, not from whether GDP was negative.
Exam tip
Place it, then prove it
State the phase in your first sentence, then support it with at least one coincident, one lagging and one leading indicator or policy signal, each with its value and period. Finish with what the data cannot show, such as a figure that may be revised.
Summary
Place the economy by reading several indicators over several quarters, not one figure.
Coincident indicators show the present, lagging ones confirm the past, leading ones and policy show the turn.
A trough often shows output recovering while unemployment is still at its highest (mid-2009, mid-2020).
A peak shows growth above trend, unemployment at its lowest and rising inflation (December 2022).
A contraction is growth below trend with unemployment rising; it need not include a fall in real GDP (2023–24).
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.