Lesson 6 of 8 · 16 min
Budget outcomes, causes and fiscal stance
Read a federal budget outcome as a per cent of GDP, separate its cyclical and structural causes, and decide whether the fiscal stance was expansionary or contractionary and what that did to aggregate demand.
What you will be able to do
- Read a budget outcome: the underlying cash balance, in dollars and as a per cent of GDP, for a named financial year.
- Separate the cyclical causes of a change in the budget balance (automatic stabilisers, commodity prices) from its structural, policy-driven causes.
- Decide whether a fiscal stance was expansionary or contractionary, and explain its effects with the AD/AS model.
Each year, usually in May, the Treasurer hands down a budget: a plan for the financial year that starts on 1 July. Each September, Treasury publishes the Final Budget Outcome: what actually happened in the year that ended on 30 June. The outcome is the past this topic asks you to judge, and it is rarely what the budget planned. In the 2019–20 Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook (December 2019), Treasury forecast a surplus of $5.0 billion for that year. The outcome was a deficit of $85.3 billion.
Definition
The budget balance
The budget balance is receipts minus payments for a financial year. Australia's headline measure is the underlying cash balance. A positive balance is a surplus; a negative balance is a deficit.
Compare years as a per cent of GDP: a $20 billion deficit would have been about 1.6% of GDP in 2008–09 but about 0.7% in 2025–26, because the economy (and every price in it) grew in between.
| Financial year | $ billion | Per cent of GDP |
|---|---|---|
| 2017–18 | −10.1 | −0.5 |
| 2018–19 | −0.7 | 0.0 |
| 2019–20 | −85.3 | −4.3 |
| 2020–21 | −134.2 | −6.4 |
| 2021–22 | −32.0 | −1.4 |
| 2022–23 | 22.1 | 0.9 |
| 2023–24 | 15.8 | 0.6 |
| 2024–25 | −10.0 | −0.4 |
| 2025–26 | −22.3 | −0.8 |
Key idea
Fiscal stance
The fiscal stance is the direction in which the budget pushes aggregate demand.
- Expansionary: the budget balance falls (a smaller surplus or a larger deficit). The government is adding more to spending in the economy than it takes out, so AD shifts right.
- Contractionary: the budget balance rises (a larger surplus or a smaller deficit). AD shifts left, or grows more slowly.
Judge the stance by the change in the balance as a per cent of GDP, not by whether the budget is in deficit. A deficit that shrinks is contractionary.
The change in the headline balance is the first reading, and the one a data question usually asks for. It mixes two things: the cycle's effect on receipts and payments, and the government's decisions. Whether the government chose to stimulate or restrain demand shows in the change in the structural balance, the second reading below. When the two differ, say so.
Worked example
The stance of the 2022–23 budget outcome
The underlying cash balance was −$32.0 billion (−1.4% of GDP) in 2021–22 and $22.1 billion (0.9% of GDP) in 2022–23 (Treasury, Final Budget Outcome). Calculate the change in the balance in dollars and in percentage points of GDP, state the stance, and give one cyclical cause.
Step 1: Change in dollars
: the balance improved by $54.1 billion.
Step 2: Change as a share of GDP
percentage points of GDP.
Step 3: Stance
The balance rose, so the stance was contractionary: the budget took more out of the economy than the year before, restraining aggregate demand.
Step 4: A cyclical cause
Treasury's outcome report attributes the higher tax receipts to elevated commodity prices and a strong labour market. Neither was a policy decision: both are cyclical.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The balance rose by $54.1 billion, or 2.3 percentage points of GDP: a contractionary stance. A cyclical cause: high commodity prices (and a strong labour market) lifted tax receipts.
Method
Change = new balance − old balance, keeping deficits negative.
A rise in the balance is contractionary; a fall is expansionary.
Watch out for
Subtracting 32.0 from 22.1 and getting −9.9: a deficit is negative, so subtracting it adds.
