Lesson 5 of 9 · 20 min
The tariff diagram and its calculations
Draw a small open economy at the world price, add a tariff, and calculate the new price, domestic production and consumption, imports, tariff revenue and the two welfare-loss triangles.
What you will be able to do
- Draw domestic demand and supply with the world price, and mark production, consumption and imports under free trade.
- Show the effect of a tariff, labelling , to , the revenue and the welfare loss.
- Calculate the effects of a tariff from linear demand and supply.
- Explain who gains and who loses, and why the triangles are a loss to the whole economy.
Australia is a small open economy in most markets: it buys too little of most goods to change their world price. It can import as much as it likes at the world price, . That one assumption makes the trade diagram simple: the world price is a horizontal line, because foreign supply to Australia is perfectly elastic at that price.
Start with domestic demand () and domestic supply () for a good Australia imports. Without trade, the price would be where they cross, . With free trade the price falls to , below :
- domestic producers supply only , where meets ;
- consumers buy , where meets ;
- imports fill the gap: imports .
Free trade in a small open economy. Domestic producers supply , consumers buy , and imports fill the gap.
Adding a tariff. A tariff of dollars per unit raises the price of every imported unit to . Domestic producers can now charge that price too, because buyers have no cheaper option. So the domestic price rises to , and:
- domestic production rises along from to ;
- consumption falls along from to ;
- imports shrink from to ;
- the government collects tariff revenue .
A $10 tariff on an illustrative market: demand , supply , world price $40, quantities in thousands of units.
Drawing a tariff diagram
Draw and label the axes
Price (P) up the side, quantity (Q) along the bottom.
Draw domestic D and S
Label them "domestic demand" and "domestic supply" (or D and S).
Draw the world price
A horizontal line below where D and S cross. Mark on S and on D, and bracket imports.
Draw the tariff
A second horizontal line above , still below the domestic equilibrium. Mark on S and on D, and bracket the smaller imports.
Shade and label the areas
The rectangle between the price lines from to is tariff revenue. The triangle between and is the production loss; the triangle between and is the consumption loss.
Common mistake
A tariff moves no curve
The tariff changes the price at which trade happens. Domestic demand and domestic supply stay where they are: producers move along S to and consumers along D to . Drawing a shifted supply curve for a tariff loses the diagram marks.
The government puts a tariff on imports of this good. Show the effect, if any, on the domestic demand and supply curves.
Raise the tariff and watch the price, domestic output, imports, revenue and the two triangles. (Illustrative market: , , .)
Calculating the effects. With straight-line demand and supply you can find every quantity by substituting a price.
Worked example
The effects of a $10 tariff
In an illustrative small open economy, domestic demand is and domestic supply is , with in dollars per unit and in thousands of units. The world price is $40. The government imposes a tariff of $10 per unit.
Calculate domestic production, consumption and imports before and after the tariff, and the tariff revenue.
Step 1: Before the tariff, at the world price of $40
; . Imports thousand units.
A small economy can buy all it wants at the world price, so the domestic price equals $40.
Step 2: The new domestic price
.
Step 3: After the tariff
; . Imports thousand units.
Step 4: Tariff revenue
Revenue imports after the tariff .
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Before: production 20 000, consumption 80 000, imports 60 000. After: price $50, production 30 000, consumption 70 000, imports 40 000; revenue $400 000.
Method
Substitute into and ; imports are the difference.
Repeat at .
Revenue = tariff × imports after the tariff.
Watch out for
Using imports before the tariff (60) for revenue.
Forgetting that is in thousands, so revenue is $400 000, not $400.
In the market above (, , ), the tariff is raised to $15. How many thousand units are imported?
Who gains and who loses. Compare the areas before and after the tariff, using the letters on the figure below.
- Consumers lose: they pay $10 more on each of the units they still buy and give up the units they no longer buy. Their surplus falls by A + B + C + D.
- Domestic producers gain A, the extra producer surplus on output that now sells at the higher price.
- The government gains C, the tariff revenue.
- The economy as a whole loses B + D: consumers' losses are larger than the gains of producers and the government by these two triangles.
Area A (not shaded) is the strip between $40 and $50 left of the supply curve: the producers' gain. B is the production loss, C the tariff revenue, D the consumption loss. Consumers lose A + B + C + D.
Key idea
Why B and D are losses
B, the production loss: the units between and are now made at home at a cost above the world price, when they could have been imported for . Resources are wasted making them.
D, the consumption loss: the units between and were worth more to consumers than they cost the world to supply, but at they are no longer bought.
The revenue rectangle C is not lost: it moves from consumers to the government (and back to the public through spending or lower taxes). It is a transfer.
Worked example
Who gains and who loses from a tariff, in dollars
In an illustrative market, and (Q in thousand tonnes, P in $ per tonne). The world price is $30 a tonne and the government imposes a tariff of $10 a tonne.
Calculate the change in consumer surplus, the change in producer surplus, the tariff revenue and the welfare loss, and show that they balance.
Illustrative market. Quantities in thousand tonnes.
Step 1: Quantities at the world price
; ; imports 100 thousand tonnes.
Step 2: Quantities at $40
; ; imports 50 thousand tonnes.
Step 3: Consumer surplus falls
The trapezium between the price lines left of demand: .
Consumers pay $10 more on the 120 they still buy and lose the surplus on the 20 they stop buying.
Step 4: Producer surplus rises
The trapezium between the price lines left of supply: .
Step 5: Revenue and the triangles
Revenue . Production loss ; consumption loss ; welfare loss .
Step 6: Check the balance
Consumers' loss producers' gain revenue welfare loss . ✓ All in $ thousand.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Consumer surplus −$1.3 million, producer surplus +$550 000, revenue $500 000, welfare loss $250 000 (production loss $150 000, consumption loss $100 000).
Method
Find , at and , at .
ΔCS = −t × (Q₂ + Q₄)/2; ΔPS = t × (Q₁ + Q₃)/2.
Revenue = t(Q₄ − Q₃); each triangle = ½ × t × the change in quantity.
Check: consumer loss = producer gain + revenue + welfare loss.
Watch out for
Treating the revenue as part of the welfare loss.
Using rectangles instead of trapeziums for the changes in surplus.
With the $15 tariff (price $55, , , free-trade and ), calculate the total welfare loss in $ thousand.
Exam tip
Ad valorem tariffs on the diagram
For an ad valorem tariff, convert it to dollars first: a 25% tariff on a world price of $40 is a unit, so the new price line is at $50. Then calculate exactly as for a specific tariff.
Summary
In a small open economy the world price is horizontal; at production is , consumption , imports .
A tariff raises the domestic price to : production rises to , consumption falls to , imports fall to . No curve shifts.
Tariff revenue , a transfer from consumers to the government.
Welfare loss : wasteful domestic production and purchases forgone.
Consumers lose; domestic producers and the government gain less than consumers lose.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.