Lesson 4: Social identity theory
Apply social identity theory to a rivalry
SkillSocial identity theory
Worked example
Two surf lifesaving clubs, Point Danvers and Coral Reach, patrol neighbouring beaches. At the annual carnival, Point Danvers members wear their red caps everywhere, sing their club song, and tell new members that Coral Reach "only wins because they cheat at the start".
Explain the Point Danvers members' behaviour using social identity theory.
Step 1: Social categorisation
Members sort the people at the carnival into groups: Point Danvers (the in-group) and Coral Reach (an out-group). They categorise themselves as Point Danvers members.
Step 2: Social identification
They take on the club's identity and norms: the red caps and the club song show it. Their self-esteem is now tied to how the club is seen and how it performs.
Step 3: Social comparison
To keep their self-esteem high, they compare their club favourably with Coral Reach. Explaining Coral Reach's wins by cheating keeps Point Danvers looking better: in-group favouritism (positive distinctiveness).
Step 4: Link to the outcome
The comparison is biased in favour of their own group, and passing it on to new members spreads a negative view of the out-group, which can grow into prejudice.
Answer
Categorisation: members divide people into Point Danvers and Coral Reach and see themselves as Point Danvers. Identification: they adopt the club's identity and norms (caps, song), so their self-esteem depends on the club. Comparison: to protect that self-esteem they compare their club favourably with Coral Reach, dismissing its wins as cheating: in-group favouritism.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Social categorisation: who is in-group and out-group?
Social identification: what shows they have adopted the group's identity and norms?
Social comparison: how do they make their group look better, and why (self-esteem)?
Watch out for
Leaving out self-esteem. It is the reason comparison favours the in-group.