Lesson 3: Cognitive dissonance
Explain why $1 changed attitudes more than $20
SkillCognitive dissonance
Worked example
In Festinger & Carlsmith (1959), students did an hour of boring tasks, then were paid either $1 or $20 to tell the next participant that the tasks were enjoyable. A control group told no one anything. All then rated how enjoyable the tasks were, from −5 to +5.
| Condition | Mean rating |
|---|---|
| Control | −0.45 |
| $1 | +1.35 |
| $20 | −0.05 |
(a) Describe the pattern in the results. (b) Explain the results using cognitive dissonance theory. (c) Explain how the results challenged the predictions of learning theory.
Step 1: (a) Describe the pattern
The $1 group rated the tasks as most enjoyable (+1.35), well above the control group (−0.45). The $20 group (−0.05) was close to the control group.
Step 2: (b) Identify the dissonance
Participants who told the next person the tasks were enjoyable held two inconsistent cognitions: "the tasks were boring" and "I told someone they were fun". This caused dissonance.
Step 3: (b) Explain the difference between $1 and $20
$20 was a large reward in 1959, enough external justification for the lie ("I did it for the money"), so little dissonance remained. $1 was insufficient justification, so the dissonance stayed. The behaviour could not be undone, so the $1 group changed the cognition easiest to change: they came to rate the tasks as more enjoyable.
People reduce dissonance by changing whichever cognition is least resistant to change.
Step 4: (c) Learning theory's prediction
Learning theory, through reinforcement, predicts that a larger reward strengthens a response more, so the $20 group should have come to believe the tasks were enjoyable most.
Step 5: (c) The challenge
The opposite happened: the smaller reward produced more attitude change. A cognitive process, the drive to reduce dissonance, explained the result where a stimulus–response account could not.
Answer
(a) $1 group most positive (+1.35); $20 group (−0.05) close to control (−0.45). (b) Lying caused dissonance; $20 justified it but $1 did not, so the $1 group reduced dissonance by changing their attitude to the tasks. (c) Reinforcement predicts more change with a bigger reward; the result was the reverse, supporting a cognitive explanation.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Describe the data with the numbers.
Name the two inconsistent cognitions.
Explain justification (sufficient or insufficient) and which cognition changed.
State learning theory's prediction and show the data contradict it.
Watch out for
Saying the $20 group enjoyed it more because they were paid more: that is learning theory's prediction, and it was wrong.