Lesson 8 of 8 · 20 min

Culture and perception

Describe how culture influences visual and auditory perception, from Hudson (1960) and Deregowski (1972) to de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018) and studies of music, and evaluate the research designs.

What you will be able to do

  • Describe the aims, methods, results and conclusions of Hudson (1960), Deregowski (1972) and de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018).
  • Describe how culture shapes the perception of music (Patel and Demorest 2013; Morrison and Demorest 2009).
  • Explain how later researchers modified and replicated the seminal studies.
  • Evaluate cross-cultural studies as quasi-experiments: matching, confounding variables, test materials, reliability and validity.

If perception were only sensation, everyone with healthy eyes and ears would perceive the same picture and the same tune in the same way. But perception also draws on what we have learnt, and what we learn depends on where we grow up. Cross-cultural psychology asks which parts of perception are shared by all people and which are shaped by experience.

A note before the evidence: these studies compare groups' scores on particular tests. They never show that people of one culture "cannot see depth" or "cannot hear music". They show that familiarity with pictures, schooling or a musical tradition makes some tasks easier.

Seminal research on pictures: Hudson (1960)

William Hudson, working in South Africa, wanted to know whether people perceive depth in pictures in the same way regardless of their background. He showed line drawings of a hunting scene to South African children and adults from several cultural groups, with and without schooling.

In each drawing a hunter aims a spear. An antelope stands near him, and an elephant, drawn smaller, appears on a hill in the distance, so that on the page the elephant lies between the hunter and the antelope. Some drawings added interposition (overlap) or linear perspective (a road running to the horizon). Participants were asked "What is the man doing?" and "Which animal is closer to the man?"

A drawing in the style of Hudson's depth test (not his original). Reading the picture in depth, the elephant is small because it is far away, and the hunter is aiming at the antelope.

Answers that the hunter was aiming at the antelope, and that the antelope was closer, were scored as three-dimensional (3D) perception: the participant had used the cues to see the elephant as far away. Answers that he was aiming at the elephant, which is nearer to his spear on the flat page, were scored two-dimensional (2D).

Results. Many participants without schooling gave 2D answers; school-going children and adults with more education gave more 3D answers. Conclusion: perceiving depth in pictures is not automatic; it depends partly on experience with pictures and the conventions used to draw them.

Deregowski (1972)

Jan Deregowski reviewed this research and extended it in Scientific American. He argued that pictures are a code that has to be learnt, and reported further tests: participants who gave 2D answers on Hudson-type drawings tended to prefer a split-style drawing of an elephant (showing it as if unfolded, from above and both sides) to a top-view perspective drawing, and copied an "impossible" two-pronged trident readily, while 3D perceivers, who saw it as a puzzling object, took longer. His conclusion: the perception of pictures calls for some form of learning, and drawing conventions that seem natural to one culture are not universal.

Note

Limitations of the seminal studies

  • Test materials: Hudson's drawings are sparse, with few depth cues and no texture gradient, shading or colour; richer pictures produce more 3D answers.
  • Language and testing: questions were asked through interpreters and in an unfamiliar testing situation, so some "2D" answers may reflect the question, not the perception.
  • Quasi-experimental design: cultural groups cannot be randomly allocated, and they differed in schooling, contact with pictures and familiarity with tests, so the cause of any difference is unclear.
  • Terms and attitudes of the time: research from apartheid-era South Africa used group labels that are now offensive, and was sometimes read as showing a deficit rather than a difference in experience.

Replicated and modified: de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018)

Sixty years later, Dutch researchers asked a practical question. In asylum interviews and international criminal cases, people are often asked to recognise objects (a weapon, a building) from photographs. Is that fair to people from cultures with less exposure to pictures?

  • Participants: 46 asylum seekers from Sub-Saharan Africa (most from Eritrea), recruited from four asylum seeker centres in the Netherlands, and 46 Western European (Dutch) participants matched to them on gender, rural or urban background and age. The groups could not be matched on education (the European group had more), so education was controlled statistically.
  • Tests: an adapted version of Hudson's depth test (scored out of 17), a visuospatial test of folding a 2D pattern into a cube (out of 4), and an object recognition test. Participants viewed ten vases on a table for 90 seconds; about 15 minutes later they saw 20 vases (10 old, 10 new) one at a time and said whether each was one they had seen. Within each group, participants were randomly assigned to see the test vases as real objects (3D) or in photographs (2D).
Selected results of de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018)
MeasureSub-Saharan African group (n = 46)Western European group (n = 46)Difference after controlling for education
Hudson-style depth test (max. 17)M = 7.57, SD = 5.51M = 15.89, SD = 2.49Significant (p < 0.001)
Folding 2D patterns into cubes (max. 4)M = 1.63, SD = 1.32M = 3.30, SD = 0.94Significant (p < 0.001)
Recognising real objects from photos or as objectsAbout the same accuracy as the European groupAbout the same accuracyNot significant

Conclusions. The study replicated Hudson's finding: the African group gave far fewer 3D answers on the picture test and found the 2D-to-3D folding task harder. But it modified the picture of what this means. Recognising real objects, including from photographs, was just as accurate in both groups, and everyone was more accurate with real vases (3D) than with photographs (2D). The African participants were more likely to answer "yes" to every vase, a response style the authors suggest interviewers should allow for. Within the African group, those who had owned a television or computer at home recognised the vases more accurately, which fits the idea that experience with screens and pictures matters.

