Lesson 5: Asch (1955): conformity
Identify the variables and design in Asch's study
SkillsAsch's conformity researchResearch methods in social psychology
Worked example
In Asch's (1955) main study, participants judged line lengths either alone or after a unanimous group of confederates gave a wrong answer. In one variation he changed the number of confederates from 1 to 15.
(a) Identify the IV and the DV of the main study. (b) Identify the experimental design, and explain why the alone condition was needed. (c) State an operational hypothesis for the majority-size variation.
Step 1: (a) IV and DV
IV: whether a unanimous majority gave a wrong answer (present or absent). DV: the percentage of critical trials on which the participant gave the majority's wrong answer.
Step 2: (b) Design
Different people were in each condition, so it is independent groups. The alone (control) condition showed that people almost never misjudged the lines on their own (under 1% errors), so the errors in the group condition (36.8%) can be put down to the majority, not to a hard task.
Without a control, high error rates could just mean the lines were hard to judge.
Step 3: (c) Hypothesis
"The percentage of critical trials on which participants agree with a wrong majority will differ according to the number of confederates in the majority (1 to 15)."
Answer
(a) IV: presence of a unanimous wrong majority; DV: percentage of critical trials answered with the majority. (b) Independent groups; the alone condition (under 1% errors) shows the errors were caused by the majority. (c) The percentage of critical trials answered with the majority will differ with majority size (1–15).
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
IV: what the researcher changed. DV: what was measured, operationalised.
Design: are the same or different people in each condition?
A hypothesis names the IV and DV and is testable.
Watch out for
Giving "conformity" as the DV without saying how it was measured.