Lesson 2: Interpreting the bystander research
Test a bystander vignette study with an unpaired t-test
SkillResearch methods and data
Worked example
Twenty Year 12 students were randomly allocated to read one of two versions of a vignette about a cyclist who falls on a footpath, and rated how likely they would be to help (0–100). Illustrative data:
| Condition | n | Mean | SD |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alone | 10 | 79.60 | 8.02 |
| Ten others present | 10 | 63.50 | 7.78 |
(a) State the null hypothesis. (b) An unpaired t-test gives , . Draw a conclusion. (c) Identify one limitation of the study.
Step 1: (a) Null hypothesis
There will be no difference in the mean likelihood-of-helping rating between students who read the alone vignette and students who read the vignette with ten others present.
Step 2: Check the test suits the design
Each student read one vignette (independent groups), so the scores are unpaired: an unpaired t-test with .
Step 3: (b) Compare p with 0.05
, so the difference is statistically significant and the null hypothesis is rejected.
Step 4: (b) State the conclusion in context
Students who imagined being alone rated themselves significantly more likely to help (mean 79.60) than those who imagined ten others present (mean 63.50), a difference of 16.10 points. This supports the bystander effect on helping intentions.
Step 5: (c) Limitation
A vignette measures what students say they would do, not what they actually do, so ecological validity is low. The sample (20 students from one school) is also small and not representative.
Answer
(a) No difference in mean ratings between the two vignettes. (b) : reject the null; the alone group rated helping significantly more likely (79.60 vs 63.50). (c) It measures intentions, not behaviour (low ecological validity); small convenience sample.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Match the test to the design (independent groups → unpaired).
Compare with 0.05 and decide about the null hypothesis.
State the conclusion with the means, in the study's terms.
Give a limitation specific to the study.
Watch out for
Saying the result "proves" the bystander effect. A significant result supports a hypothesis; it does not prove it, and a type I error is possible.
Using a paired test for independent groups.