Lesson 4 of 8 · 17 min

Obedience, conformity and social norms

Explain how obedience, conformity and social norms change behaviour, and interpret Cialdini and colleagues' (2006) field experiment on descriptive and injunctive norms in the Petrified Forest.

What you will be able to do

  • Distinguish obedience from conformity, and normative from informational influence.
  • Explain how obedience and conformity lead to behaviour change.
  • Describe descriptive and injunctive norms, as Cialdini et al. (2006) describe them.
  • Interpret the results of the Petrified Forest field experiment and explain why some norm messages backfire.

A teacher says "phones away" and thirty phones disappear. At a concert, the crowd stands for an encore and you stand too, though no one asked you to. In a carpark, a sign says "Most visitors take their rubbish home", and you pick up your chip packet. Three different kinds of social influence changed behaviour in each case: obedience, conformity and a social norm.

Obedience

Changing behaviour in response to a direct instruction from a person seen as having authority.

  • There is an explicit command.
  • The source has higher status and legitimate power.
  • The person often acts against their own judgement and feels less responsible ("I was told to").

Conformity

Changing behaviour or beliefs to match a group, in response to real or imagined group pressure.

  • There is no instruction: the pressure is implicit.
  • The source is usually peers of equal status.
  • People often deny they were influenced ("I just agreed with them").

How obedience changes behaviour. From childhood we learn that people in some roles (parents, teachers, police, doctors) have the right to give instructions and that following them is usually sensible. When an instruction comes from someone with legitimate power, people tend to hand over responsibility for the act to that person. Milgram called this the agentic state: the person sees themselves as an agent carrying out someone else's wishes, so they will do things they would not choose to do on their own. Obedience is stronger when the authority is close by and seen as legitimate (a uniform, an institution), and weaker when others refuse.

How conformity changes behaviour. Deutsch and Gerard (1955) described two reasons people conform:

  • Normative influence: conforming to be liked and accepted, and to avoid standing out or being rejected. The person may privately disagree (compliance, in Kelman's terms).
  • Informational influence: conforming because you believe the group is right, especially when the situation is ambiguous or you are unsure. The person changes what they believe (internalisation).

Conformity is stronger when the group is unanimous, when it is larger (up to a point), when the task is hard or ambiguous, and when the group matters to the person. You will see the evidence in Asch's research.

Classify each behaviour change as obedience or conformity.

Definition

Social norms (Cialdini et al. 2006)

A social norm is an unwritten rule, shared by a group, about how its members should behave. Cialdini and colleagues distinguish two kinds that motivate behaviour differently:

  • Descriptive norms, the norms of "is": what most people actually do. They guide behaviour by example ("if everyone is doing it, it must be sensible").
  • Injunctive norms, the norms of "ought": what most people approve or disapprove of. They guide behaviour through social rewards and punishments.

A norm changes behaviour only when it is in focus: noticed and salient at the moment of acting.

This creates a trap for anyone trying to stop a bad behaviour. Campaigns often stress how common the problem is ("Thousands of people litter every day") to show it matters. But that message is a descriptive norm, and it tells the audience that most people do it. Cialdini and colleagues tested this in a setting where the trap was real.

Cialdini et al. (2006). Arizona's Petrified Forest National Park was losing about a ton of petrified wood a month to visitors taking small pieces, and its signs warned that the park was "being vandalised every day". The researchers placed 20 marked pieces of petrified wood along each of three visitor paths, and at the start of each path put up one of four signs, in a 2 × 2 factorial design:

  • Type of norm: descriptive or injunctive.
  • Wording (focus): negatively worded (a strong focus on the norm) or positively worded (a weak focus).

Signs were rotated so each appeared equally often at each path and time, and after each 2-hour block a researcher counted how many marked pieces had been taken. In total 2655 visitors walked the paths over five weekends. The dependent variable was the percentage of marked pieces stolen.

