Lesson 2 of 8 · 18 min
Gender and theories of gender role formation
Describe gender, and compare the social learning, cognitive developmental and biological theories of how gender roles form, with the evidence for each and how they combine.
What you will be able to do
- Describe sex, gender, gender identity and gender roles, and how gender roles differ across cultures and over time.
- Explain how social learning theory, Kohlberg's cognitive developmental theory and biological theory each account for gender role formation.
- Compare the three theories by their cause, the role of the child, timing and evidence.
- Explore the relative contributions of biological, cognitive and social factors to gender role formation.
By the age of three, many children already have firm views about which toys, clothes and games are "for girls" and "for boys", often firmer than their parents'. Where do those ideas come from? Three theories give different answers, and the syllabus asks you to compare them.
First, the terms. They are easy to blur, and exam answers lose marks when they do.
Definition
Sex, gender and gender roles
Sex refers to biological characteristics (chromosomes, hormones and reproductive anatomy) used to classify a person as female, male or intersex.
Gender refers to the social and cultural roles, behaviours, expressions and identities a society associates with being a woman, a man or another gender. Gender identity is a person's internal sense of their own gender, which may or may not match the sex they were assigned at birth; some people are non-binary.
A gender role is the set of behaviours, attitudes and activities a society considers appropriate for people of a particular gender. A gender stereotype is an oversimplified belief that all members of a gender share certain traits.
Gender roles are not fixed. They differ between cultures and change over time: occupations once seen in Australia as suited to one gender, such as nursing, medicine, engineering and policing, are now held by people of every gender. That variation is itself evidence about where gender roles come from, as you will see.
Gender role formation is how a child comes to understand, adopt and act out the gender roles of their society.
1. Social learning theory (Bandura; Mischel) says gender roles are learnt from the environment, like any other behaviour. You met the mechanisms in Unit 3:
- Modelling (observation and imitation). Children watch models (parents, siblings, peers, teachers, characters in the media) and imitate them, especially models they see as similar to themselves or as powerful.
- Direct reinforcement and punishment. Adults and peers praise or smile at behaviour they see as gender-appropriate and discourage behaviour they see as not ("Boys don't cry", or teasing for the "wrong" toy).
- Vicarious conditioning. Children see others rewarded or punished for gender-typed behaviour and adjust their own.
In this theory the child is fairly passive: gender roles take the shape of whatever the environment models and rewards. Evidence: observational studies find parents and peers react more positively to toddlers' gender-typical play than to cross-gender play. In Bandura's Bobo doll research, boys imitated the model's aggression more than girls did, until children were offered a reward for imitating, when the difference shrank: girls had learnt the behaviour but did not perform it, consistent with expectations about what was acceptable for them.
2. Cognitive developmental theory (Kohlberg, 1966) says gender roles form as the child's thinking matures. The child is active: they work out what gender is, then seek out and copy behaviour that fits their own gender. Kohlberg described three stages.
Kohlberg's stages of gender understanding. The ages are approximate.
- Gender identity (about 2–3 years): the child can label themselves and others as a boy or a girl, but may think this could change ("When I grow up I'll be a mummy," says a boy).
- Gender stability (about 3–5 years): the child understands gender stays the same over time, but may think it changes if a person's appearance or activities change (a man with long hair might be "a lady").
- Gender constancy (about 6–7 years): the child understands that gender stays the same across time and situations, whatever the person wears or does.
Kohlberg argued that only once a child reaches constancy do they actively attend to same-gender models and adopt gender-typed behaviour: they socialise themselves. Evidence: Slaby and Frey (1975) found that preschool children further along in gender constancy spent more time watching a same-gender adult on film. Against: children prefer gender-typed toys by about age 2, years before constancy, so constancy cannot be needed for gender-typed behaviour. Gender schema theory (Martin and Halverson, 1981) keeps the idea of an active child but says a basic gender identity is enough to start organising the world into "for boys" and "for girls".
Put the stages of Kohlberg's cognitive developmental theory in the order children reach them.
3. Biological theory says gender roles arise from biological sex differences:
- Chromosomes. Typically XX or XY; genes on the Y chromosome trigger the development of testes.
- Hormones. Before birth, androgens such as testosterone (higher on average in XY fetuses) are thought to organise the developing brain in ways that later influence behaviour; at puberty hormones activate further changes.
- The brain. Some average differences between groups in brain structure and function are described, though they are small and overlap a great deal.
- Evolution. Some researchers argue that average differences in behaviour evolved because they helped ancestors survive and reproduce.
Evidence: girls with congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH), a condition that exposes a fetus to higher levels of androgens, on average play more with toys more often chosen by boys than other girls do (Berenbaum and Hines, 1992), and a later study found this even though their parents encouraged typically feminine play (Pasterski et al., 2005). Against: biology cannot explain why gender roles differ so much between cultures and change within a generation, and most evidence is correlational; girls with CAH may also be treated differently by others.
