Lesson 3 of 8 · 18 min
Group influence, status, roles and power
Describe how groups influence behaviour through compliance, identification and internalisation, and how status, roles and power shape what people do in groups.
What you will be able to do
- Describe how the presence of others affects behaviour.
- Describe compliance, identification and internalisation (Kelman) and classify a change in behaviour as one of them.
- Describe status, social roles and the bases of power.
- Describe the effect of status, roles and power on social behaviour.
One of the first experiments in social psychology was about bicycles. Norman Triplett (1898) noticed that cyclists rode faster when racing others than when riding alone against the clock, and then found that children wound fishing reels faster when another child was winding beside them. Later research refined this into social facilitation: the presence of others tends to improve performance on simple or well-practised tasks and to worsen it on complex or new ones (Zajonc, 1965). You may have felt both: a practised free throw goes better with a crowd, a new piano piece worse.
Simply being watched changes behaviour. Being part of a group, two or more people who interact, share some goals or identity and influence one another, changes it more.
Definition
Group social influence
Group social influence is the change in a person's thoughts, feelings or behaviour that results from belonging to, or wanting to belong to, a group. Kelman (1958) described three processes by which it happens: compliance, identification and internalisation. They differ in why the person changes and how deep and lasting the change is.
Compliance is a public change without a private one. The person goes along with the group to gain a reward (approval, a place on the team) or to avoid a punishment (ridicule, a detention), while privately disagreeing. Because it depends on the group seeing, it usually stops when the group is not watching.
Identification is adopting a group's or a person's behaviour or attitudes because you value the relationship and want to be like them or accepted by them. The change is real, in public and in private, but it is tied to the relationship: if the group stops mattering to you, the behaviour may fade.
Internalisation is accepting the behaviour or belief because it fits your own values. You would keep doing it if the group disappeared, because it is now yours. It is the deepest and longest-lasting kind of influence.
| Feature | Compliance | Identification | Internalisation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Why the person changes | To gain a reward or avoid a punishment from the group | To be like, or accepted by, a group or person they value | The behaviour or belief fits their own values |
| Public or private | Public only: private views unchanged | Public and private | Public and private |
| Needs the group present? | Yes: depends on being seen | No, but depends on the relationship | No |
| How long it lasts | While the group is watching | While the group or person matters | Long-lasting |
For each scenario, ask: would the behaviour continue if no one was watching, and is it tied to a group the person wants to belong to?
Priya joins her school's rowing squad and starts getting up at 5 am because the senior rowers she admires all do. A year later she has left the squad, and has also stopped getting up early. Which process of group social influence best explains her early starts?
Worked example
Classify behaviour change as compliance, identification or internalisation
Three students join a school environment club.
- Josh recycles at school because the club captain checks the bins and announces who forgot. At home he throws everything in one bin.
- Amira starts carrying a reusable bottle because the older club members she looks up to all do. She stops when she leaves the club the next year.
- Ben learns how much plastic ends up in the ocean, decides it matters, and still avoids single-use plastic years after the club has ended.
Identify the process of group social influence each student shows, and justify each answer. (3 marks)
Step 1: Josh
He recycles only where the group can see and punish him, and privately does not bother: compliance, a public change without a private one.
Step 2: Amira
She adopts the behaviour to be like members she admires, and it ends when the relationship ends: identification.
The behaviour is real while she belongs, unlike Josh's, but it depends on the group.
Step 3: Ben
He accepts the behaviour because it fits his own values, and it lasts without the group: internalisation.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Josh: compliance (public behaviour to avoid disapproval, not kept up in private). Amira: identification (adopted to be like valued members; ends with the relationship). Ben: internalisation (fits his own values; lasts without the group).
Method
Ask: does it continue when the group cannot see? If not, compliance.
If it does, ask: is it tied to the group (identification) or to the person's own values (internalisation)?
Quote the evidence from the scenario for each.
Watch out for
Calling Amira's change internalisation because she did it in private too. It ended with the relationship, which marks identification.
Tip
The "nobody watching" test
To classify a scenario, ask two questions. Would it continue if no one from the group could see? If not, it is compliance. If it would, is it because of the group or because of the person's own values? Because of the group (wanting to belong, admiring them) is identification; because of their own values is internalisation.
