Lesson 3: Group influence, status, roles and power
Describe the effect of status, roles and power in a hospital ward
SkillStatus, roles and power
Worked example
On a hospital ward, a senior surgeon prescribes a dose of medication that a graduate nurse thinks is too high. The nurse has been told in training to question unsafe orders, but says nothing and gives the dose. Later she says, "He's the consultant. It's not my place."
Describe how status, roles and power affected the nurse's behaviour. (4 marks)
Step 1: Status
The surgeon has high status (senior rank, expertise, respect), and the graduate nurse low status. People defer to high-status members and are reluctant to contradict them.
Step 2: Roles
The nurse's role as a junior member of the team carries an expectation of following doctors' orders. "It's not my place" shows she acted to fit that role, even though her training role also expected her to question unsafe orders: a role conflict she resolved in favour of deference.
Step 3: Power
The surgeon holds legitimate power (the position to give orders) and expert power (specialist knowledge), and possibly reward and coercive power over the nurse's career. Power makes others more likely to obey.
Step 4: Link to the behaviour
Together these made the nurse obey an order she believed was wrong instead of acting on her own judgement.
Answer
The surgeon's high status and the nurse's junior role created an expectation that she would defer; the surgeon's legitimate and expert power made her obey. As a result she followed an order she believed was unsafe instead of questioning it.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Take status, roles and power in turn.
For each, say what it is in this scenario and how it affected behaviour.
Finish with the overall effect on behaviour.
Watch out for
Defining the three terms without linking any of them to what the nurse did.