Lesson 9 of 9 · 20 min
Trading blocs, their outcomes for Australia, and the IA2 investigation
Analyse and evaluate the outcomes of CER, AANZFTA, the EU and NAFTA (now the USMCA) for Australia, decide on their net benefits with economic criteria, and plan an IA2 research report.
What you will be able to do
- Describe CER, AANZFTA, the EU and NAFTA/USMCA and Australia's place in or outside each.
- Analyse their outcomes for Australian growth with trade data, including trade creation and diversion.
- Decide on the net benefits of a bloc using economic criteria.
- Plan an IA2 research report that reaches a justified decision.
A trading bloc helps its members and can hurt outsiders. Australia sits inside some blocs (CER with New Zealand, AANZFTA with New Zealand and ASEAN) and outside others (the European Union, and the North American bloc that was NAFTA and is now the USMCA). The syllabus asks you to evaluate their outcomes for Australian economic growth and decide on their net benefits.
CER: Australia and New Zealand (1983). The Australia–New Zealand Closer Economic Relations Trade Agreement came into force on 1 January 1983 and removed all tariffs and quantity limits on goods traded between the two countries by 1 July 1990. It has since grown into a single economic market: citizens can live and work in either country (under the Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement of 1973), and a good that may be sold in one may be sold in the other (mutual recognition, 1998). In 2025 two-way trade was $40.8 billion; New Zealand was Australia's seventh-largest export market. CER is widely regarded as one of the most complete free trade agreements in the world, and because the two economies are similar, with few barriers to the rest of the world, it has created far more trade than it diverted.
AANZFTA: ASEAN, Australia and New Zealand (2010). AANZFTA phased out most tariffs between Australia, New Zealand and the ten ASEAN members of 2010, and an upgrade in force from 21 April 2025 simplified its rules of origin and widened services access. ASEAN as a group is one of Australia's largest trading partners: in 2025 Australia exported $79.3 billion of goods and services to ASEAN members and imported $118.1 billion from them. For many goods Australia now has several overlapping agreements with the same countries (bilateral FTAs, AANZFTA and RCEP), so the gain from any one is hard to separate.
Australia's exports of goods and services to ASEAN were $84 008 million in 2024 and $79 321 million in 2025. Calculate the percentage change, to one decimal place.
The European Union (Australia outside). The EU is an economic union of 27 members with a common external tariff and a Common Agricultural Policy that has long subsidised and protected European farmers. For Australia that meant two things. When the United Kingdom joined the European Economic Community in 1973, Australian farm exports lost their preferential access to the British market: trade diversion against Australia. And EU farm subsidies and quotas kept Australian beef, sheep meat, dairy and sugar out of the European market and, for decades, depressed world prices for them. Against that, the EU is a huge, rich market: in 2025, as a bloc, it was Australia's third-largest two-way trading partner ($110.7 billion), and its second-largest source of foreign investment. Australia buys far more from it ($84.8 billion of imports) than it sells ($25.9 billion).
The Australia–EU Free Trade Agreement, concluded on 24 March 2026 after negotiations that began in 2018, would give duty-free entry to 97.8 per cent of Australia's current exports to the EU on entry into force, and new quotas for beef (35 000 tonnes a year guaranteed) and sheep meat. It is not yet in force.
NAFTA, now the USMCA (Australia outside). The North American Free Trade Agreement among the United States, Canada and Mexico came into force on 1 January 1994. It was replaced by the United States–Mexico–Canada Agreement (USMCA) on 1 July 2020, which kept free trade among the three but tightened rules of origin: for example, 75 per cent of a car's content must now come from the region for it to trade duty-free, up from 62.5 per cent. For Australia, the bloc's main risk is diversion: Canadian and Mexican beef, grains and minerals enter the US tariff-free, while Australia relies on its own bilateral agreement with the US (AUSFTA, 2005). Since 2025 the US has applied new tariffs to most countries' goods, including Australia's, which shows that an agreement's preferences can be overridden.
Australia's two-way trade in goods and services with selected partners, 2025, $ billion. Source: DFAT, from ABS data.
Key idea
Deciding on net benefits
For a bloc Australia belongs to, weigh trade creation (cheaper imports, wider export markets, more competition, scale) against trade diversion, adjustment costs in exposed industries and the cost of complex rules of origin. For a bloc Australia is outside, weigh diversion against Australia (lost access, subsidised competition) against the growth of a richer market it still sells to, and what Australia's own agreements recover. Then decide, on your criteria, whether the net effect on Australian growth has been positive, and how sure the evidence lets you be. The Productivity Commission (2010) judged the economic gains from Australia's bilateral and regional agreements to be modest and warned that rules of origin and diversion erode them, which is a reason to argue from evidence rather than from the agreement's promises.
Worked example
The net benefits of CER for Australian growth
Analyse and evaluate the economic outcomes of the Australia–New Zealand Closer Economic Relations Trade Agreement (CER) for Australian economic growth, and decide on its net benefits using the criteria of efficiency and economic growth.
Step 1: Describe the agreement
In force from 1 January 1983; all tariffs and quantity limits on trans-Tasman goods trade removed by 1 July 1990; free movement of people (Trans-Tasman Travel Arrangement, 1973) and mutual recognition of goods and occupations (1998): close to a single economic market.
Step 2: Efficiency
Firms on both sides compete in a combined market, so the lower-cost producer of each good expands. Because both countries have low barriers to the rest of the world, little trade is diverted from cheaper outside suppliers: the agreement mostly creates trade.
