Lesson 5: Attributions and the fundamental attribution error
Classify attributions and spot the FAE
SkillAttributions and the FAE
Worked example
Mr Tran's Year 12 student, Isla, scored 42% on a chemistry test. Four people explain why.
- Mr Tran: "Isla just isn't very good at chemistry."
- Isla's friend: "She was looking after her younger brother all week while her mum was in hospital."
- Isla's classmate: "She's lazy; she never studies."
- Isla's tutor: "The test covered the two lessons she missed while she was at the regional athletics."
(a) Classify each explanation as situational or dispositional. (b) Mr Tran and the classmate did not know about the week at home or the missed lessons. Explain which explanations could show the fundamental attribution error.
Step 1: (a) Classify each explanation
1 ability, inside Isla: dispositional. 2 caring for her brother, outside her: situational. 3 laziness, a trait: dispositional. 4 missed lessons, outside her: situational.
Step 2: (b) Recall the FAE
The FAE is overestimating dispositional and underestimating situational causes of another person's behaviour.
Step 3: (b) Apply it
Mr Tran and the classmate explain Isla's result by her traits (ability, laziness), while real situational causes (a week as a carer, missed lessons) went unnoticed. Explanations 1 and 3 could show the FAE.
Answer
(a) 1 dispositional, 2 situational, 3 dispositional, 4 situational. (b) Explanations 1 and 3: they explain another person's behaviour by her dispositions while overlooking situational causes, which is the fundamental attribution error.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Inside the person (ability, effort, personality, attitude) → dispositional.
Outside the person (task, events, other people, luck) → situational.
FAE: a dispositional explanation of someone else that ignores a situational cause.
Watch out for
Saying explanation 2 is the FAE. The FAE is the error of ignoring the situation, not of noticing it.