Lesson 8 of 9 · 18 min

Trade agreements, trade creation and trade diversion

Explain bilateral, regional and multilateral agreements that involve Australia, what a modern free trade agreement does, and decide whether an agreement creates or diverts trade.

What you will be able to do

  • Tell bilateral, regional and multilateral trade agreements apart, with Australian examples.
  • Explain what a modern free trade agreement covers and its contemporary role for Australia.
  • Use costs of supply to decide whether an agreement creates or diverts trade, and explain the effect on efficiency.

When the China–Australia Free Trade Agreement came into force in December 2015, Chinese tariffs on Australian beef, dairy, wine and many other goods began falling to zero. Australian wine exports to China grew quickly over the next few years. A trade agreement changes who can sell where, and at what price, but not always in the direction that is best for the world.

Definition

Three kinds of trade agreement

  • Bilateral: between two parties, such as Australia and Japan (JAEPA) or Australia and the United Kingdom (A-UKFTA).
  • Regional (plurilateral): among several countries, usually in one region, such as AANZFTA, RCEP or the CPTPP.
  • Multilateral: among (nearly) all trading nations, negotiated in the World Trade Organization, such as the agreements of the Uruguay Round that set up the WTO in 1995, or the Trade Facilitation Agreement (in force 2017).
Australia's free trade agreements in force, with entry-into-force dates (DFAT, as at November 2026).
AgreementPartnersIn forceType
ANZCERTA (CER)New Zealand1 January 1983Bilateral
SAFTASingapore28 July 2003Bilateral
AUSFTAUnited States1 January 2005Bilateral
TAFTAThailand1 January 2005Bilateral
ACl-FTAChile6 March 2009Bilateral
AANZFTANew Zealand and the ten ASEAN members of 20101 January 2010 (upgrade in force 21 April 2025)Regional
MAFTAMalaysia1 January 2013Bilateral
KAFTARepublic of Korea12 December 2014Bilateral
JAEPAJapan15 January 2015Bilateral
ChAFTAChina20 December 2015Bilateral
CPTPPTen other Pacific Rim economies, and the UK from 202430 December 2018Regional
A-HKFTAHong Kong17 January 2020Bilateral
PAFTAPeru11 February 2020Bilateral
IA-CEPAIndonesia5 July 2020Bilateral
PACER PlusPacific island countries and New Zealand13 December 2020Regional
RCEPThe ten ASEAN members of 2022, China, Japan, Korea and New Zealand1 January 2022Regional
AI-ECTAIndia29 December 2022Bilateral
A-UKFTAUnited Kingdom31 May 2023Bilateral
UAE-CEPAUnited Arab Emirates1 October 2025Bilateral

The Australia–EU Free Trade Agreement was concluded on 24 March 2026. It must still be formally signed and then ratified by both sides, so at November 2026 it was not yet in force. An agreement with India that goes further than AI-ECTA (the CECA) is under negotiation.

How agreements fit WTO rules. The WTO's most-favoured-nation rule says a member must give all members its lowest tariff. Free trade agreements are an allowed exception (GATT Article XXIV), provided they remove barriers on "substantially all" trade between the partners. So Australia can charge 5% on a good from Brazil and 0% on the same good from Japan.

Classify each agreement as bilateral, regional or multilateral.

The contemporary role of "free trade" agreements. The syllabus puts "free trade" in quotation marks for a reason: few FTAs make trade fully free. They phase tariffs out over years, keep quotas on sensitive goods (beef and sugar into many markets) and exclude some goods altogether. A modern FTA is also about much more than tariffs:

  • services (access for banks, education providers, professionals) and the movement of business people;
  • investment rules and screening thresholds;
  • rules of origin, which decide whether a good counts as made in a member country;
  • e-commerce, government procurement, intellectual property, standards and biosecurity procedures;
  • in recent agreements, chapters on labour, the environment and climate.

Because the WTO's multilateral negotiations have stalled since the Doha Round began in 2001, FTAs have become the main way Australia lowers barriers to its exports. DFAT said in 2024 that its agreements covered nearly 80 per cent of Australia's trade, and the government expects that share to reach 88 per cent once the agreement with the EU is in force.

Note

The "noodle bowl"

Each agreement has its own tariff schedule and rules of origin. An exporter selling to Japan may be able to use JAEPA, the CPTPP or RCEP, each with different paperwork. This tangle of overlapping rules raises compliance costs, and many firms do not use the preferences they are entitled to. Economists call it the "spaghetti bowl" or "noodle bowl".

Trade creation and trade diversion. An FTA removes tariffs for members only. Whether that is good for efficiency depends on who would otherwise supply the good. The economist Jacob Viner (1950) gave the test.

  • Trade creation: the agreement lets a low-cost partner replace dearer domestic production, and consumers buy more at the lower price. Resources move to lower-cost producers: efficiency rises.
  • Trade diversion: the agreement switches imports from the lowest-cost supplier outside the agreement to a dearer partner inside it, only because the partner no longer pays the tariff. The country now pays more for each unit it imports than before, and the government loses its tariff revenue: efficiency falls.
Interactive

Sign the agreement

Australia (home), a partner and the rest of the world. A $10 tariff applies to everyone until the agreement removes it for the partner only. (Illustrative costs.)

Worked example

Trade creation or trade diversion?

  • Complex familiar

In an illustrative market, Australia's demand is Qd=120−PQ_d = 120 - P and domestic supply Qs=P−20Q_s = P - 20 (Q in thousand units). The rest of the world can supply any amount at $40 a unit and a partner country at $45. Australia charges a $10 tariff on all imports. It then signs a free trade agreement with the partner.

Decide whether the agreement creates or diverts trade, and calculate the gain from trade creation, the cost of trade diversion and the net effect.

6 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Compare tariff-inclusive prices before, and partner (tariff-free) against world (with tariff) after.

  2. Diversion if the new source is not the lowest-cost supplier.

  3. Creation gain = the two triangles; diversion cost = (partner cost − world cost) × imports switched.

Watch out for

  • Calling it trade creation because consumers pay less.

Australia charges a $6 tariff on all imports of a good. The lowest-cost supplier, Country W, can supply it at $30; Country P at $34. Australia signs an FTA with P only. After the agreement, Australia imports from

Choose one answer

Common mistake

A lower price is not proof of trade creation

Consumers pay less in both cases. The test is the source: if imports replace dearer home production, or a partner is already the lowest-cost supplier, the agreement creates trade. If they switch from a cheaper outsider to a dearer partner, it diverts trade. Diversion happens when the partner's cost is above the lowest world cost but below the world cost plus the tariff.

Explain why an Australian economist might argue that unilaterally cutting a tariff to zero for all countries is better for efficiency than removing it for one FTA partner.

Write it out as you would in an exam. Put maths between dollar signs, like $x^2 + 1$. Worth 1 mark.

0 / 4000

Summary

  • Bilateral agreements have two parties (ChAFTA), regional ones several (AANZFTA, RCEP, CPTPP), multilateral ones (nearly) all WTO members.

  • In November 2026 Australia had 19 FTAs in force; the A-EU FTA was concluded in March 2026 but not yet in force.

  • Modern FTAs cover services, investment, rules of origin, e-commerce and more, and have become Australia's main tool for opening markets as WTO negotiations stalled.

  • Trade creation: a cheaper partner replaces dearer home production (efficiency rises). Trade diversion: a dearer partner replaces a cheaper outsider (efficiency falls).

  • Diversion occurs when the partner's cost is above the world's lowest cost but below that cost plus the tariff.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 8 of 90% read

Save your progress with a free account