Lesson 5: Public goods, free riders and missing markets
Why nobody sells street lighting
SkillPublic goods and missing markets
Worked example
A street of 60 households has no lighting. A light would cost $1800 a year to install and run. Each household values it at $40 a year.
(a) Is providing the light allocatively efficient? (b) Explain why no single household pays for it. (c) The residents try voluntary contributions; half of them contribute $40 each and the rest free ride. Is the light provided? (d) Explain how the council solves the problem.
Step 1: Compare total benefit with cost
Total value a year, more than the $1800 cost. Providing it adds $600 a year of net benefit: it is efficient.
Step 2: One household's view
A household that paid $1800 alone would get only $40 of benefit. Nobody pays, so the market supplies nothing.
Step 3: Voluntary contributions
, short of $1800. The light is not provided. Each free rider expected to enjoy the light without paying, because it is non-excludable.
Step 4: The council's solution
The council provides the light and funds it from compulsory rates: $30 per household covers the $1800, and each household gains $40 − $30 = $10 a year.
Compulsory payment removes the option to free ride.
Answer
(a) Yes: benefit $2400 > cost $1800. (b) Each household's own benefit ($40) is far below the cost. (c) No: $1200 < $1800. (d) Provide it from rates of $30 per household.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Efficient if total benefit to everyone exceeds cost.
Non-excludable: each person's incentive is to free ride.
Tax-funded provision makes everyone pay their share.
Watch out for
Concluding that because no-one buys the light, nobody wants it. The free rider problem hides the true demand.