Lesson 4: Groupthink
Identify groupthink in a group's decision
SkillGroupthink
Worked example
The four founders of a small app company have worked together for years and are close friends. Their investors want the app launched before a big trade show in two weeks. At a meeting, the chief executive says, "We've never missed a launch and we're not starting now." The tester, Dev, has found serious bugs, but the chief executive's deputy decides not to forward Dev's report "so it doesn't kill the mood". When the designer asks whether they should delay, the others tell her to stop being negative. Nobody else raises a concern, and the chief executive says, "Great, we're all agreed."
(a) Identify two conditions that made groupthink likely. (b) Identify four symptoms of groupthink, with evidence. (c) Suggest two ways the group could have avoided it.
Step 1: (a) Conditions
High cohesiveness: close friends who have worked together for years. Stress and time pressure: investors demanding a launch in two weeks. (A directive leader who states a view early is a third.)
Step 2: (b) Symptoms
"We've never missed a launch": illusion of invulnerability. The deputy holding back Dev's report: self-appointed mindguard. Telling the designer to stop being negative: direct pressure on dissenters. "We're all agreed" when others said nothing: illusion of unanimity (and others staying silent is self-censorship).
Step 3: (c) Prevention
The chief executive could hold back their view until others have spoken, and the group could appoint a devil's advocate or ask the tester to present findings directly; a second-chance meeting before deciding would let doubts surface.
Answer
(a) High cohesiveness; external pressure and a deadline. (b) Illusion of invulnerability, mindguard, direct pressure on dissenters, illusion of unanimity (also self-censorship). (c) Leader speaks last, devil's advocate, outside or expert input (Dev's report), second-chance meeting.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Look for the conditions (cohesion, insulation, directive leader, stress).
Match each quoted behaviour to one of the eight symptoms.
Suggest remedies that target the symptoms you found.
Watch out for
Listing symptoms without quoting the evidence for each.
Calling the deputy's action self-censorship. Hiding someone else's information from the group is mindguarding.