Lesson 8 of 8 · 18 min
Evaluating economic management and writing the essay
Judge how well the Australian Government met its macroeconomic objectives over a past period with two criteria and dated evidence, and plan and write that judgement as an IA3 analytical essay.
What you will be able to do
- Build a scorecard of the objectives over a past period from dated data.
- Evaluate economic management with two economic criteria, weighing what policy could and could not control.
- Plan and structure an analytical essay that uses seen and unseen stimulus, a diagram and a justified decision.
"How well did the government manage the economy?" sounds like a question for an opinion. In economics it is a question for evidence and criteria: what were the objectives, how far were they met, how much of that was the government's doing, and at what cost. IA3 asks you to make that judgement in an analytical essay, so this lesson builds the judgement first and then the essay.
Evaluating economic management over a period
Fix the period and the objectives
Name the financial years (for example 2021–22 to 2025–26) and the objectives: sustainable growth, full employment, price stability, external stability, sustainable development, living standards.
Set a benchmark for each
Inflation: the RBA's 2–3% target. Unemployment: near the NAIRU. Growth: near trend. Use the benchmark the stimulus gives where it gives one.
Read the record
A scorecard of each indicator, year by year, with the trend.
Attribute
What did the government's budget do (its stance and measures), what did the RBA do, and what came from outside (world prices, pandemics, wars)?
Judge with two criteria
For example, effectiveness in meeting the objectives, and equity or sustainability. Weigh the evidence for and against, and decide.
| Indicator | 2021–22 | 2022–23 | 2023–24 | 2024–25 | 2025–26 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Real GDP growth, year-ended (%) | 3.8 | 2.2 | 0.9 | 1.9 | 2.1 |
| Unemployment rate, June (%) | 3.6 | 3.5 | 4.1 | 4.3 | 4.5 |
| CPI inflation, year-ended (%) | 6.2 | 6.0 | 3.8 | 2.1 | 3.9 |
| Wage price index growth (%) | 2.7 | 3.6 | 4.1 | 3.4 | 3.2 |
| Budget balance (% of GDP) | −1.4 | 0.9 | 0.6 | −0.4 | −0.8 |
Price stability and full employment, June quarter of each year. Dashed lines: the RBA's 2–3% target band. Source: ABS via RBA tables G1 and H5.
Real wage growth is approximately wage growth minus inflation. Use the scorecard to find real wage growth over the year to the June quarter 2023, in percentage points.
Reading the scorecard. Full employment was met best: the June unemployment rate was between 3.5% and 4.5% in every year, lower than for most of the time since the monthly series began in 1978, though it drifted up from 2023. Price stability was missed badly in 2021–22 and 2022–23, returned to the 2–3% band in 2024–25, and rose above it again in 2025–26. Growth slowed well below trend in 2023–24 as interest rates rose, then recovered. Real wages fell in 2021–22 and 2022–23, grew in 2023–24 and 2024–25, and fell again over the year to June 2026 (wages up 3.2%, prices up 3.9%). Each of these is a fact; the evaluation is in what you make of them.
Key idea
The attribution problem
Outcomes are not the same as management. Between 2021 and 2023, inflation was driven partly by world events (supply chains, energy prices after Russia's invasion of Ukraine) that no Australian policy caused, and it was brought down mainly by the RBA, which raises and cuts the cash rate independently of the government. A fair evaluation of the government's management asks what its budgets did: the stance each year, whether that stance suited the phase of the cycle, and what its measures did for each objective.
In 2022–23 the budget stance was contractionary (the balance rose 2.3 percentage points of GDP to a surplus) while inflation was 6.0–7.9% and unemployment about 3.5%. Which judgement is best supported by the evidence?
Criteria. IA3 lets you choose two economic criteria for your evaluation. Good pairs:
- Effectiveness (how far the objectives were met) and efficiency (at what cost: debt, interest, resources).
- Price stability and full employment, weighed against each other through the Phillips curve trade-off.
- Equity (who gained and who lost: renters, borrowers, people on fixed incomes, the young) and sustainability (whether the outcome can last: debt, the environment).