Quick check
2 marks
The underlying cash balance went from a surplus of 0.6% of GDP in 2023–24 to a deficit of 0.4% of GDP in 2024–25. Calculate the change in the balance, in percentage points of GDP, and state the stance it indicates.
Change in the balance (percentage points of GDP; use a negative number for a fall).
The stance this indicates:
Why did the balance change? A budget balance moves for two kinds of reasons, and separating them is the heart of this lesson.
The cyclical component is caused by the economic cycle, with no decision by anyone. In a downturn, incomes and profits fall, so income and company tax receipts fall; more people claim unemployment benefits, so payments rise. These are the automatic stabilisers. Australia's budget is also moved by commodity prices: when iron ore, coal and gas prices are high, mining profits and company tax receipts surge.
The structural component is the balance that would remain if the economy were at its trend level of output and commodity prices were at normal levels. It changes when the government decides to change spending or taxes: new programs, stimulus payments, tax cuts or tax rises. These are discretionary changes.
Classify each cause of a change in the budget balance as cyclical or structural.
Worked example
From a forecast surplus to an $85 billion deficit, 2019–20
In December 2019, Treasury's Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook (MYEFO) forecast an underlying cash surplus of $5.0 billion for 2019–20. The Final Budget Outcome was a deficit of $85.3 billion (4.3% of GDP): receipts were $33.1 billion lower and payments $57.7 billion higher than the MYEFO estimates (Treasury, Final Budget Outcome 2019–20). Calculate the turnaround and explain its cyclical and structural causes.
Step 1: The turnaround
: the outcome was $90.3 billion worse than forecast. Lower receipts () and higher payments () make ; the small difference is net Future Fund earnings, which the measure left out in 2019–20, and rounding.
Step 2: Lower receipts, mostly cyclical
From March 2020 the pandemic restrictions cut incomes, profits and spending. Income, company and GST receipts fell with them: the automatic stabilisers at work.
Step 3: Higher payments, mostly structural
The government decided on large temporary support from March 2020, including the JobKeeper Payment and cash flow boosts for employers: discretionary spending. Some higher payments were cyclical too, as more people claimed income support.
Step 4: Stance and effect
The balance fell 4.3 percentage points of GDP: strongly expansionary. It supported household incomes and kept workers attached to employers, cushioning the fall in aggregate demand.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The outcome was $90.3 billion worse than forecast. Receipts fell mainly for cyclical reasons (the downturn), and payments rose mainly for structural reasons (discretionary pandemic support); the stance was strongly expansionary.
Method
Compare the outcome with the forecast to find what changed.
Receipts that fall with the economy: cyclical. New programs and payments decided by the government: structural.
Watch out for
Calling the whole deficit a policy choice: more than a third of the turnaround was lost receipts.
Common mistake
A bigger deficit is not always a decision to stimulate
When the economy slows, the deficit widens by itself through the automatic stabilisers. That cyclical widening does support demand, which is the stabilisers' job, but it is not a change of policy. To say a government chose an expansionary stance, point to a structural change: a decision that added to spending or cut taxes.
The economy starts below potential. Choose a fiscal stance and watch AD, real GDP, the price level and unemployment.
Pick a year: the balance, its change on the year before, and the stance. Name the stance before it is shown.
Exam tip
Causes and effects, both
The syllabus asks for "cyclical and structural causes and effects" of a stance. A full answer names the stance with the change in the balance, gives at least one cyclical and one structural cause, and traces the effect: on AD (and so on growth, unemployment and inflation) and on public debt.
Summary
The underlying cash balance is receipts minus payments; compare financial years as a per cent of GDP.
A fall in the balance is an expansionary stance (AD right); a rise is contractionary (AD left), whether the budget is in surplus or deficit.
Cyclical causes come from the economy: automatic stabilisers and commodity prices. Structural causes are policy decisions.
A deficit that widens in a downturn is partly cyclical; a deliberate change of stance shows in the structural balance.
The Final Budget Outcome each September reports what happened, and why it differed from the forecasts.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.