Lesson 4: Obedience, conformity and social norms
Interpret the Petrified Forest signs
SkillsObedience, conformity and normsAnalysing social psychology data
Worked example
In Cialdini et al. (2006), 19 of 240 marked pieces of wood were stolen under the sign "Many past visitors have removed the petrified wood from the park, changing the state of the Petrified Forest", and 5 of 300 under the sign "Please don't remove the petrified wood from the park".
(a) Calculate the percentage stolen under each sign, to two decimal places. (b) Identify the type of norm each sign conveys. (c) Explain the difference in theft using the concept of social norms.
Step 1: (a) Calculate the percentages
and .
Step 2: (b) Identify the norms
The first sign describes what many people do: a descriptive norm (that theft is common). The second says what is approved: an injunctive norm (that theft is disapproved of).
Step 3: (c) Explain the difference
Descriptive norms guide behaviour by example: telling visitors that many others take wood suggests taking wood is normal, so more did (7.92%). Injunctive norms guide behaviour through social approval and disapproval: stressing that theft is disapproved of discouraged it (1.67%). Theft under the descriptive sign was nearly five times as high.
.
Answer
(a) 7.92% and 1.67%. (b) Descriptive norm (many people steal); injunctive norm (theft is disapproved of). (c) The descriptive sign normalised theft, so more visitors stole; the injunctive sign focused visitors on disapproval, so fewer did.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Percentage = number stolen ÷ number placed × 100 (use each sign's own total).
Descriptive = what people do; injunctive = what people approve of.
Link each norm's mechanism to the direction of the result, quoting the numbers.
Watch out for
Dividing 19 by 300: the descriptive sign had only 240 pieces, because a rainstorm cut one block short.
Calling the first sign injunctive because it sounds disapproving. It reports what people did.