Lesson 9 of 12 · 19 min
Limiting reactants and percentage yield
Decide which reactant runs out first, use it to find the theoretical yield, and compare it with the experimental yield as a percentage yield.
What you will be able to do
- Determine the limiting reactant from the masses of two reactants.
- Calculate the theoretical yield from the limiting reactant and the mass of excess reactant left over.
- Discriminate between experimental and theoretical yield.
- Calculate percentage yield and explain why it is usually below 100 %.
A cheese sandwich needs two slices of bread and one slice of cheese. With 10 slices of bread and 3 slices of cheese, you can make only 3 sandwiches: the cheese runs out first and 4 slices of bread are left over. The cheese limits how many sandwiches you can make.
Reactions work the same way, except that you count in moles.
Definition
Limiting and excess reactants
The limiting reactant is the reactant that is completely used up first. It decides the maximum amount of product. Any other reactant is in excess: some of it is left over when the reaction stops.
. Four need only two , so hydrogen runs out first and one is left over.
Finding the limiting reactant
Convert each reactant's mass to moles
for both.
Use the mole ratio to see what one reactant needs
Calculate the moles of the second reactant needed to use up all of the first.
Compare need with supply
If more is needed than you have, the second reactant is limiting. If less is needed, the first reactant is limiting and the second is in excess.
Base every product calculation on the limiting reactant
Use its moles and the mole ratio to find the product.
Worked example
Limiting reactant when hydrogen burns
A mixture of 4.00 g of hydrogen and 16.0 g of oxygen is ignited.
(a) Which reactant is limiting?
(b) What mass of water forms?
(c) What mass of the excess reactant is left over?
Step 1: Moles of each reactant
,
Step 2: Compare need with supply
All the hydrogen would need of , but only 0.500 mol is present. Oxygen runs out first.
Hydrogen has the smaller mass, but its molecules are so light that 4.00 g is almost 2 mol. Always compare moles through the ratio.
Step 3: (b) Water from the limiting reactant
, so
Step 4: (c) Hydrogen left over
Hydrogen used: . Left: , which is .
Step 5: Check conservation of mass
of reactants; of water plus leftover hydrogen.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Oxygen (b) 18.0 g of water (c) 1.98 g of hydrogen
Method
Moles of each reactant.
Moles of one needed to react with all of the other; compare.
Product (and leftover) from the limiting reactant.
Watch out for
Choosing hydrogen as limiting because its mass is smaller.
Calculating the water from the hydrogen, which gives an impossible 35.7 g.
A reactor contains 14.0 g of nitrogen and 4.00 g of hydrogen. Which reactant is limiting?
Common mistake
The smaller mass is not always limiting
In the check above, there is less hydrogen by mass (4.00 g against 14.0 g), yet hydrogen is in excess. Mass alone tells you nothing until you convert to moles and apply the mole ratio.
Yield. The theoretical yield is the mass of product calculated from the limiting reactant, assuming it all reacts and nothing is lost. The experimental yield (or actual yield) is the mass you actually collect and weigh. They are rarely the same, so chemists compare them:
Worked example
Percentage yield of aspirin
Aspirin is made from salicylic acid and excess ethanoic anhydride:
A student starts with 2.00 g of salicylic acid and collects 1.85 g of dry, pure aspirin. Calculate the theoretical yield and the percentage yield.
Step 1: Identify the limiting reactant
Ethanoic anhydride is in excess, so salicylic acid is limiting.
Step 2: Moles of salicylic acid
, so
Step 3: Theoretical yield of aspirin
The ratio is 1 : 1. , so the theoretical yield is .
Step 4: Percentage yield
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Theoretical yield 2.61 g; percentage yield 70.9 %.
Method
The reactant not in excess is limiting.
Theoretical yield from its moles and the mole ratio.
Experimental ÷ theoretical × 100 %.
Watch out for
Using the mass ratio 2.00 → 2.00 g as the theoretical yield. The product has a different molar mass.
A reaction has a theoretical yield of 12.5 g. A student collects 10.9 g of dry product. Calculate the percentage yield, to three significant figures.
Note
Why yields are below 100 %
- The reaction is incomplete: it may be slow, or reach equilibrium before all the reactant is used.
- Side reactions turn some reactant into unwanted products.
- Product is lost when it is filtered, transferred, washed or recrystallised.
- The reactants are impure, so there was less reactant than weighed.
A percentage yield above 100 % means the product is not pure: it is still wet, or contains unreacted reactant or another substance.
Worked example
Limiting reagent and yield in a precipitation investigation
In an investigation, a student dissolves 3.31 g of lead(II) nitrate and 3.00 g of potassium iodide in separate beakers of water, mixes them, then filters, washes and dries the yellow precipitate:
The dry precipitate has a mass of 3.87 g.
(a) Determine the limiting reactant.
(b) Calculate the theoretical yield and the percentage yield of lead(II) iodide.
(c) A second group obtained 4.50 g from the same masses. Evaluate their result.
Step 1: Moles of each reactant
, so . , so .
Step 2: Compare with the 1 : 2 ratio
All the lead(II) nitrate needs of KI, but only 0.01807 mol is present. Potassium iodide is limiting.
Here the reactant with the smaller mass happens to be limiting, but only because of the 1 : 2 ratio and the molar masses. You can't tell until you compare moles.
Step 3: Theoretical yield
. , so the theoretical yield is .
Step 4: Percentage yield
Step 5: (c) Evaluate the second result
. A yield above 100 % is impossible for a pure product, so their precipitate contained something extra: most likely water (it was not dried to constant mass) or potassium nitrate that was not washed out. They should dry the precipitate in an oven and reweigh until the mass is constant, and wash it well with distilled water.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Potassium iodide (b) Theoretical yield 4.17 g; percentage yield 92.9 % (c) 108 %: the product was impure, probably still wet or containing potassium nitrate, so drying to constant mass and better washing are needed.
Method
Moles of each reactant; compare need with supply through the ratio.
Theoretical yield from the limiting reactant.
Percentage yield; above 100 % means an impure (often wet) product.
Watch out for
Using the 1 : 1 ratio and choosing lead(II) nitrate as limiting.
Saying a yield over 100 % means the reaction "made extra product".
A student's percentage yield of a precipitate is 78 %. Which of these could explain the low yield? Select all that apply.
Summary
The limiting reactant is used up first and sets the maximum amount of product; the others are in excess.
Find it by comparing moles needed with moles available, using the mole ratio; never by comparing masses.
Theoretical yield: calculated from the limiting reactant. Experimental yield: what you actually collect.
Percentage yield = experimental ÷ theoretical × 100 %; above 100 % signals an impure or wet product.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.