Lesson 8 of 8 · 18 min

Is intelligence inherited or learned?

Discuss the extent to which intelligence is inherited or learned: what heritability means, evidence that environment changes IQ, how genes and environment interact, and the nature–nurture debate.

What you will be able to do

  • Explain what heritability means and what it does not mean.
  • Describe evidence that the environment affects intelligence.
  • Explain how genes and environment interact.
  • Discuss the extent to which intelligence is inherited or learned, within the wider nature–nurture debate.

The last lesson showed that relatives' IQs correlate more closely the more genes they share, and also that sharing a home makes people more alike. So is intelligence inherited or learned? The honest answer is both, and the question needs sharpening. This lesson gives you the tools to say how far, and in what sense.

Definition

Heritability

Heritability is the proportion of the variation in a characteristic, within a particular population at a particular time, that is associated with genetic differences between its members.

Twin and adoption studies estimate the heritability of IQ in adults at roughly 0.5 to 0.8: Bouchard et al. (1990) put it at about 0.7. Three points about what that number means are easy to get wrong.

What heritability does and does not mean

  1. It describes a population, not a person

    A heritability of 0.7 does not mean 70% of your intelligence came from your genes and 30% from your upbringing. It means 70% of the differences between people in that population are associated with their genetic differences.

  2. It depends on the environment

    When everyone's environment is similar, the differences that remain are mostly genetic, so heritability is high. Turkheimer et al. (2003) found that among children in poorer families, where environments differed more and many were limiting, heritability of IQ was close to zero; among children in better-off families it was high.

  3. It does not mean fixed

    Height is highly heritable, yet average height rose across the twentieth century with better nutrition. A characteristic can be highly heritable and still change a great deal with the environment.

Heritability also changes with age. In a study of about 11 000 twin pairs in four countries, Haworth et al. (2010) found it rose through childhood and adolescence.

Heritability of general cognitive ability at three ages (Haworth et al. 2010).

A news article says: "Studies show intelligence is 70% genetic, so your IQ is mostly set at birth." Which response is most accurate?

Choose one answer

Evidence that the environment matters

  • The Flynn effect. Average scores on IQ tests rose about 3 points per decade across the twentieth century in many countries (Flynn 1987). Gene pools cannot change that fast, so the rise must be environmental: more and longer schooling, better nutrition and health, smaller families, and more experience of abstract thinking.
  • Schooling. Each extra year of education raises IQ by about 1 to 5 points (Ritchie & Tucker-Drob 2018).
  • Adoption. Children adopted from disadvantaged circumstances score higher than expected from their birth families, and gain more when adopted into families with more resources (Duyme, Dumaret & Tomkiewicz 1999).
  • Health and nutrition. Iodine deficiency and childhood lead exposure lower IQ; preventing them raises a population's average.

Worked example

Analyse IQ data from an adoption study

  • Complex unfamiliar
  • Technology active

Researchers followed 32 children with similar birth backgrounds who were adopted at about age 5. Sixteen were adopted into families with low socioeconomic status (SES) and sixteen into families with high SES. Their IQs were measured at age 14 (illustrative data).

Adoptive familynMean IQSD
Low SES169212
High SES1610412

(a) Calculate the standard error and the 95% confidence interval for each group's mean. (b) An unpaired t-test gives t=2.83t = 2.83, p=0.008p = 0.008. What can be concluded? (c) Discuss what this study shows about whether intelligence is inherited or learned.

5 steps

Try it yourself first, then check the working one step at a time.

Method

  1. SE=s÷n\text{SE} = s \div \sqrt{n}; 95% CI =xˉ±1.96×SE= \bar{x} \pm 1.96 \times \text{SE}.

  2. Compare p with 0.05.

  3. Ask what differs between the groups: genes, environment or both.

  4. State the limits of the design.

Watch out for

  • Using the SD instead of the SE to build the confidence interval.

  • Concluding intelligence is entirely learned from one adoption study.

Genes and environment interact

Genes and environments are not separate ingredients added together. They work on each other:

  • Gene–environment correlation. Children's genes influence the environments they experience. A child who finds reading easy asks for more books and spends more time reading, which builds vocabulary further. This is one reason heritability rises with age: as children choose more of their own environments, those environments match their genetic tendencies more.
  • Gene–environment interaction. The same genes can have different effects in different environments. A genetic potential for high ability may show only where schooling, nutrition and stimulation let it.

A girl with a strong memory for music joins the school band, practises daily and wins a scholarship to a music school, where her skills grow further. Which idea does this best illustrate?

Choose one answer

The broader nature–nurture debate

Intelligence is one of the oldest battlegrounds of psychology's nature–nurture debate. Francis Galton's Hereditary Genius (1869) argued that ability runs in families because it is inherited. At the other extreme, the behaviourist John Watson (1930) claimed that, given a dozen healthy infants and his own world to raise them in, he could train any one of them to become any kind of specialist he chose.

The debate has had real consequences. In the early twentieth century, claims that intelligence was fixed and inherited were used in the United States to support laws restricting immigration and the forced sterilisation of people labelled "feeble-minded". These are now recognised as serious misuses of science, and they are one reason psychologists today are careful about how claims about the inheritance of intelligence are made and reported.

Key idea

The current view

Psychologists now treat nature and nurture as interacting, not competing. Genes influence intelligence substantially, and their influence grows with age; the environment also changes intelligence substantially, as the Flynn effect, schooling and adoption show; and each shapes how the other acts. The same conclusion runs through the rest of the course, from brain development in Unit 1 to psychological disorders later in this unit.

Exam tip

Discussing "the extent to which"

Weigh both sides with evidence and then judge the extent. Inherited: correlations rise with genes shared; MZA twins correlate 0.69–0.72; heritability about 0.5–0.8 in adults and rising with age. Learned: relatives raised together are more alike than those raised apart; adoption, schooling and the Flynn effect raise IQ; heritability falls where environments are poor. Judgement: intelligence is substantially influenced by both, they interact, and heritability describes populations, not individuals or limits.

Summary

  • Heritability is the proportion of variation in a population associated with genetic differences: about 0.5–0.8 for adult IQ, and lower in childhood.

  • Heritability describes a population, depends on the environment and does not mean a characteristic is fixed.

  • The Flynn effect (about 3 points per decade), schooling, adoption and health show the environment changes intelligence.

  • Genes and environment interact: children's abilities shape the environments they seek, and environments let genetic potential show.

  • The nature–nurture debate ran from Galton and Watson to today's interactionist view; hereditarian claims about IQ were once misused to justify discriminatory laws.

Finished the lesson?

Try the 2 quick checks above and the lesson completes itself, or mark it complete now.

Lesson 8 of 80% read

Save your progress with a free account