Lesson 4: Positive externalities, and all four diagrams compared
The welfare gain forgone when too few people are vaccinated
SkillsExternality diagramsTaxes and subsidies
Worked example
In an illustrative city, 70 000 people a year buy a flu vaccination at the market price. Each vaccination protects other people as well, an external benefit estimated at $50 per dose at every level of vaccination. The socially optimal number is 90 000 a year.
(a) Identify the type of externality and sketch the diagram. (b) Calculate the welfare gain the market forgoes. (c) The government pays a subsidy equal to the external benefit. What is its cost if vaccinations rise to the optimum?
Step 1: Identify the externality
The benefit to others comes from consuming the vaccine: a positive consumption externality. MSB lies $50 above MPB; supply is MPC = MSC.
Step 2: Sketch
Draw MPC = MSC rising, MPB falling, and MSB parallel above MPB. Mark where MPB meets MPC and where MSB meets MSC. Shade the triangle between MSB and MPC from to .
Step 3: Welfare gain forgone
a year.
Step 4: Cost of the subsidy
The subsidy is paid on every dose at the new quantity: a year.
The subsidy cost is far larger than the welfare gain because most of it is a transfer to people who would have been vaccinated anyway, not a cost to society as a whole.
Answer
(a) Positive consumption externality. (b) $500 000 a year. (c) $4.5 million a year.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify where the externality arises and whether it is a cost or a benefit.
Welfare gain forgone .
Subsidy cost the quantity after the subsidy.
Watch out for
Paying the subsidy only on the 20 000 extra doses: a per-unit subsidy is paid on every dose.