The four signs and the percentage of marked pieces of wood stolen (Cialdini et al. 2006). Pieces placed: 300 per condition, except 240 for the descriptive negative sign, because a rainstorm stopped one block.
SignType of normWordingTheft
"Many past visitors have removed the petrified wood from the park, changing the state of the Petrified Forest."DescriptiveNegative (strong focus)7.92%
"The vast majority of past visitors have left the petrified wood in the park, preserving the natural state of the Petrified Forest."DescriptivePositive (weak focus)5.00%
"Please don't remove the petrified wood from the park."InjunctiveNegative (strong focus)1.67%
"Please leave petrified wood in the park."InjunctivePositive (weak focus)5.33%

Theft of marked wood under each sign (Cialdini et al. 2006): "Many removed" and "Most left" are the descriptive signs, "Please leave" and "Please don't" the injunctive ones. The strongly focused descriptive sign produced the most theft; the strongly focused injunctive sign the least.

Findings. The negatively worded descriptive sign, which told visitors that many others had taken wood, produced the most theft (7.92%), nearly five times the theft under the negatively worded injunctive sign (1.67%), which produced the least. The injunctive negative sign produced significantly less theft than the other three combined, and the descriptive negative sign significantly more. The two positively worded signs fell in between and did not differ from each other.

Conclusion. When an undesirable behaviour is common, a message should focus people on the injunctive norm (that the behaviour is disapproved of) and avoid a descriptive norm that says many people do it. A descriptive message that normalises the problem can make it worse.

Interactive

Choose the sign

Pick each sign and compare the theft rates. Which of the four is most like the park's own warning that it was being vandalised every day?

Under the "Please leave petrified wood in the park" sign, 16 of the 300 marked pieces of wood were stolen. Calculate the percentage stolen, to two decimal places.

in %

Round to 2 decimal places.

Worked example

Interpret the Petrified Forest signs

  • Complex familiar
  • Technology active

In Cialdini et al. (2006), 19 of 240 marked pieces of wood were stolen under the sign "Many past visitors have removed the petrified wood from the park, changing the state of the Petrified Forest", and 5 of 300 under the sign "Please don't remove the petrified wood from the park".

(a) Calculate the percentage stolen under each sign, to two decimal places. (b) Identify the type of norm each sign conveys. (c) Explain the difference in theft using the concept of social norms.

3 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Percentage = number stolen ÷ number placed × 100 (use each sign's own total).

  2. Descriptive = what people do; injunctive = what people approve of.

  3. Link each norm's mechanism to the direction of the result, quoting the numbers.

Watch out for

  • Dividing 19 by 300: the descriptive sign had only 240 pieces, because a rainstorm cut one block short.

  • Calling the first sign injunctive because it sounds disapproving. It reports what people did.

Common mistake

A sign that says "most people don't" is still descriptive

Descriptive or injunctive depends on what the message is about, not whether it is positive. "The vast majority of past visitors have left the wood" is descriptive (what people do). "Please leave the wood" is injunctive (what you ought to do). A positive descriptive norm ("most households in your street have cut their power use") can work well; the danger is a descriptive norm that the unwanted behaviour is common.

A council wants fewer people to leave rubbish at a beach. Which sign does Cialdini et al. (2006) suggest would be least effective?

Choose one answer

Exam tip

Explaining "how it leads to behaviour change"

Name the process, the mechanism and the change: "The sign conveyed a descriptive norm that many visitors take wood. Descriptive norms guide behaviour by showing what is common and therefore acceptable, so visitors who saw it were more likely to take wood themselves: 7.92% of pieces were stolen, compared with 1.67% under the injunctive sign."

Summary

  • Obedience: behaviour change in response to a direct instruction from an authority with legitimate power; people shift responsibility to the authority (the agentic state).

  • Conformity: behaviour change to match a group without any instruction, through normative influence (to be accepted) or informational influence (believing the group is right).

  • Descriptive norms are what people do; injunctive norms are what people approve of. A norm changes behaviour when it is in focus.

  • Cialdini et al. (2006): 2 × 2 field experiment with 2655 park visitors; theft was 7.92% under a negative descriptive sign and 1.67% under a negative injunctive sign.

  • To reduce a common undesirable behaviour, stress that it is disapproved of, and do not say that many people do it.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 4 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account