Lesson 4 of 8 · 18 min
The cycle, objectives and the Phillips curve
Analyse how the economic cycle helps and harms each macroeconomic objective, the conflicts and intertemporal trade-offs between them, and the short- and long-run Phillips curves, with Australian data from 2020 to 2025.
What you will be able to do
- Explain how each phase of the cycle helps or harms the macroeconomic objectives.
- Analyse conflicting objectives and intertemporal trade-offs with past data.
- Use the short-run Phillips curve to explain the inflation–unemployment trade-off, and the long-run Phillips curve to explain why it does not last.
In December 2022 Australia's unemployment rate was 3.5%, a tenth of a point above October's 3.4%, the lowest since the monthly series began in 1978. Inflation over the year to the December quarter was 7.9%, the highest since 1990. One objective was being met better than it had been in a generation while another was badly missed, at the same moment. That is not bad luck: where the economy sits on the cycle pulls the objectives in different directions.
| Objective | In an expansion towards a peak | In a contraction towards a trough |
|---|---|---|
| Sustainable economic growth | Growth above trend, but it cannot last once capacity is stretched | Growth below trend or negative |
| Full employment | Unemployment falls, often below the NAIRU | Unemployment rises (cyclical unemployment) |
| Price stability | Demand-pull pressure: inflation rises | Inflation eases, with a lag |
| External stability | Imports rise with incomes; the current account deficit tends to widen | Imports fall; the deficit tends to narrow |
| Sustainable development | More resource use and emissions with output | Less pressure on resources, but less investment in new technology |
Key idea
Conflicting objectives and intertemporal trade-offs
Conflicting objectives: policy that helps one objective harms another. Raising interest rates to bring inflation down slows growth and costs jobs; stimulating growth can raise inflation, imports and emissions.
An intertemporal trade-off is a trade-off across time: a cost now for a benefit later, or a benefit now paid for later. Higher interest rates in 2022–23 cost growth and jobs in 2023–24 in exchange for lower inflation from 2024–25. Large deficits in 2019–20 and 2020–21 supported incomes during the pandemic in exchange for more public debt, and interest on it, in later years.
Which pairs of objectives were most clearly in conflict in Australia in 2022, when the unemployment rate fell to 3.5% and inflation rose to 7.9%? Select all that apply.
The short-run Phillips curve. In 1958 the economist A. W. Phillips found that, in the United Kingdom, years of low unemployment had been years of fast wage growth. Economists then drew the same relationship for price inflation: a downward-sloping short-run Phillips curve (SRPC). When demand is strong and unemployment low, firms compete for workers and pass higher wages on as higher prices; when unemployment is high, wage and price pressures ease. Along one SRPC, policy can choose lower unemployment or lower inflation, not both.
A rise in aggregate demand moves the economy along the SRPC from A to B: unemployment falls below the NAIRU and inflation rises.
The long-run Phillips curve. The trade-off does not last. If unemployment is held below the natural rate (the NAIRU, the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment), workers and firms come to expect the higher inflation and build it into wages and prices. The SRPC shifts up (to the right), so the same low unemployment now comes with even higher inflation. In the long run unemployment returns to the NAIRU at whatever inflation rate people expect: the long-run Phillips curve (LRPC) is vertical at the NAIRU.
This is why the RBA cares so much about inflation expectations, and why it acted in 2022–23 even though raising rates would cost jobs: keeping expectations anchored near the 2–3% target keeps the SRPC from shifting up.
The NAIRU here is illustrative: the RBA's estimates of it are uncertain and change over time. Turn on the real points to see Australia's path.
Workers and firms come to expect inflation of 5% a year instead of 2.5%. Show the effect on the Phillips curve diagram.
Australia's path, 2020 to 2025: unemployment rate (December; June 2025) against year-ended CPI inflation (December quarter; June quarter 2025). Source: ABS via RBA tables H5 and G1.
Worked example
Explaining Australia's path on the Phillips curve, 2020 to 2025
Between December 2020 and December 2022, Australia's unemployment rate fell from 6.6% to 3.5% and CPI inflation rose from 0.9% to 7.9%. Between December 2022 and December 2024 inflation fell to 2.4% while unemployment rose only to 4.0% (ABS via RBA tables H5 and G1). Use the short- and long-run Phillips curves to explain both periods.
Step 1: 2020 to 2022: a movement along the SRPC, and a shift
Strong demand from the recovery, with expansionary fiscal and monetary policy, pushed unemployment below the NAIRU: a movement up along the short-run curve, with lower unemployment and higher inflation. Supply shocks (supply chains, energy prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine) also shifted the SRPC up, so inflation rose more than the fall in unemployment alone would explain.
Step 2: 2022 to 2024: mostly a shift back
Inflation fell 5.5 percentage points while unemployment rose only 0.5 points. A movement down one SRPC would have needed a much larger rise in unemployment. Instead, supply shocks unwound and inflation expectations stayed anchored near the target, so the SRPC shifted back down, while higher interest rates moved the economy a little down along it.
Step 3: The long run
The LRPC is vertical at the NAIRU. Had expectations risen to match 7–8% inflation, the SRPC would have stayed high and bringing inflation down would have cost far more unemployment. Keeping expectations anchored is what made the 2022–24 disinflation cheap.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
2020–22: a movement up the SRPC from strong demand, plus an upward shift from supply shocks. 2022–24: mainly a downward shift of the SRPC as shocks unwound and expectations stayed anchored, with a small movement along it from higher rates.
Method
A change in demand moves the economy along the SRPC.
A change in expectations or a supply shock shifts the SRPC.
The LRPC is vertical at the NAIRU: no lasting trade-off.
Watch out for
Treating the joined-up data points as one curve.
Common mistake
The data are not one curve
Joining real points does not trace a single SRPC. Each year's point sits on that year's curve, and the curves shift with expectations and with supply shocks (in 2021–22, disrupted supply chains, higher energy prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, floods). Use the Phillips curve to explain the movements: along a curve for a change in demand, a shift of the curve for a change in expectations or a supply shock.
Exam tip
Name the trade-off and its time frame
Strong answers say which objectives conflict, why (the mechanism), over what time (short run or long run, now or later), and back it with dated data: "Between December 2022 and December 2024 inflation fell 5.5 percentage points while unemployment rose only 0.5 points, a far smaller cost than the SRPC alone would predict, because expectations stayed anchored and supply shocks unwound."
Summary
An expansion helps growth and employment but threatens price stability and external stability; a contraction does the reverse.
Conflicting objectives: policy that helps one harms another. Intertemporal trade-offs: costs now for benefits later, or the reverse.
The SRPC slopes down: lower unemployment comes with higher inflation in the short run (a movement along the curve).
Higher inflation expectations or a negative supply shock shift the SRPC up (right); the LRPC is vertical at the NAIRU.
In 2022 Australia had both very low unemployment (3.5%) and high inflation (7.9%); by 2024 inflation had fallen to 2.4% with unemployment only up to 4.0%.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.