Lesson 3: Why bystanders hold back
Explain a failure to help with the decision model
SkillWhy bystanders hold back
Worked example
On a crowded train platform at peak hour, a man sits slumped against a pillar. Dozens of commuters walk past. Later, one commuter, Tess, says: "I did see him. I thought he might be drunk or asleep, because nobody else was doing anything. Then I realised he was grey and sweating, but there were so many people around, I figured someone would have called it in. I also didn't want to make a fuss and look silly in front of everyone."
Use Latané and Darley's decision model to explain why Tess did not help.
Step 1: Notice
Tess noticed the man ("I did see him"), so she passed the first step.
Step 2: Interpret
At first she interpreted it as not an emergency because "nobody else was doing anything". That is social influence: she used others' calm as information (pluralistic ignorance).
Step 3: Take responsibility
Once she realised he was unwell (grey and sweating), she assumed "someone would have called it in". That is diffusion of responsibility: with many bystanders she felt little personal responsibility.
Step 4: Audience inhibition
She "didn't want to make a fuss and look silly in front of everyone": audience inhibition. Not wanting to overreact in front of others kept her calm and waiting. In Latané and Darley's (1969) account this works at the interpret step, alongside social influence; later accounts would say it also held her back from acting.
Step 5: Conclude
Tess was held back at several steps by three processes, each caused by the presence of others: the bystander effect.
Answer
Tess noticed the man, but social influence first stopped her interpreting it as an emergency; once she did, diffusion of responsibility stopped her taking responsibility, and audience inhibition (not wanting to make a fuss in front of everyone) kept her calm and waiting.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Go through the five steps in order.
Quote the detail that shows each step passed or blocked.
Name the process that blocked it.
Watch out for
Calling everything "the bystander effect". Name the specific process at each step.
Putting diffusion of responsibility before she knew it was an emergency.