Lesson 6 of 9 · 18 min
Quotas, subsidies and red tape on the diagram
Draw an import quota, a production subsidy and a bureaucratic barrier on the trade diagram, calculate their effects, and compare who gains and who loses under each and under a tariff.
What you will be able to do
- Draw an import quota and find the domestic price at which imports equal the quota.
- Explain quota rent and who receives it.
- Draw a production subsidy as a shift of domestic supply and calculate its cost and welfare loss.
- Explain why a bureaucratic requirement can cost more than an equivalent tariff.
A tariff is not the only way to cut imports. Governments also limit them directly, pay local producers, or make importing slow and costly. Each can cut imports by the same amount as a tariff, but each shares out the gains and losses differently, and that is what the diagrams show.
An import quota. A quota fixes the most that may be imported, say 40 thousand units. At the world price consumers want 80 and local firms supply 20, so 60 would be imported: the quota leaves a shortage, and the domestic price rises. It keeps rising until the gap between what consumers buy and what local firms supply is exactly the quota.
An import quota of 40 thousand units in the illustrative market (, , ). The price rises until imports equal the quota.
The quantities are exactly those of a $10 tariff, and so are the two welfare-loss triangles. The difference is the rectangle. Under a tariff the government collects it as revenue. Under a quota nobody pays a tax: the rectangle is quota rent, the extra profit of whoever holds the import licences, who buy at $40 overseas and sell at $50 at home. If the licences go to foreign exporters, or are handed out free to importers, the government gets nothing, so a quota costs the country more than the equivalent tariff. Selling the licences at auction would let the government collect the rent.
A quota is also rigid. If domestic demand grows, a tariff lets imports rise at the same price; a quota does not, so the whole rise in demand pushes up the price.
Start with a quota that does not bind (60 thousand, the free-trade imports), then tighten it. (Illustrative market.)
Worked example
An import quota and its equivalent tariff
In the illustrative market , (Q in thousand units), the world price is $40. The government limits imports to 20 thousand units.
Calculate the domestic price, domestic production and consumption, the quota rent and the welfare loss, and state the tariff that would have the same effect on imports.
Step 1: Set imports equal to the quota
.
The price rises until consumers' purchases exceed local output by exactly the quota.
Step 2: Production and consumption
; . Check: . ✓
Step 3: Quota rent
Licence holders buy at $40 and sell at $60: rent , that is $400 000.
Step 4: Welfare loss
Production loss ; consumption loss . Total $400 000.
Step 5: The equivalent tariff
A tariff of per unit gives the same price and quantities; it would raise $400 000 of revenue for the government instead of rent for licence holders.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Price $60; production 40 000, consumption 60 000; quota rent $400 000; welfare loss $400 000. A $20 tariff is equivalent.
Method
Solve quota for .
Quota rent = (quota price − world price) × quota.
Triangles as for a tariff, with = quota price − world price.
Watch out for
Setting (that gives the no-trade price, $70).
In the same market (, , ), the quota is set at 30 thousand units. Calculate the domestic price.
A production subsidy. Now the government pays local producers $10 for every unit they make. Their costs fall by $10 a unit, so domestic supply shifts down by the subsidy (to the right): at the world price of $40 they now receive $50 and supply 30 thousand units instead of 20.
Consumers are unaffected: they still pay the world price and buy 80 thousand. Imports fall from 60 to 50 thousand, because local output replaced 10 thousand of them.
A $10 production subsidy. Producers receive ; consumers still pay $40.
Who pays. Taxpayers pay the subsidy on every unit produced at home: . Producers gain $250 000 of surplus (the strip between $40 and $50 left of the original supply curve). The rest, the $50 000 triangle, is the welfare loss: the extra 10 thousand units cost more to make at home than to import. There is no consumption loss, because consumers still pay the world price.
That is the economist's case for a subsidy over a tariff when a government is set on protecting an industry: it protects the same output at a lower welfare cost, and its cost is visible in the budget. Against that, it must be paid for from taxes, which have their own costs, and it is easier for other countries to see as unfair under WTO rules.
The government pays domestic producers a subsidy for each unit they produce. Show the effect on the diagram.
In the same market the subsidy is raised to $15 a unit. Calculate the cost of the subsidy to taxpayers, in $ thousand.
Bureaucratic requirements. Suppose every imported unit must be inspected, certified and held at the port, adding $10 of cost per unit. On the diagram this looks like a tariff: the price of imports, and so the domestic price, rises to $50, with the same and . But nobody collects the rectangle. The $400 000 is spent on paperwork, storage and delay, a real use of resources that produces nothing of value. So the welfare loss of red tape is the two triangles plus the rectangle: $500 000 against $100 000 for the tariff.
| Measure | Price consumers pay | Domestic output | Imports | The rectangle goes to | Welfare loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $10 tariff | $50 | 30 | 40 | Government (revenue 400) | 100 |
| Quota of 40 | $50 | 30 | 40 | Licence holders (quota rent 400) | 100, plus any rent paid to foreigners |
| $10 subsidy | $40 | 30 | 50 | No rectangle: taxpayers pay 300 | 50 |
| $10 of red tape per unit | $50 | 30 | 40 | Nobody: spent on compliance | 500 |
Why is the welfare loss of a bureaucratic requirement that adds $10 a unit to imports larger than that of a $10 tariff?
Exam tip
Name the area and its owner
When you compare measures, say who gets the rectangle (government, licence holders, nobody) and which triangles appear (two for a tariff, quota or red tape; one for a production subsidy). A diagram with the areas labelled and a sentence on each is what "demonstrate the effect" asks for.
Summary
A quota raises the domestic price until equals the quota; the rectangle is quota rent to licence holders.
A quota and a tariff that give the same price give the same quantities and triangles; the quota is rigid when demand grows.
A production subsidy shifts domestic supply down by the subsidy; consumers still pay ; cost ; one welfare-loss triangle.
Red tape raises the price like a tariff but the rectangle is lost in compliance costs, so its welfare cost is largest.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 4 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.