Lesson 5: Attributions and the fundamental attribution error
Explain the quizmaster study with the FAE
SkillAttributions and the FAE
Worked example
In Ross, Amabile & Steinmetz (1977), pairs of students were randomly assigned, in front of each other, to be the questioner or the contestant in a quiz. Questioners wrote ten difficult questions from their own knowledge. Afterwards, contestants rated the questioners' general knowledge as much higher than their own.
(a) Explain the contestants' ratings using the fundamental attribution error. (b) Explain how this kind of attribution could influence how people respond to others in everyday life.
Step 1: (a) Identify the situational cause
The questioner's role gave a large advantage: they chose questions from their own areas of knowledge, which the contestant was unlikely to know. The roles were decided by chance, and both knew it.
Step 2: (a) Identify the dispositional attribution
Contestants explained the questioners' apparent brilliance by a disposition: being more knowledgeable.
Step 3: (a) Name the error
They underestimated the situational cause (the role) and overestimated the dispositional one (knowledge). That is the fundamental attribution error.
Step 4: (b) Link attributions to responses
We respond to people according to the cause we attribute. Someone who seems knowledgeable only because of their role (a host, an interviewer, a teacher setting questions) may be trusted, promoted or deferred to more than they deserve, while a person put on the spot may be judged less capable than they are.
Answer
(a) Contestants attributed the questioners' performance to greater knowledge (dispositional) and failed to allow for the advantage of the randomly assigned role (situational): the fundamental attribution error. (b) Because attributions shape responses, people in advantaged roles may be judged more capable and treated with more respect, and people at a disadvantage judged less capable, than they deserve.
Try a similar one
A fresh question of the same kind, checked as you answer, with hints and a full solution.
Method
Identify the situational factor that explains the behaviour.
Identify the dispositional explanation that was made instead.
Name the FAE and link the attribution to how people respond.
Watch out for
Saying the questioners really were more knowledgeable. The roles were random, so the two groups did not differ in knowledge on average.