Every group has a structure: some members count for more, some jobs come with expectations, and some people can make others act. The syllabus names these as status, roles and power.
Status is a person's position or rank in a group or society, and the respect and importance that go with it. Some status is ascribed (given, such as age or family) and some is achieved (earned, such as captain, doctor or prefect). High-status members are listened to more, talk more, are interrupted less and have more influence on group decisions, and others tend to defer to them. Symbols of status (a title, a uniform, a corner office) cue that deference.
A social role is the set of behaviours expected of a person who holds a position: a teacher, a captain, a nurse, a guard. Roles make groups predictable, because everyone knows what to expect of each other. They also change the people who hold them: people adjust their behaviour, and sometimes their attitudes, to fit the role's expectations. Holding two roles whose expectations clash (a student who is also a part-time worker during exam week) is role conflict.
Power is the ability to influence or control the behaviour of others. French and Raven (1959) described five bases of power, the sources it comes from:
| Base | Where it comes from | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Legitimate | A position or role that others accept gives the right to give instructions | A principal, a police officer, a referee |
| Reward | Control over things others want | A manager who sets shifts and bonuses |
| Coercive | The ability to punish | A coach who can drop a player from the team |
| Expert | Knowledge or skill others need | A doctor advising on treatment |
| Referent | Being liked, admired or identified with | A popular senior student or an influencer |
The effect on social behaviour. Power lets the powerful set the group's agenda and makes others more likely to obey and comply. Legitimate power is the basis of the obedience you will meet in Milgram's study. Power without checks can be abused: holders of power may pay less attention to the views and suffering of those without it, and those with little power may feel they cannot refuse. Status, roles and power usually go together: a role brings status and power with it, which is why the uniform and the title matter so much in the studies of obedience and of the Stanford Prison Experiment later in this topic.
Identify the base of power each person is using.
Worked example
Describe the effect of status, roles and power in a hospital ward
On a hospital ward, a senior surgeon prescribes a dose of medication that a graduate nurse thinks is too high. The nurse has been told in training to question unsafe orders, but says nothing and gives the dose. Later she says, "He's the consultant. It's not my place."
Describe how status, roles and power affected the nurse's behaviour. (4 marks)
Step 1: Status
The surgeon has high status (senior rank, expertise, respect), and the graduate nurse low status. People defer to high-status members and are reluctant to contradict them.
Step 2: Roles
The nurse's role as a junior member of the team carries an expectation of following doctors' orders. "It's not my place" shows she acted to fit that role, even though her training role also expected her to question unsafe orders: a role conflict she resolved in favour of deference.
Step 3: Power
The surgeon holds legitimate power (the position to give orders) and expert power (specialist knowledge), and possibly reward and coercive power over the nurse's career. Power makes others more likely to obey.
Step 4: Link to the behaviour
Together these made the nurse obey an order she believed was wrong instead of acting on her own judgement.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
The surgeon's high status and the nurse's junior role created an expectation that she would defer; the surgeon's legitimate and expert power made her obey. As a result she followed an order she believed was unsafe instead of questioning it.
Method
Take status, roles and power in turn.
For each, say what it is in this scenario and how it affected behaviour.
Finish with the overall effect on behaviour.
Watch out for
Defining the three terms without linking any of them to what the nurse did.
Exam tip
Describe the effect, not just the term
"Describe the effect of status, roles and power on social behaviour" wants what happens to behaviour. Define the term, then give the effect with an example: "Roles carry expectations about how the role-holder should act, so people change their behaviour to fit them; for example, a student made a prefect starts reminding others of the rules."
Summary
The presence of others changes behaviour: social facilitation improves performance on simple tasks and worsens it on complex ones.
Compliance: public change to gain rewards or avoid punishment, private views unchanged; lasts while watched.
Identification: change to be like or accepted by a valued group or person; lasts while the relationship matters.
Internalisation: acceptance because it fits your own values; public and private, long-lasting.
Status is rank and respect in a group; high-status members have more influence and are deferred to.
Roles carry expected behaviours, and people change their behaviour to fit them.
Power (legitimate, reward, coercive, expert, referent) lets people control others' behaviour; unchecked, it can be abused.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.