Why is the comparison between the African and European groups in de Bruïne et al. (2018) a quasi-experiment rather than a true experiment?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Evaluate de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018)

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

In de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018), 46 asylum seekers from Sub-Saharan Africa and 46 Dutch participants matched on gender, rural or urban background and age completed an adapted Hudson depth test (maximum 17). The African group scored M=7.57M = 7.57, SD=5.51SD = 5.51; the European group M=15.89M = 15.89, SD=2.49SD = 2.49. The European group had more education, so education was controlled statistically.

(a) Calculate the standard error of the mean for each group. (b) Explain what the difference in standard deviations shows. (c) Evaluate the conclusion that "culture affects the perception of depth in pictures".

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. SE=s÷nSE = s \div \sqrt{n}.

  2. Evaluate with strengths, limitations of the design, and a judgement.

Watch out for

  • Concluding that people from Sub-Saharan Africa cannot perceive depth: the test measured depth in drawings only.

  • Using n−1n - 1 in the standard error: SE=s/nSE = s / \sqrt{n}.

Interactive

Measure an illusion on yourself

Your result stays in your browser and is for learning only. The culture panel summarises the cross-cultural evidence.

Culture and hearing: music perception

The syllabus pairs the visual evidence with auditory perception: the perception of music. Music is found in every known culture, but its scales, rhythms and timbres differ widely, which makes it a natural test of how experience shapes hearing.

Patel and Demorest (2013) reviewed cross-species and cross-cultural studies of music cognition to sort the shared from the learnt. Some capacities appear widely shared, such as grouping sounds into a beat. Others are tuned by enculturation, the largely unconscious learning of one's own culture's music. In one well-known line of studies (Hannon and Trehub 2005), North American six-month-olds noticed a disruption to a rhythm in both a simple Western metre and a complex Balkan metre, but North American adults noticed it only in the Western one, while adults from Bulgaria and Macedonia noticed it in both. Exposure narrows and sharpens what is perceived.

Morrison and Demorest (2009) reviewed research on these cultural constraints on music perception and memory, including their own studies with Turkish and American listeners. Listeners from each culture remembered music from their own culture better than music from the other, and the effect held for listeners with and without musical training. Brain-imaging work by the same group later found differences in brain activity when people listened to culturally familiar and unfamiliar music.

Which finding best supports the claim that culture influences auditory perception?

Choose one answer

Worked example

Describe the effect of culture on music perception

  • Complex familiar

Describe how culture influences auditory perception, using evidence from studies of music. (4 marks)

4 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. Name the process (enculturation), then give evidence with its source.

Watch out for

  • Saying people from other cultures hear different frequencies. Sensation is the same; perception differs.

How the research moved on

The line from Hudson to de Bruïne shows how science works. A seminal finding was replicated with new samples and new tests, and modified as later researchers controlled variables the original could not (matching groups, controlling education statistically, randomly assigning the test format) and asked new questions (does it matter for recognising real objects?). The music studies did the same for hearing, moving from comparing listeners' judgements to measuring memory and brain activity. Each step narrowed what "culture affects perception" means.

Interactive

Variables in a cross-cultural illusion study

A Müller-Lyer study comparing two cultural groups. Notice why there is no IV for the researcher to manipulate.

Exam tip

Describing and evaluating a cultural study

For "describe", give the aim, the participants, what they did, the key results (with numbers where you know them) and the conclusion. For "evaluate", add strengths and limitations of the design: a quasi-experiment can show a difference but not its cause; matching and statistical control reduce, but do not remove, confounding variables; test materials made in one culture may be less valid in another; small subgroups give low power. Finish with a judgement.

Summary

  • Hudson (1960): many participants without schooling gave 2D answers to drawings with depth cues; perceiving depth in pictures depends partly on experience.

  • Deregowski (1972): pictures are a learnt code; split drawings and impossible figures are perceived differently by people with different pictorial experience.

  • de Bruïne, Vredeveldt and van Koppen (2018) replicated the picture-depth difference in matched groups, but found equal accuracy in recognising real objects from photographs.

  • Patel and Demorest (2013) and Morrison and Demorest (2009): enculturation shapes the perception of rhythm and memory for music; people remember their own culture's music better.

  • Cultural comparisons are quasi-experiments: groups differ in many ways, so matching, control of variables and careful test design matter.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 8 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account