Lesson 7 of 8 · 16 min
Visual constancies and illusions
Explain size, shape and brightness constancy, use depth cues and constancy to explain the Müller-Lyer and Ponzo illusions, and measure and analyse illusion strength.
What you will be able to do
- Explain size, shape and brightness constancy and what each depends on.
- Explain the Müller-Lyer and Ponzo illusions with depth cues and size constancy.
- Calculate illusion strength and interpret repeated-measures illusion data.
When a friend walks away from you across the oval, the image of them on your retina shrinks to a fraction of its size. You do not see them shrinking. When a door swings open its image changes from a rectangle to a narrow trapezium, but you still see a rectangular door. Perception holds objects steady while their images change. These are the visual constancies.
Definition
Visual constancy
A visual constancy is the tendency to perceive an object as keeping its size, shape or brightness, even though the image it casts on the retina changes with distance, angle or lighting.
| Constancy | The retinal image changes because… | We still perceive… | The brain uses… |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size constancy | the object moves nearer or further away | the same size | depth cues to judge distance, and knowledge of the object's usual size |
| Shape constancy | we see the object from a different angle | the same shape | depth cues showing the object's tilt, and knowledge of its real shape |
| Brightness constancy | the lighting gets brighter or dimmer | the same brightness (a white page looks white in shade) | the object's brightness compared with its surroundings, which change by the same proportion |
Move the person further away and compare the retinal image with what you perceive. Then hide the context with the reduction screen: without depth cues, size constancy breaks down.
Driving into a tunnel, the yellow line on the road reflects far less light than in the sunshine outside, yet it still looks yellow and bright against the grey road. Which constancy is this mainly an example of?
Visual illusions
A visual illusion is a consistent misperception: everyone sees it, and it persists even when you know it is wrong. Illusions are useful to psychologists because they show the rules perception is following, by catching the brain applying a rule where it does not fit.
The Müller-Lyer illusion. Both shafts are exactly 6 units long.
The Müller-Lyer illusion. Most people see the line with outward fins as clearly longer. One explanation, from Richard Gregory's constructivist approach, is misapplied size constancy. Outward fins resemble the inside corner of a room, where the corner is further away than the walls; inward fins resemble the outside corner of a building, which juts towards you. The brain reads the first shaft as further away, and size constancy scales it up: the same retinal image from something further away must belong to something larger. The drawing is flat, but the depth rule is applied anyway.
The explanation is debated. The illusion still occurs when the fins are replaced by circles, which look nothing like corners, so depth may not be the whole story. Cross-cultural studies suggest experience matters: Segall, Campbell and Herskovits (1966) reported that groups living in environments with fewer straight-edged buildings were, on average, less susceptible to the illusion (the "carpentered world" hypothesis), though later studies have not all agreed.
The Ponzo illusion. The two orange bars are the same length.
The Ponzo illusion. The converging lines are a strong linear perspective cue, like railway tracks running into the distance. The upper bar sits where the "tracks" are closer together, so the brain reads it as further away. Two bars that make the same retinal image, one further away, must differ in size, so size constancy makes the upper bar look longer.
Which explanation of the Ponzo illusion is best?
Measuring an illusion
To study an illusion scientifically you need a number. In the method of adjustment, a participant changes the length of a plain comparison line until it looks equal to the illusion's shaft. The difference from the true length, as a percentage, is the illusion strength:
A participant adjusts a comparison line to 117 mm to match the 100 mm shaft of a Müller-Lyer figure with outward fins. Calculate the illusion strength as a percentage.
Illustrative data: ten students each matched a 100 mm shaft in both versions, in counterbalanced order. Each student did both conditions, so the paired t-test is the right test. Switch to the unpaired test to see what ignoring the design does.
Worked example
Analyse Müller-Lyer illusion data
Eight students each adjusted a comparison line to match the 100 mm shaft of a Müller-Lyer figure, once with fins outward and once with fins inward. Half did the fins-outward version first and half the fins-inward version first.
| Student | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fins outward (mm) | 116 | 121 | 112 | 119 | 124 | 114 | 118 | 120 |
| Fins inward (mm) | 93 | 90 | 95 | 91 | 88 | 94 | 92 | 89 |
(a) Calculate the mean and standard deviation of each condition, to 2 decimal places. (b) Calculate the mean illusion strength for the fins-outward condition. (c) A paired t-test gave , . Draw a conclusion. (d) Identify the design and one control it used.
