Lesson 1: Pure substances and mixtures
Is the ring pure gold?
SkillMelting point and density data
Worked example
A seller claims a ring is pure gold (density ). The ring has a mass of . When it is lowered into a 10 mL measuring cylinder, the water level rises from to . Each reading has an uncertainty of .
Calculate the density of the ring and evaluate the seller's claim.
Step 1: Find the volume by displacement
The ring pushes aside its own volume of water, so the rise in level is the ring's volume. .
Step 2: Calculate the density
, about . The volume has only one significant figure, so this value is rough; the next step works out how rough.
Step 3: Allow for the uncertainty
The volume is a difference of two readings, so its uncertainty is : lies between 0.7 and 0.9 mL. So lies between and .
A small volume measured in a measuring cylinder has a large percentage uncertainty (about 13 % here), so check whether the accepted value could still fit.
Step 4: Compare with pure gold
Even the largest possible value, , is below . The ring is less dense than gold, so it must contain a less dense metal: it is an alloy (a mixture), such as gold with silver or copper.
Answer
The ring's density is about (between 14.0 and allowing for uncertainty), below gold's , so the claim is not supported: the ring is a gold alloy, not pure gold. A larger sample or a more precise volume measurement (weighing the ring in water, for example) would make the test more convincing.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Volume by displacement: final level minus initial level.
.
Work out the range of possible densities from the uncertainty.
Compare that range with the accepted value before judging.
Watch out for
Using the final water level (5.8 mL) as the ring's volume.
Writing the volume as 0.80 mL. The readings give 0.8 mL, one significant figure; adding a zero claims a precision you do not have.
Judging the claim without considering the measurement uncertainty.