Lesson 1: Pure substances and mixtures
Using melting data to judge purity
SkillsMelting point and density dataPure substances and mixtures
Worked example
Pure benzoic acid melts at 122 °C. Two students each made a sample of benzoic acid and measured its melting behaviour.
| Sample | Started to melt | Fully melted |
|---|---|---|
| A | 121.5 °C | 122.5 °C |
| B | 113 °C | 119 °C |
Determine which sample is pure and which contains impurities. Justify your answer.
Step 1: Recall what a pure substance does
A pure substance melts sharply, at one fixed temperature (within about 1 °C in a school melting-point test).
A pure substance has a fixed composition, so every part of it needs the same temperature to melt.
Step 2: Look at sample A
Sample A melts over 1 °C (121.5–122.5 °C), centred on the known melting point of 122 °C. It behaves like the pure substance.
Step 3: Look at sample B
Sample B melts over a 6 °C range, and the whole range (113–119 °C) is below 122 °C.
Impurities disrupt the regular arrangement of particles in the solid, so it starts to melt at a lower temperature, and the composition of the remaining solid changes as it melts, which spreads melting over a range.
Step 4: Conclude with the evidence
A is pure; B contains impurities (it is a mixture), shown by its lower and wider melting range.
Answer
Sample A is pure: it melts sharply at the accepted 122 °C. Sample B is impure: it melts over a range (113–119 °C) that is lower than 122 °C.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Compare each melting range with the pure substance's melting point.
Sharp and at the accepted value: pure. Lower and over a range: impure.
Watch out for
Saying B is pure because it still melts at a definite temperature. A mixture also melts, but over a range.
Forgetting to quote the data in the justification.