Step 1: Means
Fins outward: mm. Fins inward: mm.
Step 2: Standard deviations
Fins outward: the squared deviations sum to 106, so mm. Fins inward: they sum to 42, so mm.
Divide by , the sample standard deviation.
Step 3: Illusion strength
: on average the shaft with outward fins was seen as 18% longer than it is.
Step 4: Conclusion from the t-test
, which is less than 0.05, so the difference is statistically significant. Reject the null hypothesis: fin direction affected the perceived length of the shaft, with outward fins seen as longer (mean 118.00 mm against 91.50 mm).
Step 5: Design and control
Every student did both conditions, so it is a repeated-measures design (hence the paired t-test). Half did each order first: counterbalancing, which controls order effects such as practice.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
(a) Fins outward 118.00 mm (SD 3.89); fins inward 91.50 mm (SD 2.45). (b) 18%. (c) The difference is significant (p < 0.001 < 0.05): outward fins make the shaft look longer. (d) Repeated measures, with counterbalancing.
Method
Mean, then the sample SD (divide by n − 1).
Illusion strength = (matched − true) ÷ true × 100.
Compare p with 0.05, then state the conclusion in terms of the variables.
Watch out for
Using the population SD (dividing by 8): 3.64 mm instead of 3.89 mm.
Concluding "the hypothesis is proven". A significant result supports it; a type I error is still possible.
Worked example
Explain the moon illusion with size constancy
The full moon looks much larger when it is just above the horizon than when it is high in the sky, although photographs show it makes the same-sized image in both places.
Use depth cues and size constancy to propose an explanation, and suggest one way to test it. (4 marks)
Step 1: The retinal image is unchanged
The moon is the same distance away in both positions, so it casts the same-sized retinal image. The difference must come from perception.
Step 2: Depth cues near the horizon
Near the horizon the moon is seen beyond trees, buildings and terrain. Interposition, linear perspective and texture gradient in the landscape tell the brain it is very far away. High in the empty sky there are no such cues.
Step 3: Apply size constancy
With size constancy, an object that makes the same retinal image but is perceived as further away is perceived as larger. So the horizon moon looks bigger: the same rule as the Ponzo illusion.
Step 4: Test it
Remove the depth cues: have participants view the horizon moon through a tube or a hole in a card (a reduction screen) and match its size. If the explanation is right, the illusion should shrink.
Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.
Answer
Depth cues in the landscape make the horizon moon seem further away than the moon overhead; size constancy then makes the same retinal image appear larger. Viewing the horizon moon through a tube, removing the cues, should reduce the illusion.
Method
Rule out sensation: the retinal image is the same.
Name the depth cues present and the constancy that misapplies.
A test removes or adds the proposed cause.
Watch out for
Saying the atmosphere magnifies the moon. Photographs show the image is the same size.
Exam tip
Explaining an illusion
Name the cue or principle the figure contains, say what it leads the brain to infer, then name the constancy or rule that produces the error. "The converging lines are linear perspective, so the top bar is perceived as further away; size constancy then makes it look longer" earns the marks. "It's an optical illusion that tricks the eye" earns none.
Summary
Size, shape and brightness constancy keep an object's perceived size, shape and brightness stable while its retinal image changes.
Constancies rely on depth cues, context and knowledge; when depth cues are removed, size constancy fails.
Illusions are consistent misperceptions that reveal the rules perception uses.
Müller-Lyer: the fins are read as depth cues and size constancy makes the outward-fin shaft look longer (a debated explanation).
Ponzo: linear perspective makes the upper bar seem further away, and size constancy makes it look longer.
Illusion strength = (matched − true) ÷ true × 100; fins-out against fins-in data from the same people call for a paired t-test.
Finished the lesson?
Try the 3 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.