Lesson 6: Boom and bust, and resources that cannot move
How immobile labour misallocates resources
SkillBoom, bust and immobile resources
Worked example
Explain how the closure of the car assembly plants at Altona (Toyota, 3 October 2017) and Elizabeth (Holden, 20 October 2017) could have led to a misallocation of resources, referring to two types of immobility. Suggest one measure that would reduce the misallocation. (5 marks)
Step 1: State the market signal
Falling sales and the end of production signalled that the labour, land and capital used in car assembly were now more valued in other industries.
Step 2: Occupational immobility
Assembly workers had skills specific to car making. Moving into growing industries, such as health care or electrical trades, needed qualifications that take time and money to gain, so many could not change occupation quickly.
Step 3: Geographical immobility
The plants were in particular suburbs. Workers with mortgages, partners' jobs and children in local schools found it costly to move to places with vacancies, and housing near jobs could be expensive.
Step 4: The misallocation
Labour stayed unemployed, or took lower-skilled work below its potential, while other industries reported skill shortages. Specialised plant sat idle. Resources were not in their most valued uses, so output was below what the economy could produce.
Step 5: A measure
Subsidised retraining (for example fee-free TAFE places in trades with shortages) reduces occupational immobility; relocation assistance or information about vacancies reduces geographical immobility.
Answer
Specific skills (occupational immobility) and the costs of moving (geographical immobility) kept workers out of industries that needed them, leaving labour unemployed or under-used while shortages persisted elsewhere; subsidised retraining would reduce the misallocation.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Say what the price signal was telling resources to do.
Name each type of immobility and the barrier in this case.
Say what happened to the resources: idle, under-used, shortages elsewhere.
Match a measure to the barrier.
Watch out for
Describing the closure without saying why resources could not move.