Lesson 3: Group influence, status, roles and power
Classify behaviour change as compliance, identification or internalisation
SkillCompliance, identification, internalisation
Worked example
Three students join a school environment club.
- Josh recycles at school because the club captain checks the bins and announces who forgot. At home he throws everything in one bin.
- Amira starts carrying a reusable bottle because the older club members she looks up to all do. She stops when she leaves the club the next year.
- Ben learns how much plastic ends up in the ocean, decides it matters, and still avoids single-use plastic years after the club has ended.
Identify the process of group social influence each student shows, and justify each answer. (3 marks)
Step 1: Josh
He recycles only where the group can see and punish him, and privately does not bother: compliance, a public change without a private one.
Step 2: Amira
She adopts the behaviour to be like members she admires, and it ends when the relationship ends: identification.
The behaviour is real while she belongs, unlike Josh's, but it depends on the group.
Step 3: Ben
He accepts the behaviour because it fits his own values, and it lasts without the group: internalisation.
Answer
Josh: compliance (public behaviour to avoid disapproval, not kept up in private). Amira: identification (adopted to be like valued members; ends with the relationship). Ben: internalisation (fits his own values; lasts without the group).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Ask: does it continue when the group cannot see? If not, compliance.
If it does, ask: is it tied to the group (identification) or to the person's own values (internalisation)?
Quote the evidence from the scenario for each.
Watch out for
Calling Amira's change internalisation because she did it in private too. It ended with the relationship, which marks identification.