Lesson 2: Gender and theories of gender role formation
Compare social learning and cognitive developmental theories of gender role formation
SkillTheories of gender role formation
Worked example
Compare the social learning theory and the cognitive developmental theory of gender role formation. (4 marks)
Step 1: Plan by points of comparison
Choose points that both theories address: the cause of gender roles, the role of the child, when gender-typed behaviour appears, and the evidence.
"Compare" means similarities and differences, so each sentence should mention both theories.
Step 2: A similarity
Both theories agree that children learn the content of gender roles from their social environment (what their culture links to being a girl or a boy), so both can explain why gender roles differ between cultures.
Step 3: Difference 1, the role of the child
Social learning theory sees the child as largely passive: gender roles are shaped by modelling and by direct and vicarious reinforcement. Cognitive developmental theory sees the child as active: once they understand gender, they seek out and copy same-gender models themselves.
Step 4: Difference 2, timing
Social learning theory predicts gender-typed behaviour as soon as models and rewards are present. Kohlberg's theory says children attend to same-gender models mainly after gender constancy, at about 6–7 years, after gender identity and gender stability.
Step 5: Difference 3, evidence
Social learning theory is supported by findings that parents and peers reinforce gender-typical play. Cognitive developmental theory is supported by Slaby and Frey (1975), but challenged by gender-typed toy preferences at about age 2, well before constancy.
Answer
Both theories hold that children learn the content of gender roles from their society. They differ in that social learning theory sees the child as passive, shaped by modelling and reinforcement from the start, whereas cognitive developmental theory sees the child as active, seeking same-gender models after reaching gender constancy (about 6–7 years). Reinforcement of gender-typed play supports the first; Slaby and Frey (1975) supports the second, though gender-typed preferences before constancy challenge it.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Pick two to four points of comparison.
Give a similarity.
For each difference, write one sentence covering both theories, linked by whereas.
Support with evidence where you can.
Watch out for
Writing a paragraph on each theory with no comparison.
Getting Kohlberg's order wrong: identity, then stability, then constancy.