Lesson 5 of 8 · 20 min
Hollow solids and real containers
Find the volumes of hollow solids by subtracting the inner solid from the outer one, model containers filled to a depth, and use technology and simple comparisons to judge your answers.
What you will be able to do
- Find the volume of a hollow solid as .
- Write the volume of liquid in a container as a function of its depth, and solve for the depth.
- Use technology for volumes with no convenient antiderivative.
- Evaluate the reasonableness of a volume by comparing it with a cylinder or cone.
Real objects are rarely solid all the way through. A pipe, a bead, a cup and a ring all have a hole in the middle. Rotate a region that does not touch the axis, and the strips sweep out washers: discs with a disc-shaped hole cut out.
Rotate the region between and about the -axis. Each strip makes a washer with outer radius and inner radius .
Key idea
Hollow solids
If on , rotating the region between them about the -axis gives
the outer solid minus the hole. The same idea works about the -axis, with -values in terms of .
Common mistake
Not the square of the difference
. That would rotate a region of height sitting on the axis, a solid with no hole. For and on , the correct volume is ; the wrong formula gives .
Worked example
A hollow solid from and
The region enclosed by and is rotated about the -axis. Determine the exact volume of the solid formed.
Step 1: Find the intersections
, so or .
Squaring both sides can introduce false solutions, so check them. Both and satisfy the original equation.
Step 2: Identify the outer and inner radii
At , . The outer radius is and the inner radius is .
Step 3: Subtract the squares
The solid is the outer solid with the inner solid (a cone) removed.
Step 4: Evaluate
Step 5: Check by another route
Outer solid: . Inner cone: . Difference: . ✓
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The volume is cubic units.
Method
Find the intersections, which become the terminals.
Identify the outer and inner radii.
Integrate .
Check with a known volume such as a cone if one appears.
Watch out for
Using , the square of the difference.
The region between and is rotated about the -axis. Determine the exact volume of the solid.
Containers filled to a depth. Stand a bowl upright with its lowest point at the origin, and let its inside surface be the curve rotated about the -axis. If the liquid is deep, the liquid itself is a solid of revolution from to :
That gives a formula for the volume at any depth, which you can solve for the depth that holds a given volume.
Worked example
How deep is 500 mL in a parabolic bowl?
The inside of a salad bowl is formed by rotating the curve , for , about the -axis. Lengths are in centimetres.
a) Determine the capacity of the bowl.
b) Determine the depth of the water when the bowl holds 500 mL, to the nearest millimetre.
c) Evaluate the reasonableness of your answers.
Step 1: Rewrite the curve in terms of y
. The rim is at , which is cm.
The bowl stands upright, so rotate about the -axis and integrate with respect to .
Step 2: Write the volume at depth h
Water of depth fills the bowl from to :
Step 3: Find the capacity
, about 804 mL.
Step 4: Solve for the depth that holds 500 mL
, so solve :
Step 5: Evaluate reasonableness
A cylinder of radius 8 cm and height 8 cm holds ; the bowl holds exactly half of that, which matches the shape (it is narrow at the bottom). 500 mL is a little under two-thirds of the capacity, yet needs about four-fifths of the depth: that also makes sense, because the bowl is widest near the top, so the last few centimetres hold the most water.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
a) . b) About cm deep. c) Both are consistent with the bowl being half a cylinder's volume and widest at the top.
Method
Write in terms of and find the -value of the rim.
Build as a function of the depth.
Solve the given volume, converting mL to .
Compare with a cylinder of the same radius and height.
Watch out for
Using from to as the terminals of a integral.
Assuming half the volume is at half the depth.
Without technology
Use it when has an antiderivative you know. Give the exact volume, then a decimal with units if the context needs one.
With technology
Profiles such as give integrands that are tedious or impossible by hand. Enter in the numerical integration tool, in radians, and write down the integral you evaluated.
A vase is 20 cm tall. Its inside surface is formed by rotating , for , about the -axis, with lengths in centimetres. Use technology to determine the capacity of the vase, to the nearest cubic centimetre.
Exam tip
Evaluate reasonableness with a comparison
A quick bound catches most errors. Squeeze the solid between two cylinders using the smallest and largest radius, or compare it with a cone or hemisphere of the same size. Then say so in a sentence: "The volume lies between the volumes of cylinders of radius 2 cm and 4 cm, so it is reasonable."
Summary
Hollow solid: , outer radius squared minus inner radius squared.
Never square the difference: .
For a container filled to depth , ; solve the given volume for .
Use technology for awkward profiles, and write down the integral you evaluated.
Check every volume against a simple cylinder, cone or hemisphere.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.