Each finding supports one theory of gender role formation. Match each to the theory it supports most directly.
| Point of comparison | Social learning | Cognitive developmental | Biological |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main cause | The environment: models and reinforcement | The child's developing understanding of gender | Chromosomes, hormones, brain differences |
| Role of the child | Mostly passive: learns what is modelled and rewarded | Active: seeks out information that fits their gender | Little: predispositions are set before birth |
| When roles appear | As soon as models and rewards are present | Mainly after gender constancy (about 6–7 years) | Predispositions present from birth; activated at puberty |
| Explains cultural variation | Yes: different models and rewards give different roles | Partly: children adopt whatever their culture links to gender | Poorly: biology is similar across cultures |
| Key evidence | Reinforcement of gender-typed play; Bobo doll | Slaby and Frey (1975) | CAH studies (Berenbaum and Hines, 1992) |
| Main limitation | Underplays the child's own role; why children ignore some models | Gender-typed preferences appear before constancy | Cannot explain change over time; correlational |
Key idea
The theories are not rivals in every way
Similarity: social learning and cognitive developmental theory both agree that children learn the content of gender roles from their society; they disagree about whether the child is passive or active. Both disagree with a purely biological account, which locates the cause inside the body.
Most psychologists today take an interactionist view. Biology may give small average predispositions, social learning supplies the content of a culture's roles, and the child's developing thinking organises and applies it. The large differences between cultures and the speed at which roles change across generations suggest that social and cognitive factors contribute most to the form gender roles take.
Worked example
Compare social learning and cognitive developmental theories of gender role formation
Compare the social learning theory and the cognitive developmental theory of gender role formation. (4 marks)
Step 1: Plan by points of comparison
Choose points that both theories address: the cause of gender roles, the role of the child, when gender-typed behaviour appears, and the evidence.
"Compare" means similarities and differences, so each sentence should mention both theories.
Step 2: A similarity
Both theories agree that children learn the content of gender roles from their social environment (what their culture links to being a girl or a boy), so both can explain why gender roles differ between cultures.
Step 3: Difference 1, the role of the child
Social learning theory sees the child as largely passive: gender roles are shaped by modelling and by direct and vicarious reinforcement. Cognitive developmental theory sees the child as active: once they understand gender, they seek out and copy same-gender models themselves.
Step 4: Difference 2, timing
Social learning theory predicts gender-typed behaviour as soon as models and rewards are present. Kohlberg's theory says children attend to same-gender models mainly after gender constancy, at about 6–7 years, after gender identity and gender stability.
Step 5: Difference 3, evidence
Social learning theory is supported by findings that parents and peers reinforce gender-typical play. Cognitive developmental theory is supported by Slaby and Frey (1975), but challenged by gender-typed toy preferences at about age 2, well before constancy.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Both theories hold that children learn the content of gender roles from their society. They differ in that social learning theory sees the child as passive, shaped by modelling and reinforcement from the start, whereas cognitive developmental theory sees the child as active, seeking same-gender models after reaching gender constancy (about 6–7 years). Reinforcement of gender-typed play supports the first; Slaby and Frey (1975) supports the second, though gender-typed preferences before constancy challenge it.
Method
Pick two to four points of comparison.
Give a similarity.
For each difference, write one sentence covering both theories, linked by whereas.
Support with evidence where you can.
Watch out for
Writing a paragraph on each theory with no comparison.
Getting Kohlberg's order wrong: identity, then stability, then constancy.
Common mistake
Comparing means side by side
Three paragraphs, one per theory, is a description, not a comparison. Write point by point: "Social learning theory sees the child as passive, whereas cognitive developmental theory sees the child as actively seeking out gender information." Each sentence should mention at least two theories.
Five-year-old Noah tells his dad that his friend will "turn into a girl" if he wears his sister's dress to the dress-up party. According to Kohlberg, which stage is Noah most likely in?
Summary
Sex is biological; gender is the social and cultural roles, behaviours and identities linked to being a woman, a man or another gender; a gender role is what a society expects of a gender.
Social learning theory: gender roles are learnt by modelling, direct reinforcement and vicarious conditioning; the child is mostly passive.
Cognitive developmental theory (Kohlberg): gender identity → gender stability → gender constancy; after constancy the active child seeks same-gender models.
Biological theory: chromosomes, prenatal and pubertal hormones and brain differences; evidence from CAH studies.
Compare point by point: cause, role of the child, timing, cultural variation, evidence and limitations.
Gender role formation reflects biological, cognitive and social factors interacting; cultural variation and change over time point to a large social contribution.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.