Step 3: Growth
Firms can achieve larger scale, and labour moves to where it is most productive. In 2025 two-way trade was $40.8 billion; New Zealand was Australia's seventh-largest export market and a destination for manufactured and services exports that Asian markets buy less of.
Step 4: The limits
New Zealand is small (about a fifth of Australia's population), so the market it opens is limited, and the gain to Australian growth is modest relative to Asian markets. Some Australian industries faced adjustment costs as New Zealand competitors entered.
Step 5: Decide
On efficiency and growth, CER's net benefit is clearly positive though modest in scale: it is a deep agreement between similar, open economies, so creation dominates diversion. The judgement would weaken only if it held Australia back from more valuable agreements, for which there is no evidence.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
CER has a clearly positive but modest net benefit for Australian growth: as a deep agreement between two open economies it mainly creates trade and lets firms and workers move to their most productive use, but New Zealand's small size limits the gain.
Method
Describe the bloc and Australia's place in it, with dates.
Apply each criterion: creation versus diversion, scale, competition.
Use data to size the outcome; decide; qualify.
A student writes: "NAFTA is the free trade agreement between the US, Canada and Mexico." What correction should be made?
The IA2 investigation. This topic is assessed by an investigation: a research report of up to 2000 words on a current international economic issue of national, state or regional significance to Australia, relating to globalisation, barriers to trade or trade agreements. You choose your own economic criteria (no more than three), analyse the issue with current, reliable data, and evaluate an economic outcome for the purpose your teacher sets. It is worth 25% of your subject result, marked on comprehending (6 marks), analysing (8), evaluating (7) and creating a response (4).
A report that reaches a justified decision
Introduction
State the issue, the purpose and your decision in a sentence. Name your criteria (at most three) and say why they suit this issue.
Background and concepts
Define the terms the report uses (the method of protection, the agreement, globalisation) and explain the model, with a labelled diagram if the issue involves protection.
Analysis
Use current, sourced data (trade values, tariffs, prices, jobs) to show patterns and trends and the cause-and-effect relationships behind them. Analyse from more than one viewpoint.
Evaluation
Judge the outcome against each criterion in turn, weighing the strongest evidence on both sides. Synthesise: say how the criteria together point to a decision.
Recommendation and conclusion
Restate the decision, justify it, and give the condition or risk that could change it.
References
Cite every source in the text and list them. Prefer primary sources: DFAT, ABS, RBA, Productivity Commission, WTO.
Worked example
Planning an IA2 investigation: choosing criteria
Your IA2 task asks you to recommend whether the Australian Government should ratify the Australia–EU Free Trade Agreement concluded in March 2026. Choose up to three economic criteria, say what evidence you would use for each, and write the decision sentence of your introduction.
Step 1: Read the purpose
The decision is "ratify or not", so every criterion must be one on which the agreement could make Australia better or worse off.
Step 2: Choose measurable criteria
(1) Economic growth: change in export values and output in the industries that gain access (beef, sheep meat, dairy, grains, critical minerals). (2) Living standards: prices of EU imports (the agreement removes Australia's remaining tariffs on most EU goods) and jobs. (3) Resource allocation: whether resources move to Australia's comparative advantage, and the adjustment costs for industries facing EU competition.
Three criteria the data can measure are better than many vague ones; QCAA allows no more than three.
Step 3: Plan the evidence
DFAT's A-EU FTA outcomes (duty-free entry for 97.8% of current exports on entry into force; beef and sheep meat quotas), ABS trade data by partner and commodity (2025 exports to the EU $25.9 billion, imports $84.8 billion), the Productivity Commission's work on trade agreements, and views from farm groups and import-competing manufacturers.
Step 4: Plan the analysis and counter-argument
Use a tariff diagram for an EU-protected product to show the gain to Australian exporters, discuss trade creation and diversion, and answer the strongest objection (for example, that the beef quotas are small relative to the EU market, or that geographical-indication rules restrict some Australian product names).
Step 5: Write the decision sentence
"This report recommends that Australia ratify the A-EU FTA because, judged on economic growth, living standards and resource allocation, its gains to exporters and consumers outweigh its adjustment costs, provided the beef and sheep meat quotas are filled."
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Criteria: economic growth, living standards and resource allocation, each tied to measurable evidence (export values, import prices and jobs, resource movement and adjustment costs); the introduction states the decision and its condition.
Method
Start from the purpose and the decision it asks for.
Choose at most three criteria the data can measure.
Match each criterion to current, sourced evidence and plan the counter-argument.
State the decision in the introduction.
Exam tip
What lifts an investigation into the top band
The top descriptors ask for perceptive use of criteria, discerning synthesis of ideas and perspectives, and critical reasoning using reliable evidence. In practice: criteria the data can measure, data that is current and sourced, every claim linked to evidence, the strongest counter-argument answered, and a decision that follows from the criteria rather than an opinion.
Using the information in this lesson and one economic criterion, decide whether Australia's exclusion from the European Union has had a net negative effect on Australian economic growth. Justify your decision.
Summary
CER (1983) is a near-complete free trade area and single economic market with New Zealand; it mostly created trade.
AANZFTA (2010, upgraded 2025) links Australia with New Zealand and ASEAN, a group Australia traded $197 billion with in 2025.
The EU (27 members) diverted trade from Australia after 1973 and protects its farmers, but is Australia's third-largest partner; the A-EU FTA was concluded in March 2026.
NAFTA (1994) was replaced by the USMCA on 1 July 2020; its preferences risk diverting US trade from Australia.
Decide on net benefits with named criteria and evidence. IA2 rewards up to three measurable criteria, current sourced data and a justified decision.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.