Lesson 3: Cognitive dissonance
Identify dissonance and how it is reduced
SkillCognitive dissonance
Worked example
Noah is captain of his school's environment club and believes that flying is bad for the climate. His family has booked an overseas holiday by plane.
(a) Identify the two inconsistent cognitions. (b) Describe what cognitive dissonance theory predicts Noah will experience. (c) For each response, name the strategy Noah is using to reduce dissonance:
- "Planes fly whether I'm on them or not."
- "I'll plant 20 trees when we get back to make up for it."
- Noah asks to stay with his grandparents instead.
Step 1: (a) The two cognitions
"Flying is bad for the climate" (an attitude) and "I am going to fly overseas" (knowledge of his own behaviour). They are inconsistent.
Step 2: (b) The prediction
The inconsistency causes dissonance, an unpleasant psychological discomfort, and a drive to reduce it. Because the environment matters a lot to Noah (he is the club captain), the dissonance will be strong.
Step 3: (c1) "Planes fly whether I'm on them or not"
He keeps his belief but makes his own part seem unimportant: reducing the importance of the conflict.
Step 4: (c2) Planting trees
A new thought that justifies the behaviour: adding a consonant cognition.
Step 5: (c3) Staying with his grandparents
He brings his behaviour into line with his attitude: changing the behaviour.
Answer
(a) "Flying is bad for the climate" and "I am going to fly". (b) Psychological discomfort (dissonance), strong because the belief is important to him, and a drive to reduce it. (c) 1 reducing the importance; 2 adding a consonant cognition; 3 changing the behaviour.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Name the attitude and the behaviour (or the two beliefs) that conflict.
State that the inconsistency causes discomfort and a drive to reduce it.
Match each response to a strategy: change behaviour, change a cognition, add consonant cognitions, reduce importance.
Watch out for
Calling response 1 "changing his attitude". He still believes flying is bad for the climate; he has only made his own part seem small.