State your criteria in the introduction and use them by name in the evaluation.
Worked example
Plan an analytical essay on economic management
Plan a response to this question, using the scorecard in the lesson as stimulus: "To what extent did the Australian Government's fiscal policy support the achievement of price stability and full employment between 2021–22 and 2024–25?"
Step 1: Decode the question
"To what extent" asks for a decision on a scale, not yes or no. The focus is fiscal policy (not the RBA), two objectives (price stability, full employment) and a fixed period.
Step 2: Choose two criteria and a thesis
Criteria: effectiveness in meeting the two objectives, and appropriateness to the cycle (did the stance fit the phase?). Thesis: "Fiscal policy largely supported both objectives: contractionary while the economy was at its peak, it helped the RBA bring inflation down without a large rise in unemployment, though the return to expansionary budgets in 2024–25 added to demand while underlying inflation was still above the band."
Step 3: Plan the analysis
(1) The cycle: peak in 2022, slowdown in 2023–24 (scorecard, a cycle diagram). (2) The stance each year: contractionary in 2021–22 and 2022–23, mildly expansionary in 2023–24, expansionary in 2024–25 (budget balance, % of GDP). (3) The trade-off: inflation from 6.2% to 2.1% with unemployment from 3.6% to only 4.3% (Phillips curve).
Step 4: Plan the evaluation
Criterion 1: effectiveness, with evidence for (the outcomes) and against (the RBA did most of the work; world shocks unwound). Criterion 2: appropriateness: a contractionary stance at the peak fits; an expansionary one in 2024–25 is debatable (cost-of-living relief and tax cuts versus inflation still being brought down). A second perspective: households with mortgages and renters bore much of the adjustment.
Step 5: Conclusion
Restate the decision with its strongest reason, and what it implies for the next phase.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
A plan with a scaled thesis ("largely supported"), two named criteria, three analysis paragraphs each tied to stimulus and a diagram, an evaluation that weighs evidence and perspectives against each criterion, and a conclusion that restates the decision.
Method
Decode: the verb, the focus, the period.
Thesis with a scale; two criteria named.
Analysis: trends and relationships, each with stimulus.
Evaluation: each criterion, evidence for and against, perspectives.
Watch out for
Writing about the RBA's decisions as if they were the government's.
A thesis that only restates the question.
Put the parts of an analytical essay in order.
Write one analysis paragraph (about 120–160 words) explaining the relationship between unemployment and inflation in Australia from December 2022 to December 2024. Use the data: unemployment 3.5% (Dec 2022) and 4.0% (Dec 2024); CPI inflation 7.9% (Dec quarter 2022) and 2.4% (Dec quarter 2024); cash rate target 3.10% (Dec 2022) and 4.35% (Dec 2024). (Source: ABS via RBA tables H5, G1, A2.)
Exam tip
What the IA3 marking guide rewards
Comprehending (6): the features of the objectives, indicators and budget stances, and precise terms. Analysing (8): meaning from patterns and trends, relationships with complexity, and "perceptive selection and use of relevant seen and unseen data". Evaluating (7): a decision made with your criteria, synthesis of ideas and perspectives, reasoning from reliable evidence. Creating a response (4): an analytical essay format, a model or diagram that adds meaning, and "consistent and accurate identification of sources".
Common mistake
Description is not analysis
"Unemployment was 3.5% in 2023 and 4.1% in 2024" is description. Analysis says what it means and why: "Unemployment rose 0.6 points over 2023–24 as higher interest rates slowed demand, a lagging response to the cycle turning from its 2022 peak." Every figure you quote should be doing work in an argument.
Summary
Evaluate economic management against the objectives, with benchmarks, over a named period, using a scorecard of dated indicators.
Separate what the government's budgets did from the RBA's policy and from outside shocks (the attribution problem).
Choose two economic criteria (effectiveness, efficiency, equity, sustainability, or two objectives) and use them by name to reach a decision.
An analytical essay states its decision in the introduction, analyses patterns and relationships with sources and a diagram, evaluates with the criteria and concludes.
Cite every figure's source and period; analysis explains what the figures mean, not just what they are.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.